Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

What happened at Monktonhall?

No. 678, 2 December 1983 · pp. 10-11 of the scan · 1,401 words

The scan: Militant 678 1983-12-02.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 5.9x body type, 2 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 10]

CHRIS HERRIOT, a young miner who played an active role in the recent strike of Monktonhall pit in Scotland explains what happened and the lessons to be learned. MINERS ARE engaged in a national overtime ban. They sixteen strike committees at reject the paltry pay offer local level in miners clubs and the threat of wholesale throughout the Lothians in pit closures. order to involve every rank National Coal Board and file member. chairman Ian MacGregor The closure of Monktonhas declared his desire to hall would have a close all pits producing coal devastating effect on the at a cost of over £60 per local community. After the tonne. This would result in war there were nineteen the immediate closure of for- working pits in East ty four pits. Lothian. By 1951 there were The recent strike at twelve. Now there is only Monktonhall pit in Scotland Monktonhall-which lies which ended after eight between East and Mid weeks, should be an inspira- Lothian. tion to every British miner.

Wide support The Monktonhall campaign holds many important lessons for the struggle In Mid Lothian twelve pits against MacGregor and the existed in 1965. Now only Tories. Bilston Glen remains. Other For six weeks leading up industries have been similarto the strike our colliery suf- ly hit. A paper mill which fered attack after attack on once employed 2,500 people working practices, working is now down to 115. For conditions, incentive every forty people unempayments and trade union ployed there is one vacancy. representation. This The community had to aid culminated in the halting of our fight. development of the pit and Cash was collected from the abandoning of con pubs, betting shops, supersultative and conciliation markets, corner shops and procedures. traders. Fund raising acThe final straw came when tivities were organised in the 150 men were locked out for clubs. Easthouses miners being a few minutes late in club donated £670. The newpresenting themselves at the ly formed, (but as yet unofpit-head after a union ficial) Mid Lothian Labour meeting to discuss manage- Party Women's Section ment attacks and 300 assisted by making up food redundancies parcels. The LPYS organisLed meetings and collected money for the strike fund.

Donations came from factories throughout the Lothians. The workers at Torness power station gave t157.

This show of solidarity clearly illustrates how a local dispute can involve the whole population.

We recognised the necessity of spreading the strike, Arthur Scargill.

first to Scotland then to the We immediately took over rest of the British coalfield. the colliery administration The Scottish NUM called corridor, sat down and for the dispute to be made refused to budge. The rest of official and later for a the lads on the day shift 24-hour stoppage and a £2 came back up to join the sit- levy. Many branch officials in. This reflected the depth were apprehensive about the of feeling that had been possible outcome of the building up over weeks. 24-hour stoppage. They A mass meeting was held underestimated the depth of on the arrival of the 'Ham feeling. and Egg' (maintenance) shift. We unanimously Looking south agreed to call a 24-hour stoppage and a special meeting the next day. At Francis Colliery, Fife, A dispute which started as any doubts about support a simple protest at manage- for the stoppage or the need ment's provocation explod- for the levy were dispelled as ed into a battle for the future soon as miners heard the of the pit. arguments. All shifts Over 700 men voted vir- unanimously agreed to the tually unanimously (20 action. If the NCB can close against) for an all-out in- a nineteen year-old super-pit definite strike until such time they can close any pit. as the NCB agreed to restart Even miners at the development of the pit and Blinkbonny private mine to return to full consultation struck-under threat of not and conciliation procedures. having jobs the next day.

The craftmen's union The support in Scotland was SCEBTA and later COSA solid. We began to look linked with the NUM branch south. and formed a joint strike Rank and file members as committee to organise the well as branch officials from campaign. The first step was the joint unions addressed the establishment of some meetings at pit-heads, delegate conferences and area executives. Leaflets were distributed and appeals made for financial support. The response was tremendous. Area after area pledged support in one form or another. The Doncaster Panel (delegate conference) voted to take industrial action as soon as the Scottish Area took action in support of Monktonhall. Many other individual pits also pledged strike action in our support. In the north-western area, traditionally considered right wing, we got a tremendous response.

There can be no doubt that a national miners' strike was looming-over the Monktonhall issue in particular and pit closures in general.

Mick McGahey.

At the June NUM national conference a resolution to fight pit closures was passed unanimously. From that point the whole of the union machine should have been thrown into the battle. Regular tours should have been mounted by national speakers, along with miners from the threatened pits, explaining the case for a fightback.

A poster and leaflet cam paign should have been launched, for distribution not only to the miners but to the local communities and trade unionists.

It was evident during the speaking tours that morale was lifted. A decisive lead was essential.

By the sixth or seventh week of the strike the ground had been laid for spreading the dispute. Miners were prepared for escalation of the dispute, firstly by stopping Scotland and then moving south. Astonishingly, however, elements of the Scottish NUM leadership began to argue that we should return to work in order to participate in the national overtime ban.

This was decisively rejected by a SCEBTA mass meeting. At no time did the area or national leadership discuss with the Monktonhall men a strategy for linking the strike to the national overtime ban.

The mood of our workforce was of supreme confidence. Attention had shifted from anger at the antics of local management to the need to stop MacGregor and even take on the Tory government.

lobbying lead on the right issue.

whole union took up the battle.

production.

policies in the NUM.

Broad Left.

A bombshell was then dropped by the Scottish area leadership. They recommended a return to work. The picket that was lobbying the meeting exploded when they learnt the executive's recommendation had been decided without discussion or a vote being allowed. It was stated the NCB had climbed down and conceded a return to the laid down consultative and conciliation procedure. A representative of the Scottish NCB, on the other hand, appeared on TV and stated there was no change in their position. This CLAI IN For make a clean break. basis of proven need. mation of society.

Join Militant in this and the Tories.

produced anger and confusion among our members.

Many were demanding guarantees before any return to work.

But it became clear that escalation of our dispute within the Scottish area was out of the question. We were left with no alternative but to accept the offer and immediately return to work.

Nevertheless, the SCEBTA branch voted to remain on strike by a 2 - 1 majority and the NUM branch voted only narrowly to go back.

The craftsmen then had no alternative but to recall their SUALISM IS SECLKTT Militan ment is either o help prop u capital Mining is in crisis because of t he crisis in the capitalist economy of which the mining industry is an integral part. dustry. This must be ended. the interests of the working class.

third appointed by the government.

fight. Stop MacGregor meeting a few days later and agree a return to work, emphasising that as far as they were concerned it didn't mean the end of the dispute.

The NCB will possibly restart some development of the pit, but they will come back later with another attack. If they don't close Monktonhall then another pit will close in its place. We must be prepared to fight for other pits. Cronton in Lancaster is to close shortly. If MacGregor gets his way then pit closures will proceed at an ever-increasing pace.

[page 11]

2 December 1983 MI LITANT 11

----- pull-quotes -----

Defeat out of victory

← STOP CUTS! SAVE - SERVICES!FOR THE FULL FORD CLAIM →

Something wrong on this page?