[page 14]
Militant's Cowle Correspondent IN WRITING this reply, I'm assuming that Mr Simpson of Coventry is genuinely confused over the events surrounding the BL dispute at Cowley last November.
Apart from his 'glaring inaccuracies' concerning the events of the strike, Mr Simpson's main contention is the old chestnut, beloved of every cynic and sceptic, ...the working class won't struggle' (apart from the miners, of course), ...nothing wrong with the leadership but it's the blokes who have no backbone... " etc.
Workers ground down by struggle often project their own despair or pessimism onto the whole of the working class. Mr Simpson is no exception. After all, leaders of the Labour Party, the TUC, and all the groups and sects on the left (with the exception of the Militant) were all arguing in the wake of the 1983 general election that the working class had shifted to the right; that Thatcherism had subdued the working class.
The miners' strike has so overshadowed events since then as to make that election result seem like a lifetime ago. Yet we shouldn't overlook the struggles of other groups of workers which took place prior to and during the current miners' strike: Post Office Engineers; print workers; civil servants; shipyard workers; dockers and railway workers to name a few.
These struggles, rather than conjuring up a picture of servility are graphic examples, as Militant explained in advance, of workers being compelled to struggle against job losses, low wages, bad conditions etc.
That these actions weren't successful can be traced to the role of the leadership of the trade unions concerned. Lack of combativity on the part of the working class often has its roots in a justifiable lack of confidence in its leaders. BL is no exception to that.
The strike in Austin-Rover last November which lasted two and a half weeks (barely a fortnight", says Mr Simpson) has to be seen against a background of massive job losses (over 80,000 since the mid-70s), victimisation of stewards and militants, speed-ups, and a series of defeated strikes.
The fact that Austin-Rover workers took strike action at all is a testimony to their anger and determination. Clearly, Michael Edwardes and his contemporaries in BL management didn't have the workforce "well weighed up"
### Leadership
The workers at Austin-Rover were compelled by low wages, attacks on trade union rights and shopfloor conditions, to again take the road of struggle. However, its one thing to enter the ring to take on your opponent, it's entirely diferent to square up to him with both of your hands securely tied behind your back. Yet that's what happened at BL. The quickest glance at the events surrounding the strike show that to be the case.
For example, the National Negotiating Committee recommended strike action following BL's derisory pay offer. But that was immediately undermined. Ken Cure, one of the AUEW reps. on the JNC said the strike call was *ill advised", and that the "pay offer was reasonable." No doubt four and a half per cent of his inflated salary was!
To make matters worse, at the crucial moment in the strike, the AUEW, rather than carry out TUC policy of defying the 1984 Trade Union Act under which BL were saying the strike was illegal (no ballot held) declared the strike unconstitutional and therefore "unofficial"
BL didn't have to split the workforce; the AUEW leaders did it for them. Although it should be said that many rank and file AUEW members remained on strike despite their leaders.
Naturally, the EETPU leaders went one better. They ordered their members back to work. To their credit EETPU members at Longbridge twice voted against their national official's instructions and stayed out. At Cowley, many electricians, włile willing to join the strike had great difficulty in locating their elusive convenor even to hold a meeting!
The largest union in BL, the TGWU, while publicly stating their intention to defy the courts failed to advance a strategy to achieve this. For example, no attempt was made to prepare the whole of the TGWU membership for strike action in defence of union funds and their trade union rights.
At BL, the T&G were simply left holding the line. Unfortunately, BL workers have been along this road Picket line at Austin Rover Longbridge before. During the washing-up time dispute in 1983, the workers at Cowley stayed out for a month only for the leadership to cave-in and sign away their precious 3 minutes.
The lesson is clear, to struggle under today's conditions, wnen the employers are on the offensive, backed up every inch by the Tory government, means the trade union leaders cannot expect to win •by asking their members to 'sit it-out' A clear strategy for winning has to be put forward.
In the mass meetings during the week of the BL strike the union leadership should have stepped up the action at BL's other plants, and prepared the ground for natic nal strike action by the whole of the TGWU.
A strike cannot stand still, it has to go forward or it fails. When the T&G leadership failed to argue a strategy for victory the workforce had no confidence in winning. Indeed, what was to be gained from convening mass meetings when no new offer had been made by BL and when no new initiative was being offered from the unions? By 3-1, the workforce voted to cut their losses and return, bloodied but unbowed.
Contrary to Mr Simpson's verworks sion of events "thousands of workers" didn't ignore picket lines. Only a few hundred scabs went in and production was brought to a halt.
The problems facing BL workers won't disappear. In a depressed economy, with lack of investment by BL management the spectre of plant closures is raised. In these conditions a new generation of shop stewards tempered in the harsh school of struggle will be created.
In the halcyon days of British capitalism when reforms could be won relatively easily, to be a shop steward could be something of a 'perk' Today , however, gor steward runs gr eat risk of icti mis tion by manag ement.
History of struggle Contrary to Mr Simpson s narrow view of history, the working class has always had to struggle long and hard to achieve democratic rights; these struggles occasionally reaching revolutionary proportions. Yes, there is to be found Mr Simpson's "obsequious" tradition, typified by the present right-wing reformist Labour leadership; but there is also the John Harr revolutionary tradition of the Chartists, Red Clydeside and the It's that latter tradition which is being re-learned by the working class in the 1980s and I for one am confident that the working class will build on the experience of the ' 80s and the '30s to arm itself with programme and leadership capable of ensuring the capitalists can never return us to that misery again.
Finally, I must decline Mr Simpson's kind offer to work for Walt Disney. The buggers at Disneyland keep going on strike!
[page 15]
22 Febrüary 1985' MILITANT 15