[page 6]
David Basnett casts the GMBATU massive The Tories' 1984 Trade Union Act demands that unions hold a ballot at least every ten years on continuation of their political funds. The attempt to break the historical link between trade unions and the Labour Party they largely created is not being determinedly opposed by the TUC, who propose to The Tories' attack is strengthened by lack of confidence in workers' understanding of the need for their own political partv. EILEEN SHORT looks at ou leave it up to individual unions.
one example of the pessimism of many in movement.
IF UP to a third of trade union members vote Tory, is affiliation to the Labour Party democratic? A private survey commissioned by Trade Unions for a Labour Victory (TULV) has been quoted by journalists to show that rank and file trade union members are opposed to the unions' political role and affiliation to the Labour Party.
'Brother' John Torode (as he describes himself) wrote a substantial article in The Guardian (2.8.84) claiming: 'The survey shows that in only three affiliated unions do a majority want to retain the link (with the Labour Party) and the payments that go with it"
• Being of a suspicious nature, we thought we should check before accepting Torode's reading of the survey. He doesn't give us facts, figures, questions askvote at Labour Party potentially self-fulfilling and around the labour ed or the sample size MORI used in their research.
We found Torode was being highly selective in his use of information. The survey results (which have not been publicly released) in fact indicate that a campaign of discussion, explanation and political education could produce a decisive majority in favour of trade union political funds and affiliation to the Labour Party.
The survey asked four central questions: 1. Are you in favour of the union continuing to have political funds? 2. Are you in favour of affiliation to the Labour Party? 3. Are you in favour of paying up to 5p a week for political purposes? 4. Are you in favour of the union being able to sponsor MPs?
Questions 1 and 3 ask the same thing in different forms (to find out whether quoting an amount of money made any difference). Results were almost the same for both. About 43% of all trade unionists asked, said they were in favour of political funds, and of paying for them. 44% said they weren't. 37% were in favour of affiliation to the Labour Party; of sponsoring MPs, 60%.
Breaking down the figures, in key industrial and public sector unions such as the GMBATU, NUPE, AUEW, and NUM there is a majority in favour of political funds. The white collar unions, as might be expected, produced the worst results.
There were some odd findings: UCW members were more solidly in favour of affiliation to the Labour Party than of political funds.
What Torode has done is concentrate on specific unions and their answers to question 2 alone. On this basis he concludes that trade union members object to the "uniquely unpopular" links with the Labour Party.
The MORI poll was conducted in three 'waves', each time asking 1,000 people in the street to identify themselves as union members. The answers reflect the attitudes of individual members concerned with the week's shopping, catching a bus or enjoying break from work.
A survey, like a general election, can only gives a frozen picture of moods and attitudes at a fixed point in time. Who can doubt that in the midst of the Tories' postFalklands election victory, the results of such a survey would have been worse?
### Changing
attitudes The opposite is also true: the naked face of Toryism and the intentions behind their trade union legislation is increasingly exposed in conflict with the NGA, GCHQ workers, Liverpool Council and now most sharply in the miners' struggle. Through experience trade unionists become more conscious of their class interests.
If the TUC begins a campaign now to reach every member in workplace meetings, special union branch discussions, with leaflets and rallies, workers can be convinced of the need for a political fight. They will see 'their struggles to keep head above water, to protect the interests of their families, are unavoidably linked to the fight for a Labour Party that serves the interests of the working class.