Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Wolfe Tone, by Marianne Elliott

· No. 46, Summer 1991 · p. 41 of the scan · 620 words

The scan: Militant International Review no46 Summer 1991.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

Wolfe Tone By Marianne Elliott Published by vale University met Press, at £16.95 Reviewed by Anton McCabe THEOBALD WOLFE TONE (1763- 98) was a great Irish revolutionieve reform.

ary, the father of Irish Republicanism'. Marianne Elliot's biography is well researched, but conveys no sense of what made tens of thousands join a revolutionary to bring i French- In the late eighteenth century, a few great landed families controlled Irish politics. In Belfast, centre of the most energetic capitalist Mayor and twelve burgesses were the electors; even the wealthiest merchants and manufacturers lacked the vote. Eighty per cent of the people were Catholics, legally shut out capitalists wanted their own state, to provide political conditions for capitalist development. To this end, Tone was one of the founders of the Society of United Irishmen in Belfast in Tone was the son of a wealthy this most radical section of the Dublin coachmaker, a member of bourgeoisie. with some exceptsubscribe

organisation style republic to Ireland. development, the from political power.

The Irish 1791.

the Established Church and a law- ions, were not prepared to mobilyer. Moves to parliamentary reform and Catholic emancipation with government clampdowns. The government forced Tone to leave the country or face trial for treason. He was driven to revolution as the only way to ach- In 1795 Tone went to France to seek help. But after Thermidor in 179÷, when the Committee of Public Safety was overthrown, a more conservative section of the French bourgeois had come to power, less keen on exporting revolution. Tone was given the run-around for three years. The United Irish leadership were the most radical section of the bourgeoisie, not supported by most of their own class. The ranks were artisans, labourers and peasants. Elliot wrongly writes that "squabbling sectarian divisions... decimated the United Irish movement" before the 1798 rebellion. In fact as a social movement the I'nited Irishmen stopped much of the sectarian violence whipped up by the government and landlords in rural lister. Only after the defeat would this re-assert itself. Ireland's tragedy was that even

ise the Irish masses to make the revolution, fearing necessary them more than they did the British government. They were 'foreign-aid - wanting France to take power for them. The Northern ranks, largely artisans and Presbyterians and reflecting the stronger development of capitalism there, pushed for action - without France if necessary. 1797 was a year of smothered revolt. Elliot ignores the extent to which the United Irishmen controlled large areas such as Mid. Ulster. But the hesitation of the leaders dissipated the movement. Tone in France felt a 'great lack of spirit' in the leaders at home. Like Robespierre in the Great French Revolution, he was prepared to go beyond the bounds of bourgeois property to ensure the of the bourgeoisie. He victory wrote: "If the men of property will not support us, they must fall; we can support ourselves by the aid of that numerous and respectable class in the community - the men of no property:"

Elliot dismisses the heroic rebellion of 1798 as 'bloodr and sectarian'. The lack of Tone's spirit among most leaders meant it was partial. Between May and August there were ten separate unco-ordinated risings across three provinces. In Wexford the rebels held power for almost four weeks. They set up a Committee of Public Safety, with ordinary working men serving on sub-committees dealing with supplies.

The French help which came was too little, too late: 1.000 men on the West Coast in late August. a month after the last rebels in the east had surrendered.

The Irish bourgeois then preferred servility to following the rerolutionary Tone. Consistent in their fear of revolution they ignore or distort him today.

← Notre Ami le Roi (Our Friend the King), by Gilles PerraultA new era opens →

Something wrong on this page?