Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Ponting trial rebounds on Tories

No. 736, 15 February 1985 · p. 4 of the scan · 950 words

The scan: Militant 736 1985-02-15.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 5.0x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 4]

Tory minister's racist past OVER 40 people lobbied the Mansfield Labour Party Executive last Thursday to protest against the possible expulsion of Militant supporter Paul Shawcroft and Notts striking miner Graham Naylor. Striking miners from four pits were represented on the lobby together with one Womens Action Group, and members of NALGO, USDAW, The executive decided to report to the General Committee that they were not satisfied with Paul Shawcroft's 'explanations'. This was because he admited organising a Militant public meeting in support of the miners, and refused to give an undertaking not to sell Militant in public. From the comments at the executive meeting, it was clear that this was a political attack on the ideas of Marxism.

Letters of protest to: JT Pearson, Mansfield CLP Secretary, Copies to Paul Shawcroft, 36 Hollington Way, WHEN IS an election not an election? When it's in Nicaragua of course- or at least that's what Mrs Thatcher seems to believe. Last Friday she took an hour off from wrecking the British economy to lecture Sergio Ramirez on democracy. Mr Ramirez was recently elected as vice-president of Nicaragua and is a very popular politician in his own country (which is more than can be said for Mrs Thatcher).

In a nutshell, the bargain basement Boadicea explained to Ramirez that she was concerned about the arms build-up in Nicaragua and criticised the Sandinistas for 'giving support to suppression'. What's more, Her Regal Superfluousness went on, future relations with Her Kingdom depended on those naughty Nicaraguans cutClive Ponting found not guilty Andrew Wiard (Report) THE PROSECUTION of Clive Ponting was blatantly political and has blown up in the government's face.

Last summer it was ministers, notably Heseltine, who demanded prosecution instead of just allowing Ponting to resign. Ponting only confessed to leaking the documents after he had got a promise he would not be prosecuted.

It was Thatcher's press secretary, Bernard Ingham, who stated that the government hoped the case would be taken by a severe judge. This was only a jest, he said, but nevertheless he got his wish; Justice McCowan presided at the trial.

Before the trial began, the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, implied in a radio interview that Ponting was guilty. At one time last Wednesday, Mc Cowan wanted to stop the trial and direct the jury to convict. He was pursuaded not to, but his summing up left little doubt of his views.

The jury was the one PREDICTABLY, the Tory press tried to present the contemptuous statements of Junior Employment minister Alan Clark-who described blacks as coming from "Bongo-Bongo land"' —as a 'slip' and a 'gaffe' They seemed more concerned that the comments of this minister, incredibly in charge of race relations (!), had been leaked to the press.

But his remarks weren't a one-off slip of the tongue. They are in keeping with his reationary, racist views. The January issue of Searchlight, the anti-fascist magazine, chronicled some of his other rogue card, but everything possible was done to try and get them to bring in a guilty verdict. Although Ponting was not charged with handing over documents of national security, an atmosphere close to a treason trial was created. The jury were vetted. Parts of the trial were held in secret, and sensitive documents about the Belgrano sinking were introduced and the jury sworn to secrecy.

Guilty The judge told them that they should bring in a guilty verdict if they found that Ponting's actions were detrimental to the interests of the government, as the interests of the state and the government were the same. The jury disagreed. As Ponting stated afterwards: the jury's verdict "means that the way defence ministers conducted themselves in the early part of 1984 was against the national interest."

He had pointed out that ministers, notably John Stanley, ha d tried to mislead Parliamen by ordering two statements:

* In 1972 shortly after his selection to stand for Plymouth Sutton he said immigrants should be told: "You cannot come into this country because you are not white."

### Bans 'unfair'

* In 1981 he complained to the Home Secretary that it was not fair that National Front marches are banned while "young blacks damaged shops, terrorised the white population, shout objectionable slogans to the monarchy and try to prodraft replies for Parliamentary questions--one truthful, one not-so that ministers could pick and choose which answer to give. None of this was on "national security" grounds or to save lives, just the political necks of ministers who since the Belgrano sunk had been misleading Parliament.

The response from the Tory right-wing to Ponting's acquittal has been predictable. Tory MP John Stokes thinks: "the result must put into question the selection of juries in London"

The labour movement should demand the immediate sacking of John Stanley and Michael Heseltine for their role in the Ponting case. It must demand the repeal of the Official Secrets Act and it must actively campaign for public documents to be made fully available to the public. It must call for a full public enquiry into the sinking of the Belgrano and the subsequent cover-up. As long as this government remains in office, no-one's rights are safe. voke the police.

* In 1982 he called tor increased recruitment to the police to deal with the "gangs of 50 young blacks looting shops in broad daylight."

During the last election the Tories attempted to woo black voters (remember 'Labour say he's black, we say he's British?). The fact that this character with his weird fantasies about race can rise to a ministerial post, show the Tories' real bigoted attitudes towards black and Asian workers.

----- pull-quotes -----

Gordon Benn writes-

← District Party and MPs back HattonSam Bond assaulted →

Something wrong on this page?