Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

WEIR HANDS WERE BLUE ASIEVE THEY PR WASIEVE THEY

No. 736, 15 February 1985 · pp. 9-10 of the scan · 1,516 words

The scan: Militant 736 1985-02-15.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 11.9x body type, 3 line(s), left edges within 0.004.

[page 9]

dustrial revolution. Glyn MONETARISM IS the creed of Margaret Thatcher and her cronies. Until ten years ago few people had heard of it, but over the past five years it's done a lot of people a lot of harm.

Briefly monetarism is the theory that inflation is mainly caused by an increase in the money supplythe quantity of money in circulation. Monetarists believe that the money supply has been pumped up in the past to pay for increased government spending.

Thatcher came to power in 1979 committed to a "counter-inflation strategy" of cutting government spending and reining in the growth in the money supply. The 1979 White Paper on Government Spending began "Public expenditure is at the heart of Britain's economic difficulities."

Five years later inflation is down but public spending is up from 39½ % to 42½% of the national income! The 1979 dogma and programme lie in ruins but still the Tories want cuts in public spending.

### Boom collapses

Monetarism then is just a screen for the real policy of the Tories. They are not motivated by dogma but by the interests of their class— Thatcherism recognises that the good days of the post war boom have gone for good. The only way to save the bosses' bacon is to cut wages and the social wage of public spending. Monetarism is just another stick to beat the workers with.

During the post war boom production had gone up enormously, state spending had risen by leaps and bounds and relatively full employment had given workers unprecedented improvements in their living standards. The illusion CAPITALISM spread that increased state intervention had caused the boom and that by spending money, if necessary by running up debts instead of balancing the budget, the government could 'fine-tune' the economy.

This theory was associated with the name of the economist Keynes. It was particulary congenial to right wing Labour leaders who longed to make their peace with the ruling class. All but the Marxists forgot the simple fact that what goes up must come down.

Keynesian failure The prolonged crisis beginning in the 1970s shook the economic establishment to its roots. The Heath government in Britain for instance came to power in 1970 committed to a policy of confrontation with the unions. In 1972 they were decisively defeated by the miners and changed back to traditional Keynesian policies of pumping money into the economy to restore the fortunes of British capitalism.

An explosion of easy credit however did not lead to renewed investment in industry. By 1974 half the bank credits were pouring into the purchase of commodities, office properties which bumped up the rate of inflation not that of production.

The reason was not far to seek. The rate of profit in manufaturing was at a record low point. Capitalists could make more money in speculations than production. For the first time mass unemployment and increasing inflation existed side by side.

Thatcherism emerged in response to the failure of the Tory government of 1970 to 1974. The central problem was identified as restoring the rate of profit, pumping more unpaid labour out of the working class. Wets, Heathites and Keynesians of all persuasions were derided as "yesterday's men" . This is quite true as long as we remember that the monetarists are the day before yesterday's men. THE WORLD economy was moving into recession in 1979. But its effect was far more bruising in Britain because of the economics of Thatcherism.

Between 1979 and 1982 one fifth of British manufacturing industry was destroyed. Production actually fell by more in those years than it did in the great depression of 1929-32.

Leaner and fitter industry really meant leaner and weaker. When the world upturn finally came in 1982 British manufacturing was not geared up to respond to the challenge. Large chunks of it just didn't exist any more.

Investment fell by 10%. As for the improvement in productivity the Tories boast about, that was only achieved by a shop floor offensive on conditions and protective practices in a climate of fear engendered by fear of the sack. That is why as the upturn in the world economy does start to touch some sectors of production, workers fight back.

### Worse in Britain

Productivity over the past year has been more or less stagnant. British capitalism is underinvested and uncompetitive as ever.

No more easy • money! The Tories jacked up interest rates to restrain credit. As a result money flowed into sterling, which stood four years ago at : $2.45 to the pound.

It was impossible for British manufacturing capitalists to sell abroad at this rate of exchange. Britain slid into the position of being a net importer of manufactured goods for the first time since the inThe world upturn from 1982 offered some respite. If British interest rates were high, American THE TORIES don't stand a dogs chance of sticking to their self inflicted spending targets. A few months ago they had £2.7 billion in the contingency fund, now it's £500 million overdrawn.

One of the main reasons is of course the miners' strike. This has cost the government £1,400 million in lost revenue so far, with another £500 million down the drain if it carries on till the end of March. The strike makes the projections for cutting subsidies to the NCB, Steel, BR and the Electricity Board disappear into the middle distance.

Trade, industry, energy and employment are all 29% overspent. Housing is 24% over the top. Councils have spent £2 billion more than they should.

The government says it will force local authority spending down to target but they have never been able to achieve that so far. If they fail again they will be another £2.5 billion adrift.

There is no way that public sector workers will allow their wage levels to be pinned at 3% for the next 5 years, as the White Paper assumes while inflation starts at 5% and goes up. Social Security benefits will go over target for the simple reason that unemployment is bound to go over the unrealistic target level of 3 million for the next five years.

This month's grim dole figures show they've already started to do so. Every extra 100,000 jobless TORY MACE cyLl rates were higher. So sterling slid against the dollar, till the slide became a panic.

Is there no truth in the tenets of monetarism? It certainly is the case that the policies of the Heath government in pumping money into the economy added inflation to the problem of recession and made these worse. But the main reason for the recent fall in inflation rates is not monetarist policies but because the world economic crisis has caused a collapse of commodity prices to their lowest level since the 1930s.

It is also true that government spending has increased both abAndrew Giyn's pamphlet gives the Marxist alternative to the failure of monetarism and Keynesianism. It is an excellent introduction to socialist economics.

Price £1.20 (inc p&p) from World Socialist Books, 3-13 Hepscott Rd, London E9 5HB. means another £200 million on budget costs.

There are two ways the Tories can cut down subsidies to the nationalised industries. One is to allow monster rises in gas and electricity prices - which will feed inflation. It will also force workers to fight to defend living standards, and so wipe out the government's estimates on their wages costs for the next five years.

The other way is to bump up the sales of public sector assets. The Tories hope to raise £2.5 billion next year and £2.25 billion in each of the two years after that. This will mean an unprecedented looting of public assets.

Bargains vanishing In the first place to raise that amount of money in a set time is like selling your stereo to buy a packet of crisps. Secondly all the really juicy bargains have already been sold and some of the industry left is essential but basically unsaleable.

Nevertheless Thatcher and Co are hooked on asset sales. They need the short term cash to balance the books. But what are they going to do when the saleable assets run out? A combination of departmental clashes and the inherent failure of monetarist policies means the White Paper will remain forever a dream of what might have been, not a working control on government spending. solutely and as a proportion of national income since the Second World War. But this is roofed in the decline of the capitalist system, despite its superficially ruddy glow until recent years.

Governments, both Tory and Labour, have been increasingly forced to step in to provide all kinds of handouts, subsidies and tied markets for decaying monopolised capitalist class. If money policy runs away under the strain, that is only the reflection of deeper and more fundamental problems for the system.

Tribune's Alternative Strategy or Socialist Plan by Andrew ITANT PAMPHLET

[page 10]

Youth Trade Union 15 February 1985 MILITANT 7

----- pull-quotes -----

~ WENT TO SMARTER (THE JUMBLIES BY EDWARDLE He Halian.

CAPITALIST CRISIS

← Next three yearsYTS-we need unions →

Something wrong on this page?