Anatomy of a Scientific Discovery By Jeff Goldberg Published by Bantam Books, £4.99 Reviewed by Gwyn Morris THIS BOOK PROVIDES i useful insight into the fierce competition and rivalry in the scientific world. It points to the prizes of success, not just rewards of Nobel prizes, but the financial gains to be made in the commercial applications of new discoveries. It also gives a readable account of our developing understanding of the functioning of the brain and nervous system.
The story starts in a woefully underfunded research laboratory at Aberdeen University with a germ of an idea which was later going to tax the imagination of hundreds of scientists interna-
lions of pounds of research funding. The idea, put simply, was that the nervous system itself produced chemicals which modified the sensation of pain. There were numerous examples of men and women reporting no pain even when badly wounded in war. It was thought that painkillers such as morphine mimiced natural Chemicals.
At Aberdeen, despite poor equipment and the nervousness of workers there to ask for advice on techniques from other laboratories for fear of giving away their secrets, this brain chemical or endomorphine was isolated, purified and its structure elucidated. Their results hit the world scientific community like a bomb, and started a mad race to lead this new research field in public and private laboratories.
However, it became clear very quickly that the first endomorphine isolated was part of a family tionally and attract tens of milof chemicals acting in the nervous system. What at first seemed a simple system proved immensely complicated. Furthermore, the chemicals were small proteins, which would prove incredibly expensive to produce commercially. The possibility of short-term gain receded and the multinationals scaled down their efforts. The complexity of these chemicals at a molecular level was reflected in their effects or funetions. Their presence in certain glands linked them to appetite and temperature control, in addition to regulating the emotional and physical response of humans to stress, anxiety and fear. They have also been linked to the process of childbirth - levels were six times higher at the end of pregnancy than in non-pregnant women. It is clear that these molecules form a link between chemical, physical and emotional states, having a role in pain, pleasure, memory, stress, immunity and sexual response. Exciting and fascinating as this is, its sheer complexity is a block to commercial exploitation. Consequently, the piecing together of this gigantic puzzle, and mapping its relationship with environmental inf luences, will inevitably fall to small groups of scientists around the world.
Goldberg's book, then, provides futher evidence of the delays and pitfalls inherant in competitive science, unable to harness all the disparate research interests to find the answers to questions which could revolutionise potentially our understanding of the workings of our bodies.