Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Pit closures- economics of the madhouse

No. 711, 3 August 1984 · p. 5 of the scan · 524 words

The scan: Militant 711 1984-08-03.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 6.2x body type, 3 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 5]

When talks between the miners and the National Coal Board broke down, Arthur Scargill said: 'This strike has been forced to continue over one word—beneficial". Who benefits from closing down pits? Tory objectives for the Coal Board illustrate argument that the irrationality of pit closure ty's point of view is rooted in the anarchi At first sight the Coal Board's claim that "uneconomic" pits should close seems reasonable. Last year the NCB made a loss and had to ask the government for a £630 million handout. You would expect MacGregor to welcome the strike-the longer the better-to clear all the coal stocks.

But then we hear an official announcement that the strike has cost the NCB £600 with Government NCB objectives following terms:

.market.

of capitalist production for profit. million so far. As the NUM has pointed out, the total cost to society is v ery much more. What is the real situation?

Balance sheet In the first place, one third of the government subsidy is money spent not to keep the pits going but to close them down. £122 million goes to cover the "social cost" of pit closures and £105 million to help cover redundancy Report al Coal Board ano Nor publication cast, or use on JULY 27 1983 Mick Brooks s froi n socie : con petition Mick payments. Since Maggie Thatcher is so anxious to save money we can save her £227 million right away-by fighting the closure programme!

But the flow of money is not all one way. The NCB paid the governemt £360 million in interest on loans of £3,600 million. A writeoff of debt charges-money which reaches such undeserving hands as the old private coal owners-could save f2 million a pit.

The National Coal Board is losing £30 million a week through the strikethey save £30 million in wages but lose £60 million in lost production. So each miner makes £1 for the NCB for every il he is paid in wages.

That is not the end of the matter. The Central Electricity Generating Board is losing £20 million a week by its politically motivated decision to burn oil instead of coal. Steel is losing £8m a week in lost production. Rail is losing £5m a week in coal freight. The DHSS is losing flm a week in payments to miners' families, despite attempting to cheat them out of their entitlements. The exchequer is losing £4 million a week in taxes.

Capitalist logic The real cost of the strike, £70 million a week, drives home the lesson that coal mining is not a drain but a wealth creating sector of the economy that would be disastrous to chop.

The NCB, like capitalist management, say what is good for them is good for the country. The whole fault of a capitalist economy is that individual managers or owners take decisions which are in their own or their firms' interests but not in the interests of society. LET Photo: Rick Matthews (IFL)

VV C NEED YUUK

----- pull-quotes -----

answer to a Parliamentary Question on March 18 capacity into line with its continuing shard ofthe

Alcounts 1982/3

← COME HOME TO A LIVING FIRES BABURN ALLA MACGREGORTories ignore energy experts →

Something wrong on this page?