[page 4]
THE THREAT by Nottinghamshire working miners' leaders to form a breakaway union has been eagerly welcomed by all the miners' worst enemies. Two rival unions within the industry would be a massive step backwards for every miner. This can be confirmed by the experience of an earlier such breakaway movement in the same coalfield, when George Spencer MP formed the Nottinghamshire and District Miners' Industrial Union. The damage done by this "company union" lasted for more than a Harworth lodge miners on NUM march in London last summer. Harworth pit was at the centre of the dispute in which Spencers' union was quashed by the Nottingham Miners' Association, in a ballot, a result ignored by the bosses.
iii) That the Industrial Union can be clearly seen in our movement should be allowed to nominate three today, calling for witch-hunts and full-time officials to the NMA's two. wanting to do deals with the Tories iv That the rules of the and the bosses and. for the lucky I HAD intended to write something about the first day of televised debate in the House of Lords. Unfortunately after half an hour I fell asleep. The human mogadon responsible for this was a particularly barmy bishop whose speech was incomprehensible until he eventually revealed he thought that the Government were a bunch of pretty good eggs. l understand that their Lordships had earlier discussed the issue of euthanasia, a subject clearly of more than passing interest to many of them.
The advocates of televising the House of Fossils see it as the first stage in the campaign to televise the Commons. Apart from the fact that Austin Mitchell is one of the supporters of the campaign, l can't see anything wrong with the idea (perhaps Austin is just hedging his bets for a future career as a commentator.) On the other hand if we are going to be scrupulously fair to the Tories you'd have to televise the bars as well.
In all the fuss about this 'important democratic breakthrough, I've hardly heard a voice raised about the credibility of the Lords. The media in this country are so servile that they never question the fact that two thirds of the legislature in Britain is composed of the monarchy and a second chamber stuffed full of the bootlickers of various Prime Ministers (past and present ), bishops(!) and the descendants of a motley crew of robber barons, murderers, land grabbers and petty tyrants of every description.
We are bombarded from every angle with propaganda about how the second chamber acts as a "bulwark against an elected dictatorship". This must be code for a landslide Labour government, for the Thatcher Government has not been noticeably "moderated" by the Lords. Even if you accept the argument about the importance of a second chamber (which I don't), it hardly decade.
AFTER THE defeat of the general strike in 1926, the miners gallantly fought on until November when they were starved back to work. The coal owners took their revenge. They had the upper hand; many of the activists never returned to work. The districts were isolated and the owners decided the conditions and wages.
In Nottinghamshire, which was the first area to crack, the employers had the opportunity to smash the influence of the Miners' Federation of Great Britain (MFGB) and its district organisation, the Nottinghamshire Miners' Association (NMA).
George Spencer a right-wing Labour Party MP and witch-hunter of his day was a Nottingham miners' official. He supported the banning of communists at the 1924 party conference at which he declared: "If there was one outstanding fact in world history, it was that nothing substantial had ever been accomplished by revolution".
### Local settlement
He vehemently opposed the communists, though the union that sponsored him as MP had elected Arthur J Cook, a declared 'Leninist' as general secretary Spencer opposed the continuation of the strike in his area, which was one of the more prosperous, and the local owners were willing to settle on favourable terms.
He began to make local settlements and was eventually suspended from the MFGB. The owners, understanding that Spencer would be safe, agreed to give him sole negotiating rights. So the Nottinghamshire and District Miners' Industrial Union was born with the blessing of the coal owners.
Attempts were made to spread the idea to other coalfields, notably South Wales, Northumberland, Durham and Scotland.
In the wake of the General Strike's defeat, the Tories passed the Trades Disputes and Trade Union Act 1927. Sympathy strikes were made illegal, the old offence of intimidation was revived from Victorian days, restrictions were placed on picketing and Labour Party funds from the unions were blocked. Spencer's union reflected the Tories' concept of how a union should act; it was nonpolitical-in other words anti-Labour and had no political fund Spencer's Industrial Union often reported collections for the NMA to management. In one dispute at Wellbeck colliery, the management forced all the miners to have contributions to the Industrial Union stopped out of their pay or face the sack. While the dispute was on, Spencer had agreed a reduced price list (amount paid to miners for coal produced). Similarly at Annesley, 200 men were sacked and were only taken back if they joined Spencer's union.
or a company union une In lustrial union's membersnip wa low-between 4,000 to 5,000 in 1927. In the following years it grew, but real support for Spencer's union was shown in the ballot organised by the TUC in May 1928: Despite intimidation, 32,277 voted to support the NA and only 2,533. voted for Spencer. The owners payed little notice to this ballot result.
The battle lasted 10 years. NMA membership declined from 15,740 in 1928 to 8,500 by 1935. But with the upturn in the economy the NMA began to grow; by the end of 1935 it had increased to 10,000.
The greater demand for coal meant that the MFGB influence began to increase. The national owners agreed to form a "Joint Standing Consultative Committee" which settled many of the outstanding disputes in the industry. The Nottinghamshire owners, because they never recognised the Federation, stood outside such a body.
The conflict between the two unions grew, with Spencer siding more and more with the owners, and came to a head at Harworth. In early 1935 the NMA had only seven members at Harworth out of a total workforce of 2,285. It began to increase. The year ended with 157 members and six later it doubled to 302.
There was much discontent at the pit, especially on dirt deductions. After a number of small disputes, the NMA conducted a ballot asking which union the men wanted •to represent them. Despite intimidation they won 1,175 votes against 145 for Spencer's union. The management refused to negotiate with them.
One owner, Captain Muschamp, voiced his view: "We want to adopt the German idea—if the government is to check future trouble it must put its foot down and put its foot down strongly... We carried on peaceably with the Industrial Union for ten years."
### Spencer's terms
Spencer was forced to negotiate with the MFGB. He would fuse but it had to be on his terms. These included:
i) That Nottinghamshire should be immune from strikes during the current agreement.
ii) That all local officials and collectors of the NMA who were not employed in the industry should be NI excluded from membership.
LAG LUIN amalgamated body should provide that political business could only be discussed at specially convened political meetings.
Surprisingly the MFGB accepted this formula as a basis for negotiation. An agreement was signed, but a Special Conference rejected the fusion on the above terms. A national ballot was taken and by an overwhelming majority a call for a national strıke was supported. Eventually a formula was found that diverted the strike and the fusion was accepted substantially on Spencer's terms. He was made permanent President until he retired in 1945.
Many men never returned to work at Harworth and many of Spencer's ex-officials supported victimisation of militants.
Did Spencerism die in Nottinghamshire? The answer to that question is no. Certainly it cannot die while we have in our movement men and women who put the interests of their careers before that of the workers. NOTTINGHAMSHIRE AREA hat Mr de.
Class collaborators like Spencer, Nava L... ones, being rewarded by their friends with a peerage. Until they are under the control of the membership and their wages are no more than that of skilled workers, this will continue.
The chief lesson of Spencerism today is that although ultimately the miners in Notts were won back to the national union, enormous damage was done to the conditions of miners, not only in that coalfield but nationally, because ot the division 1: - - 11-- 1within the heart of the industry.
It is vital that the NUM leaders today do everything in their power to persuade the Notts miners, not by threats of expulsion, but by debate and explanation, that their interests are tied up with those of their fellow workers in the other coalfields. A breakaway will be disastrous for all miners, but for none more so than the Notts miners themselves.
Peter Jarvis
----- pull-quotes -----
Gordon Bennet writes-
HARWORTH BRANCH UNITY IS STRENGTH