Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

NUM response

No. 716, 14 September 1984 · pp. 5-6 of the scan · 573 words

The scan: Militant 716 1984-09-14.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 3.1x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 5]

water and gas. The union agreed to restore cover, but even then there was a 12-hour delay before the safety men were allowed in, causing further deterioration. Management now claim that it will take a year before the pit can be brought into production again. Miners regard this as an exaggeration, but accept that the pit has been damaged.

### Monktonhall

As at Monktonhall, it seems that management are prepared to see a pit close rather than stop strikebreakers from reporting for work. It has even been suggested that the reason for the Coal Board's much tougher attitude in Scotland is that they would be prepared to see the closure of the entire Scottish coalfield, and can therefore ignore the union when the withdrawal of safety cover is threatened. UNION ACTIVISTS are in a terrible dilemna. If they help management keep pits open at the same time as scabs are being brought in, the Board can reach the stage, as at Bilston Glen, where they can produce coal and provide their own safety cover. The union has then lost one of its best bargaining weapons. The strikers could begin to feel that there was no longer any point in staying out.

The withdrawal of safety cover was an angry and justified response to NCB provocation. To have done nothing would have seemed like giving in to the nanagement.

If, however, each time the Board claim that a pit is in jeopardy, safety cover is restored by the union, the original withdrawal will seem to have achieved nothing. So some union activists are now arguing for the removal of all saity cover, regardless of the consequences to the pit, so long as scabs are still being brought in. This, it is argued, will force the NCB to back down. It is, however, a massive gamble; if the Board are prepared to let the whole coalfield close, they might still refuse to back down and sit back and let the mines be destroyed, with incalculable consequences for the miners and the Scottish working class in general. For the union it is a "Catch 22". To keep safety cover on could mean letting the management seize the initiative and organise an accelerafing return to work; to take it off could mean the loss of all miners' jobs in Scotland.

But neither course of action is in itself going to win the strike. Even if the Board responded to the withdrawal of safety cover by making coalfield, a campaign to involve other unions in the fight is vital. It is easier to show these other workers how they are directly atfected, since the closure of the whole coalfield would cause job losses over a huge area of the Scottish economy.

Wider campaign To launch such a wider campaign should be top priority for the area leaders. To see withdrawal of safety cover as some sort of alternative "solution" would be a grave mistake. The situation will have to be carefully weighed up at each pit, when the issue arises. But on balance at this stage it would be better to maintain safety cover where necessary, while, as a matter of great urgency, convening mass meetings of the NUM membership and then the wider movement in order to broaden the struggle and lead the strike to victory.

[page 6]

Bosses football chaos •Clubs face financial relegation 6 MILITANT 14 September 1984 Players - mobile advertisements. AFNIA

← NCB sabotageNew season - higher prices →

Something wrong on this page?