Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Coal stocks crisis close?

No. 715, 7 September 1984 · pp. 7-8 of the scan · 1,858 words

The scan: Militant 715 1984-09-07.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 7.6x body type, 2 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 7]

THE PREDICTION by Militant that power station coal stocks could be at a critical level by midOctober has been confirmed by the analysis of the National Institute for Economic and Social Research (NIESR). Even the Economist has abandoned the government's propaganda line.

In the Institute's latest report, they say " ...difficulties in power production could conceivably be encountered by the Autumn when demand for electricity seasonally rises." They also predict that the cement industry, where nearly 90% of energy requirements are met by coal could be severely affected by the strike.

### Energy trends

The latest edition of 'Energy Trends' published by the Department of Energy also confirms Militant's analysis. The amount of coal burned in the power FOR THE last six FOR THE last six months the Tory months the Tory press and Tory press and Tory ministers have been ministers have been blaring out that the hlaring out that the miners' strike is 'only costing £20 million a weekmoney well spent if coal industry.

Though this is a fine propaganda line the ruling class does need accurate inside information to make its own, less public evaluations. The current report tron the National Institute for Economic and Social Research on the British cconomy gives a better estimate of the real cost of the miners' strike.

Wages and oil On output, the NIESR claims: "The loss of coal production was equal 10 about ! u of Gross Domesic Product in the first quarter and 1-1! 0, of GDP in the second As a result of the miners" strike national output has fallen for the first time in three years. 140,000 miners on strike means 140,000 workers with no wages to spend on the TVs and videos which have become the symbols of working class prosperity in the eyes of the media. The eftect of this "knocks-on' to the producers of cars, TVs and all the other things miners and their families are doing without. The NIESR reports that: "In the first six months of the year wages in the whole economy were probably about 1% lower than they would otherwise have been." The miners lose and we all stations in June rose to 3.82 million tonnes compared to the May figure of 3.19 million tonnes.

This shows that the CEGB's ability to switch any further alternative sources of energy, such as oil or nuclear, has been exhausted. Stocks at the power stations fell by over 1.7 million tonnes to 16.7 million tonnes in June. According to the figures over 2 million tonnes was moved into the power stations in the month, mainly coal from the Notts area.

This high figure is unliketo be repeated in July and WORKING Working class economist at TUC lobby. lose because there's less work producing the things they would have bought.

The CEGB has been running its oil-fired power stations overtime to save coal. Normally only one tenth as much oil as coal is used to generate electricity because it's so much more expensive. Oil and coal are now being used in equal amounts. The Tory war on the miners is costing £18m extra a week —which we will have to pay for in higher electricity bills.

Nor is that the end of the matter. Last year Britain had a balance of payments deficit of £716m. But North Sea oil provided a surplus of exports over imports of £6,875m—so the non-oil deficit was £7,591m. As Militant has so often pointed out, the headlong collapse of British manufacturing, measured by the loss of the home market to imports and the crisis in the balance of payments has been screened by the bonus of North Sea oil.

As a result of the dispute however: 'Between the first and second quarters the volume of crude oil exports

Critical levels Photos: Jacob Sutton (Gamma). Montage: Steve Edwards

August since movement by rail has been virtually eliminated, as disclosed in Militant (issue 713). The NUM estimate that about 1 million tonnes is being moved per month at the moment, the vast majority by lorry.

Coal burnt in July and August is approximately the same as in June, so if the NUM estimate is accurate, stocks fell by about 5.5 million tonnes in these two mouths. This means that stocks were just over 11 million tonnes at the end of August, and will be around 7 million tonnes at the end of this month.

The CEGB admit the critical level is 6 million tonnes, but some experts have put the figure higher, at 8/9 million tonnes. In addition, ALL.

Photo: Militant fell by 10%, the volume of crude oil imports rose by 50% and the surplus on oil trade declined from £2.3 billion to £1.5 billion." So oil destined for export to mask the chronic problems of manufacturing has been diverted to Britain to brow beat the NUM. Over a full year the balance of paynents would lose more than £3,000m (£3bn), which means a collapse of the pound.

### Intlation or

interest rise The government has tried to avoid such a fall in the price of sterling in relation to other currencies. If the pound falls on world markets it buys less imports by making them relatively more expensive. A higher cost of imports feeds through the economy as a higher rate of inflation.

The Tories are in a dilemna. The only way they can stop a f3bn a year Exocet blasting through their "counter-inflation policy' is by making the pound more attractive for foreign as pointed out in Militant, some of the existing stocks will be useless. If these factors are considered the crisis point could be reached later this month.

