Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

What is to be Done?, by Nikolai Chernyshevsky

· No. 32, Summer 1986 · p. 45 of the scan · 967 words

The scan: Militant International Review no32 Summer 1986.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents-titles located in body; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 45]

MIR Summer 1986: Book reviews What is to be done?

By Nikolai Chernyshevsky Published by Virago, 1982 Reviewed by Bill Hopwood What Is To Be Done: is a novel which influenced Russian revolutionaries. Written in 1863 it showed the early tremors of Russian society which culminated in the earthquake which shook the world in 1917.

Nikolai Chernyshevsky, the author, was himself imprisoned for his activities against Czarism. He wrote What Is To Be Done? from the Peter and Paul fortress before he was moved to Siberia where he was exiled for nearly 20 years.

Born in 1828 his outlook was shaped by the European revolution of 1848. In contrast to many of the great Russian novelists he considered himself a materialist, he was influenced by Feurbach, and was more concerned about the town than the countryside. Lenin described him as a 'great Russian socialist'. The title of one of Lenin's critical pamphlets in building of the Bolsheviks What Is To Be Done? is a clear recognition of Chernyshevsky.

Although he died in 1889, before the Russian Social founding Democratic Labour Party, he was part of its pre-history.

Written from prison His words on the future, "Love it and work for it, for the closer you bring it, the brighter, richer and happier life will be" express the optimistic outlook of revolutionaries through out the ages. This confidence sustained him and there is no while in prison pessimism in his novel.

The main theme of the novel is the struggle of Vera Pavlovna for independence and happiness.

Her father is a servant in a rich household, and her parents main concern is making money and arranging a good marriage for her.

There is little family affection and Vera's parents constantly remind her that she is indebted to them. She is told to marry for money and not to worry about love or affection. All the women are involved in its running and the profits are divided equally. The co-operative goes beyond the work to include buying food, and social activities. The women regardless of their background work together.

Those women without family ties live together in a large house.

They also organise readings, trips to the countryside and to the theatre so that there is a rounded development of the co-op members. Chernyshevsky uses this business to show the advantages of socialist co-operation.

However this scheme, like the lives of the main characters, is an isolated island of the future in the grey sea of Czarist Russia. It was utopian to think that such examples, by reason alone, can change society. It required the struggles of millions, linked to a clear programme, in a revolution, to end Vera broadens herself through experience and struggle. Nonetheless she strives for more, in particular to include sexual satisfaction in her relationship.

She is drawn into friendship with Alexander Kirsanov, a colleague of Dmitry, who eventually leaves Vera out of respect for her feelings. Vera and Alexander get married.

The growth of this companionship is not described in a sentimental and slushy manner like a Mills and Boon story but with real doubt, guilt, sadness and upheaval before finding a new richer fulfilment.

Alexander is a doctor and Vera in a further break with convention decides The author to study medicine.

dismisses the prejudices against women. He writes "Any person who pursues their goal, in a business like fashion, whether they are dressed in men's or women's attire makes no difference: that person is simply a hardworking human being-and there's an Chernyshevsky further explains how their relationship grows, "a man loves a woman only if he is prepared to help and be beloved rise up his independent."

They discuss sensual love as well as their independence, in fact their love is strengthened by their independence. In one passage Vera discusses the abandoning of wearing a corset. This is both a physical and mental freedom. Vera has several dreams which mark the crises of her development. One is a powerful and vivid description of womens personal and sexual role culminates in a future where the "barren desert turned into fertile land" Chernyshevsky's socialist What Is To Be Done? is a powerful book of the struggle of a woman. The style in places is odd but the character and the experiences come through. Vera's character unfolds through struggles with the tensions building to a crisis to inaugrate a new stage of her Women's struggle for emancipation Her experience is in the material world rather than the mystic world of many other Russian novelists of the 19th century.

Chernyshevsky has a deep understanding of woman's struggle for emancipation. Vera explains "Everything rests on money, whoever has money has power and freedom. Then, as long as woman lives at man's expense, she will be dependent on She rejects the stereotype role of "What is this femine nature. Is it necessary to discuss the respective merits of contralto and baritone? We are always told to remain women. Isn't that nonsense? I am going to throw off this feminity and put forth utterly masculine ideas."

Her search for liberation does not include a battle against men. She seeks the way forward with some men. The barrier is social.

Chernyshevsky explains the need for those who struggle and would win to be conscious, confident and united. "Women have always been told they are weak, and so they feel weak" He explains how in war a smaller organised group can deteat larger "These did not share this numbers.

fear and were not accustomed to surrended without a struggle. They conquered everytime."

His book is full of confidence and that confidence is vital to victory. Marxists, women and men, have a key role to win the victory that will change the "barren desert" of capitalism into a "fertile land".

← The Other America: Art and the Labour Movement in the United States, by Philip Foner and R. SchultzThe Right's Pyrrhic victory →

Something wrong on this page?