Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

About Turn: The Communist Party and the Outbreak of the Second World War, edited by King and Matthews

· No. 46, Summer 1991 · p. 39 of the scan · 708 words

The scan: Militant International Review no46 Summer 1991.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 39]

About Turn - The Communist Party and the Outbreak of the Second World War Edited by King and Matthews Published by Laurence and Wishart, 1990 Reviewed by David Turner WAR IS ONE of the severest tests of any organisation claiming to be This was clearly revolutionary. illustrated in 1939 by the impact of the outbreak of war on the Communist Party of Great Britain (CPGB).

During the late 1930s. Stalin answered the threat to the Soviet L'nion from Nazi Germany by proposing a 'Peace Front' with British and French imperialism. They. of course, were not interested. secking through their policy of appeasing Hitler, to encourage Nazi aggression against the U'SSR. In the summer of 1939. Stalin opened negotiations with Germany, aiming to exploit Hitler's reluctance to fight a war on two fronts. In August 1939 a Nazi-Soriet 'Non-Aggression Pact was concluded, with a secret agreement to carve up Poland. Days later the German army marched into western Poland while the Red Army took the eastern half. Britain and France. clear about the threat posed to their own interests by Hitler, declared war on 3 September.

The Communist Party's reaction was to support Britain's declaration of war, seeing it as the realisation of Moscow's previous policy. However, the Soviet I'nion. far from supporting Britain and France's 'anti-fascist' war, denounced them as 'aggressors', fighting an imperialist war.

Dave Springhall, the CPGB representative at the Conimunist International's headquarters. was dispatched back to London to 'explain' the new line. On his return, the new position was em- braced by the majority of the central committee (CC), yet resisted by Harry Pollitt. General secretary of the CPGB. JR Campbell. editor of The Daily Worker. and Willie Gallacher, the CP's only A verbatim report was made of these CC meetings for immediate transmission to Moscow. where it has lain inaccessible in the archives for half a century. The CPGB finally obtained a copy of the document last year and it is this which is now published. The transcript shows that. while the CC members awaited Springhall's return from Moscow, Pollitt told them that "we are all like a lot of rabbits in front of a snake". The comparison is apt.

Springhall simply intorms the CC that Moscow has decreed that all Communist Parties must opp ose the war as imperialist'. After a week's adjournment. the C.C. reconvenes. Pollitt. unable to accept the new line. has been replaced as General Secretary: Demanding adherence to Moscom's new line. the party's chief theoretician. Rajani Palme Dutt. argues that "fun- Nazi Germany has camentally been weakened br the Soviet-German Non Aggression Pact". concluding that "the one thing that ther (the Nazis-DT) are desperately searching for is peace"! The way to end the war is by campaigning for British imperialism to negotiate with the "peace-hungry" Nazis.

In a spluttering tirade. Willie Gallacher explodes at this "unopportunist scrupulous and speech", accusing Dutt of "mean dislovalty" and despicable in pretending that he had no responsibility for the old line. Campbell. for his part. warns that the new line will make the CPGB "indistinguishable in a very short time from the filthy rabble of Trotsky- Moscow's policy: of course. bore no relation to the attitude to the war adopted by the Trotsk!• ists. the genuine Marxists. The! consistently opposed the imperialist war being waged by the ruling class. arguing that workers must continue to fight the class enemy at home. They fought for a Labour government with a socialist programme against Chamberlain's 'National government', explaining that a socialist Britain, with workers' control of industry and the armed forces. would be able to wage a revolutionary war against fascism. making a class appeal to the German workers. Within two years the wheel had turned full circle. In June 19+l Hitler invaded the USSR. Overnight the Comintern proclaimed the war aims of British imperialism as 'anti-fascist. The CPGB then embarked on one of the most reactionary periods in its history. giving full support to Churchill. breaking strikes and opposing freedom for the colonies. The Trotskyists. whilst supporting the gains of the revolution. maintained their implacable opposition to the Stalinist bureaucracy and to British imperialism. They alone can truthfully claim to have stuck steadfastly to the ideas of Marxism throughout world war tWO.

← Marxism, Anarchism and the State Nick WrackThe Longest War: The Iran-Iraq Military Conflict, by Dilip Hiro →

Something wrong on this page?