Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Disciplined for backing party policy

No. 738, 1 March 1985 · pp. 7-9 of the scan · 1,870 words

The scan: Militant 738 1985-03-01.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 3.2x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 7]

at meetings of over 4,500 local authority workers only 11 people have voted against strike action on the 7th. Tony Benn will be speaking at the Rally outside the Town Hall.

In an interview with The Times, 19 February, Enviroment Secretary Jenkin, says he has "the firm backing of the Cabinet to take direct action if local administration in Liverpool appeared later this year to be breaking down. There was no question of bailing out councillors". He was made to eat his words last year, and if there is a firm united struggle he can find it becomes an annual diet. NEWCASTLE CITY Council Labour Group voted to start serious disciplinary proceedings against Councillor David Archibald as it was alleged that he had broken Labour group's standing orders.

The heinous crime he had committed was to speak at an LPYS public meeting in favour of national and district Labour Party policy. He spoke in favour of a strategy of non compliance in refusing to increase rents and rates to compensate for government cuts in grants and setting a deficit budget to demand back the money stolen by this Tory government.

However, when asked, they were unable to state which standing order had been broken and since when has it been an offence to speak at a meeting of the labour movement in favour of Labour Party policy? The real reason for this attack is political. This year Newcastle just escaped ratecapping, but will almost certainly be rate-capped next year and will face cuts of at least £15 million leading to the destruction of services and the loss of thousands of jobs.

The proposed disciplinary action against Dave Archibald must be seen as part of a process of weeding out any potential opposition to rate-capping and of preparing the ground to make those cuts.

By Alan Docherty (Newcastle Central CLP)

[page 8]

= Labour must defend jobs and si Tories wage war on coun MILITANT March 1985 LOCAL AUTHORITIES are facing a devastating crisis. They are being called upon by the Thatcher Government to preside over the wholesale destruction of services established over two generations.

The full implementation of the Tory cuts in council spending will mean an estimated 75,000 redundancies nationally with a knock-on effect of as many as 125,000 in addition! Council workers have no alternatives but to fight.

All the gains of the past-wages, conditions, jobs and services—are being systematically whittled away. The burden of the decline of British capitalism is being placed squarely on the shoulders of working people.

But the council. workers are fighting back. Their response has been to forge powerful new instruments of struggle, the Joint Shop Stewards' Committees. On 7 March, when the threatened councils meet on "Budget Day", council workers will be involved in an unprecedented campaign of leafletting, rallies and demonstrations. They are not prepared to see the Tories massacre their jobs and the vital services they provide.

Grants slashed Part and parcel of this attack by the Thatcher Government is the slashing of public expenditure and the destruction of "wasteful" local services. The government, through its Environment Secretary, Jenkin, has slashed the grants to local authorities.

The main Rate Support Grant has been reduced from 65 pence in every pound a council spends (1975) to just over 48 pence in the pound today.

They are being prevented from taking the "easy" option of jacking up rates to compensate for the reduction in Rate Support Grant by "rate capping" laws and government firancial penalties.

They are being pushed to raise rents and slash services when councils have to provide more, not less, to the growing needs of the community.

Over the last 5 years alone, the government has taken £9,000 million from local authorities. Jenkin has stated that rate-capping would "save" £400 million. The Tories are planning to cut in half the capital spending on housing in England in 1985/86, at a time of chronic housing shortages. Whereas there were 148,000 new houses built in 1975, less than 30,000 are planned this year!

But together with the cuts in Rate Support Grant have come, since 1981, harsh government spending targets and a penalty system. The Tories now estimate the needs and standard of service for each local authority-the Grant Related Expenditure Assessment. If councils spend above this target they are subject to increasing financial penalties.

Roughly, for every 1% a council spends over its target, the government will claw back nine pence in every pound the council receives in grant! (ie if you spend 10% over your target, 90 pence in every pound you receive will be taken back). In July 1984 additional harsher penalties for overspending were announced. These penalties have slashed a council's revenue and crippled its spending plans.

Liverpool City Council, although not rate-capped, faces a financial crisis due to impossible targets and Jenkin's reneging on the deal made last July. Liverpool is being told to reduce its budget by over 16% or £43 millions! Such a cut would mean a rate rise of over 200% and 6,000 redundancies.

Although only 18 councils have been officially "rate-capped', all other authorities are in the same boat-they are in effect self ratecapped by government penalties. What authority could raise its rates by 100% or 200% to save its services? It is caught between the devil and the deep blue sea!

Services destroyed THE TORY GOVERNMENT, using the excuse of protecting the rate-payer and reducing 'overspending' by councils, pushed the Rates Act through Parliament last June. This gave the Tories the power to set centrally expenditure targets for any council spending more than £10 million a year, and fix a legal limit on rates that can be raised to pay for spending.

