[page 2]
In Malaysia last week, Thatcher was gloating how she had "seen off" the miners. "We resisted that year-long strike and one outstanding achievement was that, among trade unions in Britain, not one gave support, because "We are now getting new leadership from moderate trade unionists," she claimed, "and that augurs well for Her openly contemptuous attitude towards the magnificent struggle of the miners and all those thousands of workers who did support them has angered trade unionists. She has revealed her true nature. This is the language of class war and it will only harden the resolve of workers to prove just how wrong she is if she thinks she has brought the trade unions under her thumb.
The miners' strike opened up rifts within the Tory Party and the ruling class. It brought about an eight per cent swing from Tory to Labour in the opinion polls. It has resulted in a deep loathing of Thatcher amongst previously non-political workers. If she regards that as a comolete victory, what would a defeat for the Tories Workers will answer Thatcher in the mighty struggles of the coming months. Already teachers are in the midst of an unprecedented struggle, civil servants are balloting on industrial action. In manufacturing industry, where Thatcher believes that unions have learned the lesson of "moderation" , average earnings have, according to the CBI, grown by 8.5% a year, more than double the rate in the USA, Japan and West Germany.
Not only is the movement not cowed; it is being hardened in the heat of battle. Without conceding the industrial struggle, workers are also turning to the political arena, to force Thatcher out of office at the general election.
At least Thatcher's remarks were entirely typical. Less expected is that a similar view on the decline of union militancy is taken by Eric Hobsbawm of the Communist Party in another chapter of gloom and doom about the state of the labour movement in the pages of Marxism He ridicules those who claim that "the movement hasn't had serious setbacks, mainly because the unions are in excellent shape." "This is baloney" he says, "anybody who belives this in April 1985—anybody who believed it at the peak of the miners' strike-is living in "It is an insult to the intelligence as well as to the devotion, loyalty and heroism of British union militants to pretend that they haven't taken a good few beatings over On the contrary, it is Hobsbawm himself who is insulting the union militants with remarks like this. Of course he is right that there have been defeats since Thatcher came to power; no Marxists have denied that. The role of Marxism, however, is not to deplore the workers' failure to win their battles, but to explain the reasons for those defeats and point the way forward to victory.
He however sees no hope of victory. His article is Parents call for the sacking of Honeyford. steeped in pessimism and defeatism. Yet he concedes that we are at a time "when the contradictions of capitalism are more visible and potentially catastrophic than ever before in Britain and the World." He cannot disagree with the genuine Marxists that the objective conditions for establishing socialism are present. Yet nowhere does he examine the subjective problems, in the leadership of the movement which have led to defeats.
The "intelligence, devotion, loyalty and heroism" of the workers is not in doubt. The leadership of the trade unions and Labour Party has however been inadequate.
Hobsbawm not only fails to recognise this crucial factor, but his ideas fortify this leadership. If you know that you are going to lose anyway, why bother to fight on to victory? Hobsbawm is not merely an observer with a wrong analysis; his pessimism positively helps to bring Mass unemployment has reduced the total number of trade unionists, but as the teachers and civil servants are showing, militant trade unionism is spreading to new layers of society. The setbacks of the last few years may have discouraged a small number of trade unionists, but far more, like the young miners, have learned important lessons, have become more politically aware, as a result of the class warfare being waged by Thatcher.
David Basnett, a right-wing union leader, has understood better than Hobsbawm the processes at work, when he talks of the prospect of insurrectionary trade New, young trade union leaders will sweep away the old. Marxist ideas will be brought back on to the agenda and will come to dominate the thinking of the trade union Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office. Publishea by Militant; printed by Cambridge Heath Press (TU) Ltd., 3/13 Hepscott Road, London E9 5HB. ISSN 0144-9275 class war it the Daily Mirror have lept to the defence of Ray Honeyford, the headmaster currently suspended in Bradford. "The bullyboys of the they were learning the facts of life." race relations industry have claimed their first martyr" screamed the Daily Express. the future." "A disgraceful episode"
brought through by a "bunch of local ayatollahs who have made common cause with left wing yobs" shouted the Yorkshire Post.
He is portrayed as a liberal trying to do the best for his pupils. But what are the facts?
Honeyford is a headmaster of Drummond Middle School in Manningham, a badly off working class have implied? area of Bradford. 90% of his school students are Asian.
Yet he is a contributor to the Salisbury Review, a journal of the extreme right-wing of the Tory Party. The storm which led to his suspension HONEYFORD Today.
a time warp."
the past six years," he adds.
----- pull-quotes -----
LUT LIT