Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Pit traitors become media heroes

No. 737, 22 February 1985 · pp. 4-5 of the scan · 1,627 words

The scan: Militant 737 1985-02-22.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 8.2x body type, 3 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 4]

THE GOVERNMENT, the Coal Board and the ruling class everything possible to break the miners' strike.

The "back-to-work" movement was meticulously planned and through a network of scabs, NCB officials and advisers with links the Board and the Tory government.

A supporter of the strike who has been in contact with one of those involved in the National Working Miners' Committee (NWMC) has sent Militant a detailed account of how the strike-breakers were organised. He has asked to remain anonymous in order not to lose the source of his information, so that he can continue to uncover these activities and expose them to the NUM and the wider labour movement. Additional information has come from the February edition of Labour Research.

"They are wiling helpers ofathe Tory Party and the Coal Board grass isn't greener on the other side of the fence, it is positively emerald on the other side of the time tunnel.

The point is that there appears to have been a severe outbreak of Good Old Days syndrome in certain parts of the labour movement. First infected and Master of Ceremonies is undoubtedly the Right Reverend Eric Hobsbawm but others— especially during the course of the miners' dispute-have also become carriers.

Symptoms to watch out for include statements like: 'you'd never find anyone crossing a picket line in the old days' , or 'solidarity isn't what it used to beeveryone's too selfish these days' or 'violence on picket lines is completely alien to the historic traditions of British industrial relations' (the last one being a particular favourite of leaders of the Labour Party).

The fact is that there has never been a labour movement 'golden age', a fantasy implicit in the handwringing posture of those writers and academics to whom labour history is a costume drama, filmed and assessed in black and white.

There have always been individuals who have been prepared to scab on their workmates just as solidarity action of any sort has never been produced like a rabbit out of a conjuror's hat. And if anyone thinks that state violence in industrial disputes is new then they know nothing about British labour history.

Instead of yearning for mythical 'Good Old Days' when men were men and picket lines were sacrosanct, we need to learn and absorb the lessons of the past in preparation for the future. Marxism is the science of perspectives -it's not a question of joining the dots for socialism. The most important lesson from the last year is that thousands of miners and their families have been prepared to endure incredible hardships in order to have some control over their lives and to fight for a future for their children. The ruling class have tried everything and yet they cannot crush the miners. The struggle will have enormous repercussions over the next few years and the working class, not blinkered academics, will be centre stage. IN ABOUT the third week of the strike, Roland Taylor started to cross the picket line at Shirebrook colliery.

He contacted the Sun, Nottingham Evening Post, Radio Sheffield, Radio Trent, BBC and ITV and gave interviews and statements, claiming that the decision of the Derbyshire NUM to call a strike was undemocratic, as the voting in the area was, by 16 votes, against the strike.

The management at Shirebrook gave him an office on the pit top and encouraged him to do everything he could to break the strike in Derbyshire. This took the form of more newspaper and television interviews and telephone calls to men from Shirebrook to persuade them to cross picket lines and return to work.

The area director, Ken "Holy" Moses, gave him a free hand to travel around the county and meet other men who were willing to be strike-breakers, all on NCB pay plus expenses.

Roland was also meeting solicitors to start legal proceedings against the Derbyshire NUM and making pathetic appeals through the media for any miner who did not agree with the strike to donate 50p towards a fund to start legal proceedings against the NUM. This fund did not meet with much success.

The solicitors did find funds from other sources that were sympathetic towards breaking the strike. One was Sir Hector Laing of United Biscuits, which donated £43,000 to the Tories in 1983. Roland was given time off work, along with two others from DerAA V ... byshire, to go to London on at least two occasions to consult with a QC, Nicholas Lyell, Tory MP for MidBedfordshire. This resulted in a High Court action and the strike in Derbyshire was declared unlawful.

At about the same time, Chris Butcher ("Silver Birch') was making TV appearances, giving interviews and travelling all over the country (all expenses paid to arrange meetings with other miners to encourage them to become strike-breakers. The Derbyshire group merged with others and they were holding regular meetings at the Green Dragon pub at Oxton, near Mansfield. At one of these there was some dissent and several members resigned because the avowed aim of the self-elected leaders was to defeat the strike and bring the NUM leadership to its knees.

