Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Nuclear power fact and fiction

No. 712, 10 August 1984 · pp. 8-9 of the scan · 1,193 words

The scan: Militant 712 1984-08-10.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 16.4x body type, 4 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 8]

A KEY part of the propaganda offensive against the miners is the claim that using coal to generate electricity is more expensive then using nuclear power, but even from the narrow view of capitalist economics, nuclear power doesn't make sense.

Since the nuclear emergency at Three Mile Island in the USA in 1978, no new nuclear plants have been ordered there and 40% of existing orders have been cancelled. The nuclear lobby, backed by multinationals such as Westinghouse, have suffered a serious blow as the ruling class have virtually written off further development ofnuclear power, as least in the foreseeable future. One result of this has been the publication of more objective analyses of the true costs involved.

*The PWR is the reactor which was installed at the Three Mile Island plant in the USA. A nuclear catastrophe was only narrowly averted there in 1977. Many engineers think the design is intrinsically unsafe, and no PWR's have been ordered for use in the States since 1978.

The supporters of nuclear power understate the costs in three main ways: the initial capital costs in building the plant are underestimated, full research and development costs are not included and finally, and most importantly, the operating efficiency of the power station is overestimated by up to 30%. After studying these factors, the authors of a new book in the USA came to the conclusion that, "the full cost for a unit of nuclear energy ordered today for operation in the 1990's would be more than twice that of the same unit from a coal burner". (The Competitive Economics of Nuclear and Coal Power, by Caroline and Richard Hellman, Gower Publishing Co, 1984).

The most important consideration when comparing the performance of nuclear and coal stations is the load factor. This is an efficiency rating, being the ratio of actual output from the turbines in a power station to the maximum possible output, expressed as a percentage. The nuclear planners in the USA assumed that all the units built would operate with a load factor of 80%, ie producing 80% of capacity. However, the actual lifetime average is about 55%, with the European light water reactors, which includes t want to use, ope same leve:.

Be typ e the CEGB ating at about the *GEC and the American multinational, Westinghouse stand to make huge profits if the CEGB stick to their plan to produce half of our electricity in the future by nuclear power.

The French government have had the biggest nuclear power station building programme in the world. There are 27 Pressurised Water Reactors (PWR) working at the moment, with five more planned to open this year. The first began producing electricity in 1977 and since then the lifetime load factor has been 52%. The French Electricity Board use the Westinghouse PWR, which is the same reactor the CEGB want to buy. There is also no evidence that the load factor will improve in the future; indeed, when the new 1,300 megawatt stations come on stream fresh problems may crop up, as was found in the USA.

There is evidence from Germany that damage has occured when nuclear plants have been run too hard to try to improve the load factor. Normally plants are shut down for two months each year for essential maintenance, but if this period is shortened to increase output, problems could begin to occur due to corrosion or vibration. The German Biblis-A and Biblis-B PWRs had lifetime load factors of 60%, but during the peak winter period in 1983 both were out of order.

The OECD report which made coal much more expensive than nuclear power assumed a load factor for nuclear of 75%. If a more realistic figure of 55% is used, the costs of nuclear power rise by 50%.

* Companies like Babcock and Wilcox and Taylor Woodrow, who are big contributors to Tory funds, stand to gain from a massive expansion of the nuclear programme.

The second major adjustment which must be made when calculating the costs of nuclear power is in capital spending. The capital cost of the French PWR's built between 1976 and 1983 was underestimated by 30%. In Britain, the CEGB uses historic cost accounting, which doesn't allow for the full effects of inflation. As nuclear power is twice as capital intensive as coal, the effects of using historic costs is to 'write down' the cost of nuclear power as compared to coal, since the heaviest price burden in nuclear generation is incurred in the early years of construction, when prices are lower. Also full interest charges are not always included during construction; this is a particular big omission for a station like Dungeness B which was switched on 12 years late.

Research and development costs are not always fully acounted for. The civil and military nuclear programmes have always been closely linked; the first nuclear power station at Calder Hall was built to supply radioactive material for atomic bombs. It is likely then, that research work for power stations is paid for partly by the Ministry of Defence.

There are other hidden costs for nuclear power which are difficult to quantify. These include unexpected major breakdowns, waste disposal such as the cost of the Sellafield plant and decommissioning costs. This last point is particularly relevant in Britain where the original Magnox reactors are coming to the end of their lives.

The CEGB still claim that electricity produced by nuclear means will be cheaper than by coal. They plan to increase the amount of electricity produced from nuclear stations to 50%, using the Westinghouse PWR. It is not valid though, to use the past performance of the British nuclear industry as yardstick for future performance. The present workhorses of the nuclear power stations are the ageing Magnox reactors. These are of old fashioned design and of relatively small size which by now are quite reliable and operate with high load factors.

* A coal fired power station, ordered now, will produce electricity twice as cheaply as the PWR nuclear power plant favoured by the CEGB.

Even so the CEGB have been forced to admit that historically electricity has been produced more cheaply by coal-fired power stations. Projections based on future performance of the Advanced Gas Cooled reactor (AGR) are meaningless, firstly due to its appalling record to date and secondly to the fact that the CEGB intend to use the PWR for its nuclear expansion programme.

* The true cost of each nuclear power station will probably be more than a billion pounds.

When this is done, and comparisons are made with the PWR's in France and the USA, coal emerges as twice as cheap as nuclear power.

When the economic argument in favour of nuclear power is removed, the reason the Tories want to press ahead with a massive expansion is clear: to smash the power of the miners, so that the labour movement is stripped of its most class conscious fighters. The propaganda in favour of nuclear power is directed to that end.

[page 9]

5-MILE RADIUS: NEW FOR PREGNANT RG PRE-SCHOOL CHILDREN LUPHIN COUNTY DELPHIA EVACUATION ADVISED PA. 1984 MILITANT 9

← How Liverpool fought-and wonNotts jobs will go →

Something wrong on this page?