It should also be borne in mind that the above analysis is based on official figures. Careful study of them shows some interesting discrepancies. Overall, coal produced in June plus imports was 4.17 million tonnes. Stockpiles though increased capitalists to hang on to capitalists to hang on to despite the fact that there are despite the fact that there are less British exports to buy. less British exports to buy.

The way to do this is to The way to do this is to raise interest rates in the Ci- raise interest rates in the City of London. But high in- ty of London. But high interest rates are already threatening to choke off the feeble industrial recovery— firms find it more expensive to borrow and those with money find it more lucrative to leave it in the bank given the low level of profits. Higher interest rates means dearer mortgages and HP so less people buy houses and consumer goods.

### Government

borrowing The government in any case is going to have to keep interest rates up. They will need to borrow more, and have to offer a high interest rate, lo attract the money they increasingly need as a result of the strike.

The miners' strike means that the NCB is losing money and will have to borrow from the government. The CEGB is paying out to burn more oil and will have to borrow from the government. The NIESR estimate that the extra costs to the NCB alone will swell the Public Sector Borrowing Requirement by f billion in the first half of the financial year. There is a list of other such increases in public expenditure. Again that either increases inflation or raises interest rates.

The result of the Tory attack on the miners may well be to put in jeopardy the feeble economic upturn which is the government's only boast of light at the end of the tunnel." This is without power cuts on the horizonwhich will throw the whole economy into chaos.

By Mick Brooks by nearly 400,000 tonnes, excluding coal at power stations. The net amount of coal 'available' to be burned was therefore 3.77 million tons.

No comment The amount of coal actually used was 6.3 million tonnes, assuming steel output, and therefore coal used, was the same as June 83. The difference is about 2.6 THE contradictions of capitalist production are inescapable, even for the NCB accounts. Page four of the 1983/84 accounts reveals the NCB's big problem.

Some 16 million tonnes capacity of new mines is on the way, at Selby and Ashfordby etc. in the face of stagnant demand. This leads to the attempt to close capacity elsewhere. But as Andrew Glyn shows opposite that incurs massive expense and writing off the accummulated investment. Then there are expert predictions of increased demand for coal into the next century.

Energy needs planning. It can take ten years and hundreds of millions of pounds to build a new power station. Once built it can run for fifty years. But how much energy will be needed in sixty year's time. and where?

Oil, coal and nuclear power are the main ways of generating electricity. Apart from the safety aspeet, the true cost of nuclear power has been systematically concealed by governments eager to get their hands on enriched uranium for nuclear weapons. The price of oil has surged and sunk twice in the last ten years.

The Plan for Coal recognised that a modern industrial country needs a secure supply of safe fuel at a price which is is competitive and certain. It broke its back against the anarchy of the capitalist system. Primary energy demand in Britain is no higher today million tonnes, which can only be accounted for by a fall in the power station stocks. The official figure for this fall is 1.7 million tonnes, leaving 900,000 tonnes unaccounted for. There is a possibility, then, that the official figures considerably overestimate the level of coal stocks; the Tories have been noticeably quiet lately in claiming that the stocks situation is 'no problem' than it was in 1968, as is industrial production, as a result of recession. Although coal's share of this demand has been stable the new lowcost capacity being opened is at the moment surplus to requirements.

Such facts show that energy demand cannot be planned in an unplanned economy. The practical consequences for the British energy industry can be seen in chairman Norman Siddall's statement in last year's accounts: "Disposals to power stations increased but this was to meet additional stocking requirements as actual coal consumption at power stations was less than in the previous year."

### Coal mountain

Coal stocks at CEGB power stations increased from 15.1m tonnes at March 1982 to 24.1m tonnes at March 1983, then fell back to 20.6m tonnes at March 1984, although lost sales to the CEGB as a result of the overtime ban was about 5m tonnes. But for the dispute CEGB stocks would have been about 25½m tonnes when the strike began— nearly a third of annual consumption of 76.8m tonnes.

The Tories' lack of any rational energy strategy combines with their delusion that defeat of the miners will solve all their problems to produce economic and political chaos which merely mirrors the inherent chaos of their system.

Macartney

[page 8]

8 MILITANT 7 September 1984

----- pull-quotes -----

they lop off the over- subsidised' , 'ineffi- cient rump of the

Unplanned recession

← Sirs' 'solidarity-truth about steel outputTory law- police war →

Something wrong on this page?