The Coal Board gave these men every encouragement, wages and expenses and many were away from the pit where they "worked" for days and weeks at a time.

organised with both The leaders were provided with telephone-answering machines to take messages and to arrange meetings while they were away from home.

Meanwhile meetings with other traitors in the Notts and South Yorkshire NUM were being arranged by Tim Bell and David Hart. Tim Bell is a former Saatchi and Saatchi director and MacGregor's public relations advisor. He wrote and designed one of the brochures for the NWMC in the Saatchi and Saatchi office.

Hart is a wealthy property developer who has been an adviser to Thatcher. He has placed adverts in the press for the working miners, organised the banner proclaiming "Come off it Arthur!" at the TUC in Brighton and written articles in The Times. On 26 January he wrote: "The time for negotiated settlements is past... The nation wants to see him (Scargill) defeated." Hart's links with MacGregor have a long history. His father used to work with MacGregor, who has been a family friend for years. Since the strike began, they have been in constant touch. Hart was regularly to be seen at NCB HQ. On 2 August he accompanied MacGregor to the Channel 4 Chris (Silver Birch) Butcher. debate with Scargill, and it is claimed in the Daily Mirror (18 October 1984) that he boasted he had "held up the script for MacGregor."

The National Working Miners Committee (NWMC) held its first informal meeting on 11 August at the Castle Donington Guest House, near East Midlands Airport. On the following day (Sunday), Peter Walker, Leon Brittan and Tom King used the BBC and the Sunday papers to appeal to the miners to return to work. That same afternoon, they held another meeting at the Longlands Farm, Knightwick. Their host was Captain Edward Evans. Among those present was Graham Turner, a Sunday Telegraph reporter who helped draft a letter which was sent to all the striking miners in the country.

David Hart attended the meeting on 11 August, where he was introduced as "D.H. Lawrence" , and another meeting of the committee on 19 August, in Castle Donington, at which the NWMC was formally set up. This meeting appointed Colin Clarke, a Notts. miner, as President, John Blessington as Treasurer and Bob Copping as Secretary.

David Hart now says that he was only involved before the NWMC came into existence, which he says was in early September. After several advertisments over their name appeared in the press, John Blessington (now the secretary) even denied knowing David Hart and when asked if Hart attended NWMC meetings replied, "1 don't know that he did."

According to Bob Copping's minutes, however, Hart attended at least four of the meetings, two of them on 25 and 28 August, after the meeting on 19 August which formally set up the NWMC.

On 25 August, Colin Clarke, John Blessington and Bob Copping met David Hart in the Hambleton Hall restaurant, near Oakham, Leicestershire. This restaurant is owned by Tim Hart (David's brother), who once shared a house with MacGregor when they worked for a New York investment bank.

On 28 August, the NWMC returned to Castle Donington. David Hart was again present. It was here that the secretary Bob Copping became suspicious. 'He was introduced to me as the money man" says Copping. He was handing over sums of money up to £300 to be used as floats. Copping argued that as secretary he should keep a record of all money spent. Hart replied that as their solicitor (David Negus) should deal with all financial matters, the committee members were not required to sign cheques.

Increasingly anxious about Hart's involvement, Copping resigned on 5 September. He said that it was an anti-union organisation with a conservative orientation, undermining the trade union movement, which was prepared to preach democracy, but not to practice it.

These kind of men that call themselves working miners, are more like travelling salesmen, but instead of selling goods, they are selling Tory propaganda. They are completely "brain-washed" and are willing helpers of the Tory Party and Coal Board.

These are the traitors that are destroying the NUM, using the Courts to reach their goal, and at the end of the day will cost thousands of jobs in the mining industry. Also they are depriving the Labour Party of funds and fencing the door to allow the multi national companies to gain privatisation of anything that is left of the industry.

[page 5]

22 February 1985 MILITANT 5

← Miner tells of police "justice'Fight Tories YTS conscription plans →

Something wrong on this page?