Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

CPSA 'left' and right unite not to fight Tory law

No. 742, 29 March 1985 · p. 15 of the scan · 687 words

The scan: Militant 742 1985-03-29.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 4.8x body type, 2 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 15]

The NEC's victory, was ON THE advice of rightwing General Secretary Alistair Graham and TUC General Council member Ray Alderson, the CPSA National Executive Committee decided, by 11 votes to 10, to reverse the previous NEC decision and comply with the Tories' anti-trade union legislation in this year's Civil Service pay campaign.

The special meeting of the NEC on Monday 25 March was called to discuss the union's response to the government's High Court injunction against the one-day stoppage on 1 April and selective industrial action. The injunction was granted on the grounds that consultation with the members had not been in conformity with the Trade Union Act 1984.

CPSA members will bitterly resent the Tories' interference in the democratic affairs of the union and question why the NEC voted to overturn their previous decision to defy the Tories' anti-trade union laws.

The CPSA is one of the most democratic unions in the TUC. It has traditionally consulted members on national issues through workplace meetings, where votes are cast by show of hands or secret ballot depending on the wishes of members in the branch.

Early voting returns from CPSA branches show a majority for action. This explains the haste with which the Treasury solicitor issued the writ to CPSA headquarters on Friday, giving notice of a High Court hearing on Thursday 28 May.

The debate at the NEC centred around a proposal from Alistair Graham that the current consultative exercise be abandoned and replaced by a ballot that would satisfy the provisions of the Trade Union Act 1984 and be completed by Wednesday 10 April. He also argued for the need to persuade SCPS and IRSF to postpone their one-day strike to coincide with CPSA's on Monday 15 April.

TUC General Council and Communist Party member Ray Alderson added an ammendment calling for separate ballots of CPSA members involved in the regional disruptive action due to start on 2 April. These ballots would also accord with the '84 Act.

In a speech of which Pontius Pilate would have been proud, Alderson attempted to argue that opposition to the Tory laws agreed at the NEC meeting a fortnight ago was no longer tenable. In other words opposition to Tory laws was alright unless the Tories tried to use the law against us!

A procession of Broad Left '84 and right-wing speakers pleaded with the National Executive Committee not to defy the law. Mick Duggan, leading Broad Left '84 member, argued that TUC and CPSA policy of opposition to the Tory's employment laws were now out of date and should therefore be ignored.

Militant supporters argued that the priority must be how we can best win a 1985 pay campaign, but pointed out that it is now impossible for a trade union to embark upon a serious campaign of industrial action without the Tories finding some pretext for declaring the action illegal.

We argued that conducting the consultative exercise in compliance with the 1984 Act was no guarantee of avoiding a conflict with the Tories over their anti-trade union laws. The use of the law and the resultant threat of fines, sequestration and against individual union officials were all clearly designed to scupper the union's plans for an effective campaign of industrial action to defend members' living standards.

In spite of these arguments, Graham's motion and Alderson's amendment scraped through by 11 votes to 10. On 27 March we learned that CPSA had called off the ballot on regional disruptive action-just as we had argued it would have to. The SCPS, quite understandably, refused to accept the logic of having disruptive action in advance of the main ballot. This brings Alderson and Duggan (who seconded the admendment) into line with complete acceptance of the Tory laws against trade unions.

The spineless approach of Broad Left '84 and the rightwing has played into the Tories' hands. But whilst the NEC decision was a setback, all CPSA members must now work doubly hard to ensure we secure an increased majority for industrial action in the reconvened membership ballot due to start next week.

(CPSA National Executive, personal capacity)

← Battle looms over Post Office jobsFight Tory laws →

Something wrong on this page?