Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Debate of ideas: 'Marxism v Reformism'

No. 735, 8 February 1985 · pp. 6-7 of the scan · 417 words

The scan: Militant 735 1985-02-08.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 3.0x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 6]

came when an old bloke ranted and raved how he was on a steelworkers' picket line and a truck drove up with a load of "militants" in it with weapons. They jumped out and started fighting with the police and pickets, then they said: "We have to go picketing somewhere else" and drove off.

Then another truck drove up with more "militants" in it, but this time they had loads of their paper "the Militant' to sell.

At this point myself and comrade Potter were in physical pain resulting from an excessive reaction to these revelations. All in all it was a canny neet oot!

By Billy MILITANT reported last week how National Women's Committee member Margaret Creear received a warning letter from Labour Party National Agent David Hughes after debating Marxist ideas.

The meeting itself was a great success. Held in Preston under the title of 'Marxism v Reformism' Margaret Creear debated with Colin Sutherland. According to the reformists the only way Labour could be elected was if 'popular' policies were put forward, such as cooperatives, import controls, workers' control and "self management" by "persuading" company managers to give workers more say in running industry.

This was answered by a worker from British Aerospace who explained how the Lucas plan hadn't worked because the management simply turned around and said no to the workers' plans. Without taking all the power out of the hands of capitalism, all talk of 'workers' control" and "alternative production" was just academic.

At one stage a right-winger got up and told us that the British Parliamentary system was "the best we had". He was immediately answered by a comrade, who described the House of Lords as "a second-rate muppet show"

Comrade Sutherland had asked in a pamphlet he wrote (Trotskyists in the Labour Party): "Is life in Britain so bad that I am determined to help organise the overthrow of the state by revolutionary means?" Comrades who had some experience of low-pay, , unemployment, bringing up a ramily, etc soon dealt with this one. Margaret Creear explained the need to take over the 200 biggest companies-or else how could Labour pay for its socialist programme of decent wages, shorter hours, investment in industry?

During the meeting the letter Margaret Creear had received that morning from David Hughes was read out. This was answered by 53 local Labour Party members and trade unionists signing a petition protesting at the letter.

Forrester Margaret

[page 7]

• 8. February 1985 MILITANT 7

← What FELS stands forYTURC campaign gets rolling →

Something wrong on this page?