Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

WHITEHALL PROBE JOBS FOR BOYS'

No. 736, 15 February 1985 · p. 3 of the scan · 1,142 words

The scan: Militant 736 1985-02-15.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 5.0x body type, 3 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 3]

Background to smear story in this specific case. I WILL firstly outline for the benefit of the District Party, because of some of the lies in sions over this development.

I was approached approximately nine months ago by the firm concerned (Merseyprideed) and also by UCATT, a joint approach, about the possibility of going for a Superstore in the enterprise zone. At that stage no name was mentioned of the superstore and at that stage my initial reaction was to be opposed to it.

At every single discussion that happened after the initial representation, Tony Hood and John Nelson, Chairman' and deputy chairman of planning, were involved. From then on in, USDAW and the trade unions which had any sort of interest whatsoever were invited along to every meeting.

That should cut across the lies and distortions, that somehow secret meetings were happening behind closed doors. Those meetings were open and within the best traditions of the labour and trade union movement, where all sections who had an interest were involved.

It wasn't until after the first three meetings that the name of ASDA even came up. From the moment that ASDA became involved as an option the G&M were involved, because except for the Widnes store every other ASDA store in the country has complete and total G&M membership. The final meeting we had was chaired by Tony Hood, in the presence of officers, where ASDA came along and made their presentation. That's very briefly the chronological order in which things happened.

EVERY COMRADE in this room has a principl ed opposition to Enterprise Zones. But as three different comrades have mentioned, it is analogous to the Manpower Services Commission schemes we have debated in the past. I can remember a whole number of us even prior to *79 when the Labour Government was here, making impassioned pleas against MSC projects. And again in '81 and again in '83, every time a new MSC project comes about. But once they are there, what we have said in this party is, let's make the best of it, let's get the best trade union organisation and let's get the best conditions.

The reasons why UCATT, the T&G, the G&M and the EETPU have come in and given their support to the Speke development is very simple. It's because a thousand jobs can't be ignored, that a fl million rate can't be ignored and that a f20 million development with all the ensuing implications cannot be ignored.

Could you imagine, if last week the EC (of the DLP-ed) had gone against it, could you just imagine if leaks were to get out that we were going to speak against it, what the headlines in the Echo would be? 'Labour Party rejects a thousand jobs!' The Liberals and the Echo are so opportunist they'd come in on anything we were doing and go the other way, so let's not kid outselves that there's any sense or consistency in their argument.

Also, as has been said there is no evidence to sup: port the idea that jobs would be lost as a result of this development. To take a thousand jobs now is an absolute certainty. To say we are going to lose jobs is a possibility. It's a gamble justified by the terrible plight of Speke.

The second point is the trade union commitments we've got. The G&M have had an assurance from ASDA, in black and white under a national agreement, that they will have a closed shop and nomination rights, (to jobs-ed) which is something they have got in no other store in the country.

The T&G and UCATT have been given assurances as far as the building work is concerned. If we rejected planning permission and it went to appeal (to the government-ed) and we lost it, as every bit of evidence suggests we would, ASDA would have no worries at all about flying in the face of all the assurances they've given to us and to the unions.

There is no way that this party can now turn round and ignore the Tory onslaught that started over this. We are in a position where we have got to say that yes, we still oppose enterprise zones, but we also fight for the best deal for the working class just as we do in the MSC schemes, indeed capitalism itself, whilst continuing the political struggle to end them.

Felicity Dowling:

THE DEBATE at the District Labour Party produced a very close decision against the development. There is hefty trade union support and as a Speke councillor the prospect of a thousand jobs and new hypermarket is obviously very attractive for an area with massive unemployment and a run down shopping centre with a very poor range of goods.

On the other hand there is clearly genuine concern about the effect it could have on other shopping areas along with a rather mechanical interpretation of our general policy position of opposition to Enterprise Zones and all the other Tory gimmicks. Though I must say it was a bit hard to swallow when two of last year's council renegades who voted with the Liberals and Tories started lecturing us about sticking to principles.

What's most annoying is that the Liberal and press campaign produces so much noise about one proposed develpment when the miracles that have already been achieved in Liverpool are ignored.

Our Urban Regeneration Strategy has already made great improvements in Speke and elsewhere. Old blocks of flats have been knocked down and houses and bungalows built. trade unionists when they are in fact carrying out part of Labour's public policy of involving the trade unions more closely in avoiding discriminatory employment policies. Unsubstantiated and unproven allegations of interference with a housing application were blazoned against an individual councillor.

The council's right to employ the candidate it considered best qualified for the post of Race Relations Officer was ignored and the protests of a vocal minority, cynically used by Labour's opponents, given the full press treatment. Even the cost of keeping a 16 year-old in council care was turned into a scandal. Liberal demands for enquiries into Labour's alleged abandonment of proper procedures, even Derek Hatton's attendance allowances, have been Liverpool's daily news diet for months. alliance over the past week or two with resounding votes for a 24-hour strike in support of Labour's refusal to implement Tory cuts.

The Housing Department EETPU/AUEW Direct Labour Organisation voted by 298 to 2.

GMBATU branch 218, the flaggers and paviors voted by 350 votes to 2.

TGWU drivers, voted 150 to 0.

GMBATU branch 24, 200 to 0.

GMBATU branch 200, the road sweepers and bin men, voted 750 to 3.

TGWU and UCATT in the DLO voted 1,000 to 0.

----- pull-quotes -----

the press, exactly what happened in the discus-

← Jenkin blocks housebuildingDistrict Party and MPs back Hatton →

Something wrong on this page?