Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Uprooting Poverty: The South African Challenge, by Francis Wilson and Mamphela Ramphele

· No. 40, Summer 1989 · pp. 27-28 of the scan · 991 words

The scan: Militant International Review no40 Summer 1989.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents-titles located in body; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 27]

Book Reviews Uprooting Poverty - The South African Challenge By Francis Wilson and Mamphela Ramphele Published by WW Norton, 1989, 218.95.

Reviewed by David Johnson "One of the clearest images of the natare of poverty in the country is the sight of a group of elderly black each women carrying home on her head a load of firewood weighing up to 50kg, passing underneath the high tension cables that carry the electric energy between the towns and farmsteads of the Republic". South Africa produces 60 per cent of the electricity generated in the African continent but if you are an African in South Africa there is a four to one chance that where you live has no electricity. In the luxurious suburbs of white South Africa there are 18 people to every swimming pool. In the Mhala district of Gazankulu, in the Eastern Transvaal. there are 760 people to every water tap These facts come trom the Second Carnegie Inquiry into Poverty and Derelopment in Southern Africa. Its findings were collected and written up by two academics the University of Cape from Town, Francis Wilson, a professor of economics, and Dr Mamphela Ramphele, a senior research officer, in their book Wilson and Ramphele's book is an awesome indictment of the politics of apartheid and its human costs. South Africa is a colossus of misery: even its cabinet ministers' boast that 'their blacks have the best living standards in all Africa is no longer true. The infant mortality rate for African children in South Africa is 94-124 per thousand births: considerably worse than the national average in Botswana (72), Zimbabwe and Kenya (76), Congo (77). Tunisia (78), Algeria (81 ) and Zambia (8+).

Poverty in South Africa has clear racial and geographical dimensions. The darker your skin the poorer you are likely to be and in general that poverty increases with distance from the main cities. Whites constitute less than one sixth of the population but earn two thirds of the income, whilst Africans who make up nearly three quarters of the people earn just one quarter of the income Mrs Cornelius lives in Calitzdorp. a small agricultural town about one third of the way up the railway line from Cape Town to Johannesburg. She is a widow receiving an old age pension of 83 rands per month (+ rands = approximately). She lives with her daughter and six grandchildren and is the sole breadwinner. After rent. electricity and water are paid for. each member of the household has a disposable income of seven rands per month for food and household expenses. According to the South African Tourist Board in London seven rands would purchase a Coca Cola and an evening at the cinema in Central Johannesburg In the rural reserves of the Transkei. Bophuthatswana, Ciskei and Venda. which in Kafkaesque terms the South African government have declared 'independent' states. the spectre of starvation haunts everyone. The number in destitution there has grown sixfold since 1960. Between 50 per cent and 60 per cent of the residents of the Transkei never eat meat. milk, eggs or fish. In the Ciskei researchers found "an emaciated old woman confused from her hunger crying out again and again 1 am hungry. I am hungry:" They saw an old man "bludgeoned by poverty into... vacant apathy, alive only because he was not dead; who only said when asked what was wrong, 'l am hungry'."

The authors argue that the scaffolding used to create this skyscraper of tears has three key elements in its framework: colonialism which dispossessed the indigenous inhabitants of their land; ruthless exploitation of labour through the migrant labour system; and a state machine which brutally suppresses any revolt against these injustices The 1913 Land Act restricted black ownership of land to 1+ per cent of the surface area of South Africa. 50,000 white farmers now own 1é times as much land as 10 million rural Africans. The migrant labour system, first developed on the gold and diamond mines, enforces cheap labour. Migrants live away from their families for 11 months of the year in all male hostel compounds. There are at least two million migrant workers out of the five million black workers in the South African economy Their lives have been ruthlessly exploited for generation after generation particularly through the hated pass law system, enfor ced in detail until 1986. Then the pass laws were formally abolished. But from the time when official records began in 1916 to 1980

[page 28]

17 million people were prosecuted for being somewhere without official permission. As the authors note: "This means that one person was arrested every two minutes, day and night, for the entire period from the year before the Russian Revolution until the time of President Reagan's second term of office." Poverty is a profoundly political issue. South Africa produces more than half of the world's gold and 70 per cent of its platinum. Yet over one third of its black children live in the grip of dire

As Wilson and Ramphele say, "an essential prerequisite for uprooting poverty in South Africa is a redistribution of political power."

But while they gather hope from the blossoming of self-help schemes at a local level for health care, literacy and community development, they are not ivory tower academics: theirs is a masterful presentation of reality. They acknowledge that all the efforts of literacy groups in South Africa in 1980 could only help 25,000 people out of an estimated six

illiterates.

More pertinent is the quote Wilson and Ramphele draw from Frantz Fanon and his book on the Algerian revolution, The Wretched of the Earth: "What counts today, the question which is looming on the horizon, is the need for a redistribution of wealth. Humanity must reply to this question or be shaken to pieces by it".

This book shows South Africa to be a political time bomb. And the time bomb is ticking.

← Ted GrantWhen the Music's Over: The Story of Political Pop, by Robin Denselow →

Something wrong on this page?