As a result, "rate-capped' authorities are being directed to slash their budgets dramatically. (18 councils were picked out for rate-capping—16 of them are Labour). Originally Hackney was asked to cut their spending by 30.2%, Brent by 19.5%, Leicester by 18.7% and Merseyside by 17.8%. Such cuts would destroy effective services in these areas completely.

Lewisham, for example, has produced facts to show the effects of rate-capping. They would have to cut £7.37 million on social services which would mean: the closure of all four day centres for the elderly, the closure of half its 40 luncheon clubs, two holiday and training centres for the disabled. Homehelp hours would be cut by half!

In Southwark, the council needs to spend £131 million to keep services at their present overstretched and inadequate level. Southwark is the tenth most deprived area in the country, and yet the government estimated that it needs only £108 million-an effective cut of over £20 million just to stand still.

Since 1979 Southwark has had £100 million taken off them by the Tories-that's nearly £500 for every man, women, and child in the borough. The Tory motto is to hit hardest those Labour authorities that have the most deprived area Photo: Militant CLOSIN Children join the fight to save vital services.

Tory opposition RATE-CAPPING has nevertheless not had the unanimous backing of the ruling class. Opposition from within the Tory Party has been centred around the exPrime Minister Heath.

These "wets" recognise the dangers of abolishing local authority autonomy: a future left Labour government could use these powers to drive Tory councils into line, and all opposition to cuts would be focused on the national government, without the odium being placed on local authorities.

The issue will be posed in sharp terms—to the Tories' disadvantage. These "wets" are not interested in saving jobs or services, but in how to best carry through the cuts in their long term interests.

Conference defied UNLIKE THATCHER, Jenkin, and the rest of the Tory leaders who have ruthlessly defended their class interests, the leaders of our Photo: Militant movement have run for cover.

Completely rejecting the decisions of Labour Party Conference, instead of placing themselves at the head of struggle with the Tories, they have sought "respectability" in capitulating to the Tory laws.

Neil Kinnock, Jack Cunningham and the rest of the Front Bench are repeating the false arguments of last year. The Labour leaders' advice has been for councillors to remain in office at all cost, try to minimise with "a dented shield" the Tory cuts, and remain within the law.

It is a re-run of the lack of leadership last year when Cunningham's advice was that "we should not become obsessed with Liverpool(!)...Trying to bring about confrontation is not way forward(!)...I don't think the party should advise councils up and down the country to break the law. I don't think mass defiance of the law is the route to electoral success..." He then greeted, along with the Tories and Liberals, the six Labour renegades who intended to vote against the Liverpool Labour budget as "brave and sensible" people!

At the first wiff of defiance of Tory laws, our leaders take cover-or rather criticise those who are prepared to give a lead. Incidentally, it was not the Liverpool City council that sought "confrontation" , but the Tory government, who had already stolen £120 million from the City. The crisis was not created by the Labour Group, but by the imposition of staggering financial penalties by the government.

How could Liverpool have produced a "legal" budget last yearor this year for that matter? Only by breaking all their election promises and carrying out massive cuts (6,000 redundancies), slashing local services or a 220% rate rise. In other words, abject capitulation to Jenkin and the Tory government.

Our leaders have unfortunately failed to learn the rich lessons of the Liverpool struggle-that the Tories can be defeated when faced with a grass-roots movement and a firm leadership prepared to go all the way in defence of working people.

Of course, the Tories have used the choice words of our leaders with relish. A Conservative press release (15/11/84), states: "Any councillor surcharged will not be indemnified. As Labour's front bench spokesman (Cunningham) has said, "1 do not think any such guarantee can be provided by the Party" "

The trade unions created the Labour Party to represent the real interests of working people, not as a vehicle for a posh parliamentary career.

Our leaders owe their positions to people who defied unjust class laws (like George Lansbury who went to jail) and sacrificed everything to build the movement.

Far from frightening away support, Liverpool City Council's defence of working people built a mass movement, culminating in the day of action on March 29 of 50,000 workers. Despite accusations of being an electoral albatross, last May, Labour won a sweeping victory in Liverpool with a further seven gains, to the eleven gains the previous May. Sixteen of these were at the Liberals' expense.

The Labour vote in Liverpool

[page 9]

nolog naigo naigo Anaigo nuign nino & noig 190 100 поїда nolgo nolgo VE naigo naiga naigo 101 kg nulgo подо Massive demonstration in defence of councils in London last January From the resolution passed at the 1984 Labour Party conference...

Conference believes that the duty of Smith rvices noigo malgo. vulga nolgo naloo i mango nolgor Lur mongo nulgo WHOS MOOD naigo March MILITANT 1985 mult nolga поіда Igo Photo: Mark Pinder

← Blackburn attacks workersLiverpool's example →

Something wrong on this page?