Booknotes
Books received for review since the last edition of the MIR include The Great Tin Crash: Bolivia and the World Tin Market, published by the Latin America Bureau at £2.95. The world stock market crash of 1987 was preceded in 1986 by an equally stunning collapse of the International Tin Council, a 22 nation body which administered the world market prices for tin. A more than 50% drop in prices led to the end of the ITC which had been designed to maintain stable prices. Around the world, poor tin producing nations like Bolivia suffered as thousands of miners lost their jobs.
This short booklet attempts to explain what happened and why, and the consequences for working people in countries like Bolivia-it is a prophetic warning of the tragedy ahead for the people of the Third World as prices collapse in the coming world recession. The booklet graphically reveals the way in which the raw material producing poor nations have been exploited by the con-
sumer states of the advanced capitalist world, and how even the limited protection that a commodity agreement on tin provided places like Bolivia can be swept away when the forces of the 'free market' exert themselves. The book concludes: "although they have an impor tant role to play, commodity agreements cannot substitute for a planned world economy geared to ensuring a minimum standard of living for all, in which costs as well as benefits of change are shared"
Life and Death in Shanghai by Nien Cheng, pubiished by Grafton at £3.95, is an autobiographical account of how the wife of the general manager of the Shell Oil Company, who subsequently became a senior executive herself in the company after the 1949 revolution, was accused of being a British spy, locked up in solitary confinement for over six years, and cruelly humiliated by her captors during the socalled Cultural Revolution introduced by the Maoist bureaucracy in 1966.
The book graphically exposes the Stalinist methods of terror and intimidation imposed on individuals innocent of any crime during that period. Unfortunately some of its power is lost, as Nien Cheng clearly seems to take for granted her privileged status of servants, money and luxury living, and appears unaware that this would make her an obvious scapegoat for Maoist propaganda. Her life style prior to her arrest seemed very similar to Mao's own wife-except that Nien Cheng was subjected to lengthy imprisonment and her daughter was murdered. Mao's wife simply organised these brutalities.
Finally 1987 was the 250th anniversary of the birth of Thomas Paine, the Englishman who wrote some of the seminal works of the American and French bourgeois revolutions. The Thomas Paine Reader, edited by Isaac Kramnick and publ ished by Penguin at £5.95, allows the reader to dip into the ideas of Paine, but is less successful in placing them in the context of what Paine actually did during the French revolution and the American War of Indepen-
dence. In particular, Michael Foot's introduction to this volume concentrates more on Paine's thoughts and even literary style than on how this important fighter for freedom from feudalism and absolute monarchy tried to implement his ideas.
Paine opposed the colonisation of India by the British state; he fought in the revolutionary army under Washington against the British; he participated in the French revolution; he even proposed a form of social security in his most famous work "The Rights of Man' to help those without work or property. Inevitably he was forced to flee Britain and those who published his books were prosecuted by the British monarchy after the Napoleonic Wars when the government feared his ideas may be taken up by the growing movement of an emerging working-class. Unfortunately much of this is not dealt with adequately in this reader, and MIR readers may find a good biography of Paine of more value.
By Bob McKee