Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Father and Son' film one-sided

No. 735, 8 February 1985 · p. 5 of the scan · 1,020 words

The scan: Militant 735 1985-02-08.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 6.5x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 5]

Ellington miners voting to strike on 3 March last year.

Wednesday, January 23, 1985 17p TODAY'S TV: PAGE 14 Picket of Didcot power station last year. Oil is now being used increasingly at this and power stations, sometimes to 'sweeten' poor quality coal. Photo: John Harris (IFL III)

An example of hysterical Sun-style journalism which avoids anything like the truth. Sun 'mole' Richard Ellis got striking miners' confidence by trickery then attacked them with abusive outpourings none of which were backed by facts. JOHN CUNNINGHAM is a striking miner from Ellington Colliery, Ashington, Northumberland. His father, John Cunningham Senior was the Ellington Lodge Secretary who led the back-to-work moveWHEN IT comes to only tells half the story-the half that denigrates the NUM.

Since the strike began last year, the Fleet Street dailies have been full of stories about pit-mob violence' etc, while the super scabs have been portrayed as heroes. The truth paints a different picture:

• Yorkshire scab Ken Foulstone received great publicity when he took the NUM to court to force a national ballot. He received full police protection during his strike breaking campaign.

What you didnt read on the front page: Mr Foulstone will be appearing in a Doncaster court this month charged with two burglaries allegedly committed in 1977.

The Mail Papers such as the Mail on Sunday gave massive coverage to Yorkshire scab Stuart Spencer when his house burnt down in November, allegedly the work of arsonists. The Mail (25 November) described him as a "Victim of hate" and said: "Mr Spencer... accused the NUM of orchestrating the attack against him.

What you didn't read on the front page: After a full and thorough investigation, the West Yorkshire police have found no connection between the crime and striking miners or their supporters.

• The press and television crews descended on the home of Durham scab Barry Newton after he claimed three masked men threw ammonia in his face. Pictures showing Mr Newton's burnt hands and face were soon broadcast across the country.

What you didn't read on the front page: Following the police forwarding his case to the Director of Public Prosections, Mr Newton has been summoned to appear at Houghton-le-Spring magistrates court on 7 February. No one else has been implicated in the case.

• The Sun on 30 November told the story of Brodsworth scab Willy ment. World In Action broadcast a programme 'Father and Son' centred on the Cunningham family, on Monday 28 January. John Cunningham junior, a Militant supporter, gives his assessment of I HAVE just spent the most terrify. ing five weeks of my life-discover. ing the truth behind the pit picketline violence.

she stuari Sun exclusive BUSH VE SABOTAGE KNOW * * REVOLUTION ARIES :

Parker. It portrayed Mr Parker as an unsung hero who was going through a 'terrying ordeal' of violence from "thugs" and "bully boys", referring to striking What you didn't read on the front page: Shortly before the Sun article, Mr Parker made a threatening phone call to his branch delegate Kevin Hughes. Unfortunately for Mr Parker, Kevin Hughes taped the conversation. On it Mr Parker said: "I've gone and got myself a gun. If anybody touches any of my family, I'm going on the rampageand I'll go to jail for it."

When told that homes of striking miners had been attacked, in particular the branch secretary's, Mr Parker replies that if he had any trouble then "his (windows) are going through again—and I'll do it." THE Phot 3 YEARS OF TAX CUTS AHEAD - Page 2 The tape was given to the police but they have dc... nothing about it-unlike in Staffordshire recently when striking miners' leader, 51 year old Eric Lippit, was the programme:

It did not give a balanced picure, which World in Action is meant to. In my opinion the programme set out with the intention of painting a picture of a community split D Pearson down the middle-as my brother Patrick put it in the final stages of the film, a "civil war without guns". This is not the case. The strike has actually brought the community closer together. Families are more united than divided. This positive aspect never came across.

The programme also portrayed the strike as being lost, a picture of gloom and doom, despondency and demoralisation. There were a number of blatant lies. The narrator said: "Pickets watched helplessly as scab busses go in and coal comes out." To date very little coal has been brought to the surface, never mind moved from the pit yard.

When I was interviewed, hours of film were taken. I said a lot about the reasons why we were on strike. None of this was used in the final edition. They were more interested in such things as why I ignored my mother on the street, or why my father didn't tell me of his decision to return to work.

It said in the programme 800 men followed my father back to work. This is a lie. Only 100 more actually went in that week. The rest have gone back in dribs and drabs since then.

Wy wife was a bit upset, like when the papers had reports about me in. It was totally biased, there was not one shot with Brenda in. No mention of the tireless work done by the support group in relieving hardship in the community. It also appeared that she had no opinion on the strike or my father's return to work.

Most of the lads thought the programme was biased, a few thought it fair. After the programme the telephone never stopped ringing all night with people calling in support, miners from other areas and even long-lost friends. There were a couple of exceptions, the usual scabs.

On a lighter note, one scene showed me coming out of my house for picket duty. This was actually filmed at 5 pm in the evening, because the World in Action team couldn't get up early enough for the picket line.

other

----- pull-quotes -----

reporting the miners' strike, the Tory press

databa c Arthur's army

← No return to SpencerismPicket scab oil transport →

Something wrong on this page?