Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Major life threat

No. 712, 10 August 1984 · pp. 9-10 of the scan · 785 words

The scan: Militant 712 1984-08-10.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 5.2x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 9]

A government report, headed by Sir Douglas Black, into the incidence of childhood cancers in West Cumbria admitted that: "there may be channels of radiation which reach But the Black report refuses to more than twice the national link the nuclear plant at Sellafield average, and well above that of the with the disease and merely recom yard's non-nuclear workers. The mends that this *hypotheses should figures were calculated by a doctor be investigated". This is despite the who filed a law suit under the fact that the report accepts the fin- Freedom of Information Act to get dings of the Yorkshire TV access to the records. nuclear laundry'. which revealed a maintaining an iron hold over these WASTE CINCINNATI GAS and Electric of Ohio announced last week that they are converting their Zimmer nuclear plant to coal because it is far cheaper. The decision to abandon the nuclear plant, despite having spent $1,700 million on parts, had been made because nuclear power was proving far too expensive and inefficient. In the new coal plant 1,300 mega watts will be produced compared to the planned 840 mw for the nuclear plant.

The Zimmer decison comes shortly after another company, Wabash Valley Power Association, announced that they were planning to convert their nuclear plant at Marble Hill to coal people that we do not know about." documentary, 'Windscale, the dramatic increase in various cancers, especially leakeamia amongst children in the area.

How big a risk?

The authorities, already under enormous pressure following adverse publicity concerning the leakage of radioactive wastes have issued reassurances on the levels of radiation escaping from the plant and asserting that there was no evidence of general risk to people living in the area.

But what is the truth? First what is nuclear radiation and what are its effects?

Radiation-in the form of ionising particles and rays such as Xrays—are emitted when a nuclear reaction occurs as in the production of nuclear energy. They are virtually impossible to contain.

A chief characteristic of some radiation is their ability to cause mutation of cellular structure of the human body. When this occurs cancers and leukaemia results. Small children and embryos carried by pregnant women are particularly vulnerable.

Recent research has revealed that whereas high levels of radiation often kills the cell, low levels are more dangerous as they injure the cell, leaving them free to reproduce and carry on the damage.

### American results

Studies of death certificates of workers at the Hansford nuclear plant in Washington have revealed a disturbingly high incidence of cancer of the pancreas and leukaemia even though workers were exposed to levels well within the agreed "safety" limits. This pattern has now been observed amongst British workers. But the most alarming results have come from a chance discovery.

The overall cancer death rate among civilian nuclear workers at the Navy's Portsmouth shipyard in Kettery, Maine was found to be The Navy had good reason for records. The results were startling. They showed that the rate of leukaemia was an incredible 450% higher than the general population's. The incidence of lympth gland cancer was 125% higher.

As the workers were exposed to the lowest possible dosage of radiation these studies have conclusivelu domanstratad that thare in ma ty ucmousualcu lat tere is no sate level of radiation exposure. Since cancer is a long agonising process the full extent of radiation damage and that due to radioactive substances leaking into the environment are unlikely to be known for a long time.

Unreliable report The Black Report and its so-called assurances must be questioned in the light of available evidence. Moreover Black's assertion that the risks assocated with nuclear power in comparison with that of coal extraction must also be challenged. It is entirely erroneous to compare the dangers of coal mining with that of nuclear power.

The potential dangers in nuclear fission are much greater. Coal extraction is a danger to the worker in the industry and can be limited by technology. Yet the inherent dangers in nuclear fission can result in a catastrophe as shown by the Harrisburg accident.

It is vitally important that the labour and trade union movement conduct its own thorough-going enquiry. It must mobilise immediately to ensure that health and safety become a key issue in all establishments. As part of the campaign it must insist on the full revelation of all the company's records and studies relating to the poisoning and workers and the community. They must demand stringent medical checks of all workers and of the general population and the results made available.

[page 10]

Iran/Iraq war, India 10 MILITANT 10 August 1984 USA,

----- pull-quotes -----

US switche's to coal

← Notts jobs will goIndian workers back miners →

Something wrong on this page?