[page 4]
THE COLLAPSE of resistance to the Government's ratecapping law by the GLC has given the Tories a big boost in their campaign against local councils.
Despite all the brave words about the GLC and ILEA defying the government and setting an example to other councils their Labour majorities crumbled in the face of the threat of legal action.
The background to this ignominious defeat is the simple fact that despite all the heroic words and gestures the majority of GLC Labour councillors had no intention of putting themselves at risk by seriously struggling against the government.
### Symbolic
Ken Livingstone told the Greater London Labour Party conference that a number of GLC councillors had only agreed to support the Party's 'no rate' policy because they were banking on enough Labour right wingers voting with the GLC Tories to enable a rate to be set, thereby eliminating the threat of legal action. This policy of verbal, symbolic opposition with no risks, already seen once in practice in 1982 with the GLC's climbdown over the Law Lords ruling against the original Fares Fair policy, was undermined at the end of February when it appeared that the GLC Tories had found a way of legally abstaining on the crucial vote on whether or not to set a rate.
This threw the GLC Group into panic because it meant that there SOUTHWARK COUNCIL rejected ratecapping at its special meeting on 7 March.
Every Labour councillor present voted for the 'no rate position. Before the meeting a demonstration of well over 1,000 people marched to Peckham Town Hall to lobby councillors, and any waverers were left in no doubt about the strength of feeling in the local trade unions.
A series of deputations addressed the council meeting representing tenants, welfar: groups, black organisations and the local Labour Party. The packed public gallery gave very vocal encouragement to the Labour group throughout the long six hour meeting.
After the motion was passed 49 votes to 13, Labour councillors and the gallery burst into 'here we go and the Red - Flag. Policemen outside looked bemused as the singing crowd left the building at 1.30am.
A small minority on the Labour Group has already indicated however, that they will not do anything illegal. Asked for his view on the future position of the Labour Group, Council HANDS was now a real chance that the GLC and ILEA might not set a rate which would lead to possible legal action against the GLC members carrying out Party policy. This legal action could have involved a 5 year ban on holding public office, thereby blocking the parliamentary hopes of some GLC members like Livingstone The resulting splits in the GLC Labour Group were publicly exposed for the first time at the London Labour Party Conference over March 2/3. Basing himself on the fact that the GLC and ILEA, unlike the local London borough councils, legally had to set a rate by March 10, Ken Livingstone argued that the GLC members could only be expected to break the law and refuse to fix a rate if the borough councillors also took illegal action on 7 March, the day when all the threatened Labour councils had previously agreed to Photo: B.
uA. -of the truth...
No person in the movement has the privilege to say one thing in private, and adopt populist attitudes in public. They should be consistent in both. "I've told my group nothing I haven't said in public. The group has accepted them up till now."
Local trade un: ons are Tory attacis meet. Livingstone, knowing that many Labour borough councillors had as little intention of putting themselves at risk as many GLC Labour councillors had, demanded the impossible of the London Labour boroughs (given the make-up of their Labour groups) in order to frighten the majority of the GLC Labour Group into agreeing to set a legal rate. Livingstone's misfortune is he had to be the first Labour council leader to be seen to buckle under the Tories' threats, thereby letting other council leaders indulge in strong rhetoric against the GLC before their own councils caved in.
In order to justify his position, of both being in favour of setting a rate and sometimes enjoying the luxury of voting against a rate, Livingstone is employing a mixture of Neil Kinnock's HANDS OFF naigo THE MET an attempt to say that the GLC is now following a 'deficit budget' strategy. The final rate which the GLC set means a further cut of £55 million over and above what the government was demanding.
At the Greater London Labour Party Conference Livingstone declared that if a rate were set by the GLC the Labour Group would sit in that council chamber for as long as it takes week after week, line by line voting down any proposal for cuts in jobs and services'. Yet while rigorous opposition to any plans for cuts has to be shown in the council chamber, the battle will not be finally won there. Councils are under attack from the government and only a mass movement can hope to defeat the Tories. But unfortunately the collapse of the
Ken Livingstone speaking at London LPYS 1985
Conference -despite all their verbal defiance, the majority of GLC Labour councillors backed lown from serious struggle.
Labour GLC's rate-capping behaviour of leaders nas only served to undermine the building of the mass movement.
They should have clearly denounced those Labour GLC members who were not prepared to follow the example of the miners and make personal sacrifices in the struggle against the Tories. Instead many GLC leaders were, in the days running up to the budget meeting, trying to win support for the plan drawn up by Reg Race,(the ex- Labour MP who now has a well paid GLC job), to avoid a clash with the government, but which would have meant cuts in staffing levels.
Any idea that the GLC is now following the strategy argued for by Militant supporters of councils passing a 'deficit budget' is completely wrong. The GLC and Merseyside County Council's idea of a deficit budget is not to mobilise a mass movement but to muddle through the financial year. Last year Liverpool City Council campaigned for a deficit budget in order to popularly explain that the government was responsible for the council's crisis and use it as a lever in order to build the mass movement, not as a way to dodge a battle with the Tories.
The collapse of resistance resistance to and the some GLC Photo: R. Green (FL)
by the four big rate-capped authorities is a blow for other Labour councils under attack, but inese councils 11must not give up the struggle. No Labour councillor should use the GLC's cavein as a justification to give up the struggle. Every effort must be put into mobilising the working class in preparation for the coming Tory attacks on these councils.
If some more Labour councillors try to back out of the struggle the council leaders must clearly call on the rest of the movement to denounce the fainthearts and intensify the struggle to win back the money the Tories have taken from the councils and protect jobs and services. The events of the past weeks have shown once again, as Liverpool did last year, that the key to defeating the Tories lies in building a mass movement with a clear, principled, noncareerist leadership.
(Bob Labi was a member of the Greater London Labour Party Executive from 1971 until a campaign by the pro-Kinnock Labour Coordinating Committee and pro-Livingstone London Labour Briefing finally succeeded in removing him at the GLLP 1985 conference.)
----- pull-quotes -----
OFF OFF COUNTIES THE GLO nalgo
COUNTIES ST 'dented shield' argument and