[page 8]
JOHN TOCHER, AUEW No. 11 divisional organiser spoke to Militant about Terry Duffy's recent comments in the Times on the union's presidential election, in which he was personally attacked.
The most striking thing is the arrogance and contempt that the right wing have for the union its membership and constitution. They treat the union as their property. Clearly they are frightened that the union will go back to the members. But it is the membership who must decide.
I disagree with the policies of both Gerry Russell and Bill Jordan, but in some ways Russell may consider he has those rank and file struggles, which were defeated, altered the balance of opinion inside the NUM to conduct the 1972 and 1974 battles and out of them the victories which the miners obtained.
It's that relationship between the struggles of the ranks to change the opinions and actions of the leadership, and the fact that when the leadership calls for action it obtains a much bigger response than we can ever get as rank and file militants-that's the struggle that we are in at the present time.
I'd go further. One of the things that saddens those of us who have spent so much of our lives sat in smoke filled conferences of the unions and the Labour Party over the years, and which the Broad Left has to understand, is that for far too long we have used ourselves as an electoral machine, to get this person or that person onto an executive, as general secretary or leader.
We have to have troops on the ground. No matter how good a socialist Tony Benn, Arthur Scargill or anyone else may be,