[page 4]
Nuclear power output Rail workers solidarity with miners has cut coal movements LE HAS been one excuse r the another for not using against behaviour, which ld, outside a union context, e its instigators behind bars ble quick as lan MacGregor itly hinted on Tuesday. riginally, there was the re not to alienate members re National Union of Mineers, when a strike ballot still in the offing. Then was. the supposed desire alienate the Nottinghamminers (who obviously need to make arrange• protect their own funds serwise have no reason •behind Arthur Scargill).
re all, there is the deepestablishment belief that it union militants as equal inyone else before the law r than as specially privi: would be provocative or e martyrs. : non-enforcement of the Samuel Brittan's vicious article in the Financial Times, despite its 'authoritative' style is based on false NCB figures - as Bob McKée shows in this article.
But what the NCB does not tell the reader is that this figure is for the price of open-cast mined coal. The cheapest deep-mined US coal is around $57 (from non-union mines) and rises to $69 (unionised mines). There is not nearly enough open-cast coal available to supply European markets so US exports are generally from deep-mining output with prices near to $60 not $49 a tonne. In addition if US coal was to compete in British markets to substitute for NCB coal, the extra costs of transport from Rotterdam to the Thames would have to be included, taking the cost of US coal to Britain to a price of between $67 and $79. The NCB says that the price of Australian coal is only $48 per tonne when delivered to Rotterdam. This source of energy, is a market.
Are the miners being subsidised to provide insurance price of oil, which may occur against a future rise in the after North Sea of production has tapered off? If we are really concerned with conthe hest place to leave coal is in the ground.
Is it then a commercial Investment? To ask the question is to answer it. Neither the Government nor the Coal Board has yet attempted to calculate the return on these sums, which Can you imagine these suma being raised on the capital market, as much larger sums have been for North Sea oil and may be again for British Telecom?
One does not need an unduly suspicious mind to see these danegeld— issed Saxon the Danes Dark Ages. the Heath have heen trouble in • to make ring danethat ho BELIVERED PRICE OF STEAM COAL INTO WESTERN EUROPE 80,40 (SEPTEMBER 1983)
twerp Spot Price 30/30 It & Port Loading Charg AUSTRALIA losses and £100m from having to export at a discount, ie dump. (See graph.)
The Commission estimates that if the level of closures envisaged in a tripartite report approved by the Labour Government in 1974 had been achieved, present capacity would be 10m tonnes less and the position of the • industry transformed - I would say made less bad.
may be the price at which the Australians were attempting to sell their coal last September, but that price is way below the true cost of their coal. The cheapest Australian coal, whether open-cast or deep-mined, really costs $65 per tonne when delivered to Rotterdam, according to Don Barnett and the FT International Coal Report. Adding transport to Thames ports, Australian costs would reach $75. Australians are selling their coal in Europe at a heavy loss, as are the US producers.
South Africa The NCB quotes South African coal at $39 per tonne. It neglects to point Photo: Rick Matthews (IFL)
Rick August). foreword to the NCB's 1983-84 Report, the board's programme is " designed to restructure the industry towards a more efficient, high-performance husiness based on investment in long-life collieries. the conthe closure of those collieries where reserves are either exhausted realistically workable longer But how are we to know that aims are being wiling chart out that this is open-cast mined, by non-union black labour-and of course it excludes the cost of delivery to Thames ports. As it is, the available supplies of South African coal for export and competition with NCB coal have completely dried up for this year! There is no way that South African coal could replace NCB production either in the UK or even in European markets.
The NCB chart puts the cost of UK deep-mined steam coal at $69 per tonne in September 1983. That compares favourably with the cost of available US and Australian coal which varies from $67 to $79. Since last September the dollar value to be ne THE CEGB, in a desperate attempt to keep output up from nuclear power stations has deferred shutting down its reactors over the summer for routine maintenance (New Scientist, 23 Due to close The nuclear stations at Sizewell A, Huckley Point, Dungeness, Wylfa and Oldbury were due to close for a total of 80 - 100 weeks this summer. The CEGB refuse to say whether this has been done.
The giant 1,320 Graham Lever to use its " best endeavours " to take at least 70m tonnes a year. In return, the NCB agreed to keep coal price rises below the rate of inflation. There are analagous arrangements with the British Steel Corporation. If pay and other claims anything hke those tabled by the NUM are accepted, the NCB will require even larger government subsidies to keep its pledges.
There is even an official Coal Firing Grant Scheme, extended last December, worth £75m to .....na 11K industry to conaiso a quantitieg amountin tonnes. Licensed have complained that is deliberately holdin open cast mining, f0 offending the NUM. open cast operations profit last year of £211i trast to a loss on der coal of £595m—in bo before interest. Mo would undoubtedly cor oDen cast operations wit NUM threat.
The direct electric with France. due to 1986 and officially bui with the peak loads. reduce the CEB's d on British coal in emergency by the eg two nuclear fired po If the Government r such lifelines it woul further cable lin Continent where the: electricity for sale. ations such as the At a very minimi BSC should be import freely-not. a. gency measure for, th The perennial t of coal strike blackmail of the strike, but pe The fuel oil duty lifted and open ca should be freed. N of the pound sterling has declined so that the dollar cost of UK coal is now only $59 per tonne (as stated in my article in Militant 710). In fact the NCB sells coal to the CEGB at $55.
The NCB chart and Samuel Brittan have distorted the real position on world coal mining costs in order to justify cuts, or, in the case of Brittan, a complete closure of the British coal industry. The NUM claim that British coal is competitive with any deep-mined coal worldwide is still justified by the real evidence.
educed?
AGR station at Heyshaw has been forced to shut down for technical reasons. This is a blow to the Tories, since their projections of how long coal stocks will last were partly based on the assumption that an increased amount of nuclear generated electricity would be available in the next two months. In the Autumn the Electricity Board will be required by law to shut down many of their nuclear reactors for maintenance. If they comply with this, it will be another blow to their plans to minimise coal burn.