Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Why the GLC the GLC's acceptance caved in

No. 741, 22 March 1985 · p. 5 of the scan · 689 words

The scan: Militant 741 1985-03-22.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 8.7x body type, 2 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 5]

leaders have been attempting to explain away this defeat. Fundamentally the argument of Ken Livingstone and his supporters boil down to two issues. Firstly that the lower tier councils (in London the Borough councils) were seeking to avoid taking any illegal action and secondly that the GLC could have implemented a 'growth budget' within the government's rate limits.

### Posturing

Ken Livingstone, in a report to the Greater London Labour Party Executive, attacked the "posturing of some Borough leaders" who adopted a policy which allowed them to "duck the issue of illegality" at their 7 March budget meetings but "left the GLC and ILEA out on their own" because of the legal requirement for the upper tier authorities (like the GLC and ILEA) to set a rate by 10 March. Livingstone, while being accurate about the unwillingness to fight of some other Labour councillors, totally ignores the fact that three days before the GLC finally set its rate one council, Hackney, had already 'gone illegal' by refusing to set a rate in defiance of a court order to do so. Surely the GLC could have followed Hackney's example and shown the way for the other Labour authorities? (see Militant last week)

No Labour GLC member can claim that this is a new issue. The Labour manifesto for the 1981 GLC election, in a section written by Militant supporters, stated that a Labour GLC 'understanding that the Tory government does not listen to pleas but only responds to pressure Ken Livingstone. will appeal to the Labour and Trade Union movement to take action, including industrial action, to support its stand. Mass opposition to Tory policies led by a Labour GLC could become the focal point of a national campaign, involving other Labour councils, against the cuts'. Unfortunately the capitulation of the majority of Labour GLC members means that this manifesto commitment will not be implemented.

The second argument that the GLC had the possibility of agreeing a 'growth budget' within the government's rate limits is, at best, an easy excuse for leaving the other ratecapped councils isolated.

### Manoeuvres

Livingstone says that his deputy, John McDonnell, was responsible for the GLC not spending its full 1984/5 budget but does not refute McDonnell's arguments in an October report (which Livingstone quotes from a different context) that "for us to be able to use the capital fund and other financial devices to stay in office it would necessitate the government turning a blind eye to these manoeuvres. The obvious motive for the government's complicity would be to divide us from our Borough comrades thus enabling Jenkin to put down more easily the Borough revolt."

It is clear that one of the reasons why many Labour GLC members felt it right to work within the Tories' limits is that they see the battle against the GLC's abolition as already lost. But even if there will be no GLC after April 1986 to be ratecapped the local councils will still be trapped in the vice of spending cuts unless the Tories are defeated. The GLC's 'beggar my neighbour' attitude to the local councils has only served to strengthen the Tories' hand.

No strategy It is this aspect of the battle which totally undermines Livingstone's complaint that many GLC members "felt we had been misled and manoeuvrer" by talk of massive spending cuts if the GLC accepted ratecapping. The battle was not solely about the GLC it was about all the local authorities which the Tories are attacking.

GLC members George Nicholson and Valerie Wise said in the Morning Star, 16 March, that there was "no real discussion" on the strategy to be adopted by Lahour councils. There is a certain element of truth in this. In October 1984 the GLLP Executive defeated by 21 votes o eight the deficit budget' strategy put forward by Militant supporters and from that time did-not discuss any more the political issues raised in the struggle. Certainly there was no discussion of these issues at the GLLP'S annual conference earlier this month.

But it is also clear that preparations were being made for some time for a

← Militant gains support in LiverpoolLEA workers reject cuts budget →

Something wrong on this page?