[page 6]
THE TORIES' proposals on the use of non-branded (generic) drugs in the NHS are predictably meeting with strong opposition. The major drug companies are worried that their monopoly of the NHS market could be threatened by cheaper imported drugs.
The Tories are not interested in improving the Health Service, only in cutting costs. Non-branded drugs may be cheaper but controls and standards in their production, often in other countries would be difficult to maintain. In any case the exploitation of the Health Service by the multinationals would only be transferred from one group to another.
As the only real alternative, socialists have demanded the nationalisation of the drug companies to carry out research and provide cheap drugs to meet the needs of the NHS and the population as a whole. But it is also worth asking how drugs are used in medicine. Neville Hodgkinson, author of Will to be Well reviewed in The Guardian (8 February) argued that the big drug companies are interested in perpetuating the use of some drugs to keep up their profits instead of research into the causes of the disease in the first place. Many drugs have an active ingredient which relieves the symptoms of the disease for a while, until the disease itself becomes more acute. For example, drugs which control arthritis relieve the pain caused by the extra wear on the joints. But the pain has a practical aspect in stopping over-use of the joints and allowing the bloodstream to carry away the waste and debris caused by wear and this pain 'alarm' can be suppressed by drugs.
Of course many arthritis sufferers are thankful for pain-relief-but dustry instead of looking at the real causes of disease. He concludes that these causes are completely 'internal' and that it is our own "troubled thoughts, feelings and actions which create the fertile bodily territory where illness can enter and flourish" This is totally unsatisfactory to millions of people who need medical care.
Undoubtedly there is a close connection between mental well-being and physical health, but as Hodgkinson himself points out there is a great need to establish the real causes of disease instead of depending on the treatment of symptoms with drugs. This will need a drastic increase in medical research, in a direction not steered by the drug companies' desire for profits. It must also be part of a massively expanded health service now under threat from Tory policies and which increasingly can't be afforded by the capitalist system.
[page 7]
29 March 1985, MILITANČš