Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Editorial

No. 735, 8 February 1985 · p. 2 of the scan · 845 words

The scan: Militant 735 1985-02-08.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

This text was corrected by hand against the scan: transcribed from the scan of p. 2, 19 November 2026. The unsigned editorial, printed in a box under the Militant masthead in the first column, with no headline of its own (the title here is ours). The machine reading lost it: only its last words, "miners' titanic struggle", survive, at the head of "Molesworth show of strength". The editor's box below it is not part of the article and is left out. "misunderstand" is divided "misunders-tand" at a line end as printed; joined here.

THE MINERS' strike has brought to the surface all the finest qualities of the working class. Immense sacrifices have been made, enormous suffering endured, not for any short-term financial reward, but to save the jobs of the next generation and the future of communities.

They have refused to be intimidated by police truncheons, bribed by back-to-work bonuses or daunted by the lies of the Tory press. There is no way that the government and the Coal Board are going to trample the miners into the dirt. The strikers and their families have given too much already to let that happen.

It is a monstrous slander on the miners for the capitalist media, echoed by a section of the "left" on the movement's fringes, to allege that they have been crushed, and that the labour movement is now in the position it was in 1927.

At that time the miners had been starved back to work, after the betrayal of the TUC leaders led to the collapse of the general strike in 1926. The whole movement had suffered a massive defeat from which it took years to recover.

Today, inspired by the miners' fighting spirit, workers are taking on their bosses across a wide front. In the first eleven months of 1984, 30% more days were lost in strikes than in 1983, excluding the miners' strike. The CBI has revealed that the number of pay claims backed by industrial action rose by 50% in the past two years.

An employers' magazine Works Management has conducted a survey of managers in manufacturing industry which showed that three quarters of those questioned believed that a resurgence of shopfloor militancy in industry is likely: "A few organisations have already seen a return to unrealistically high wage demands, more shopfloor disputes (though most trivial) and attempts to re-establish restrictive practices which should have been obliterated."

Furthermore this militancy is paying off. According to the CBI, pay settlements in manufacturing industry averaged increases of 6.15% in the second half of 1984 compared to 5.65% in the same half of 1983.

Works Management correctly concludes that with "some easing of the recession, workers see the chance of better pay rises and less reason to co-operate with moves to improve efficiency".

It would be impossible to deny that the recession brought about serious defeats for sections of the trade union movement, especially in redundancies and victimisations. It is true that the Tories have been able to bring in draconian new laws to try and cripple trade union organisation and strength.

But this is not 1927. The trade union movement is still immensely powerful; its basic structure remains intact and workers are not only still fighting, but are achieving victories. Most of the provisions of the Tory employment laws remain unused. The bosses and their capitalist commentators still bewail the power of the unions to prevent the wage cuts which they would dearly like to see. The economy is wracked by crisis.

The fundamental problem is not the weakness of the workers' organisations, but the incapacity of the majority of those who lead them. The role of the right wing leaders in the TUC in the miners' strike has been as perfidious as in 1926. Lord Chapple actually recommended MacGregor's appointment as NCB chairman. They have consistently stood aside and refused to lift a finger to mobilise the solidarity action which would have brought victory to the miners.

A whole generation of union leaders found comfortable jobs in the post-war boom years. Negotiations with the management could, with the threat of strike action behind them, force concessions. They earned good salaries and lived a better life than those they represented. Now, however, the bosses are prepared to put the boot in, take merciless action against the workers and brush aside the trade union leaders. As a result we have seen the emergence of a new generation of class fighters, steeled in the fire of battle.

They are in the process of forging a new and totally different form of union leadership, which will spearhead the fightback, firstly on the industrial front, where battle is already engaged, but increasingly also in the political field, as union activists realise that their fight is not just with their management but the whole rotten economic system.

To bemoan the "defeats" of the movement, at the very time that 130,000 miners are in the heat of the biggest industrial battle of our time is not merely to misunderstand the reality of the situation. It amounts to a stab in the back to those fighting. Such predictions of gloom and doom, if taken seriously, would become self-fulfilling prophecies; their effect is to demoralise those in struggle.

The miners will not be affected however. Their fight goes on, and will continue to be an inspiration for the rest of the class. If the TUC will not move to organise support, it is time for the NUM leaders to appeal directly to the rank and file of the movement. They should never underestimate the strength of support for the miners' titanic struggle.

← Labour's right wing attack striking minerThatcher's Britain 1985 →

Something wrong on this page?