[page 29]
Book reviews:
Book Reviews
OF
LUT
By Wolfgang Leonhard Published by Ink Links,
price £5.95
Reviewed by John Pickard
social policies of the Communist Parties, and, later the dissolution of the Comintern itself.
The regime of the school was arrang ed so that nothing could divert the students' attention from their tasks: character-building was as much a part of training as the political line. From time to time the students were subjected to the humiliation of public "self-criticism" when long-forgotten remarks or Jokes were brougnt up analysed and deemed to be some sort of profound political deviation that had to be corrected. The students were strictly forbidden any alcohol or association with the opposite sex: even the students' own 'free time' was organised so that they all sat round stiffly and seriously singing German folk songs. (It reminded me of the Flash Gordon film when the wicked Ming exorted, "all my subjects will rejoice and be merry...on pain of death"). Failure or expulsion from the school meant a total loss of position and prospects, indeed one of the expellees is later seen as a beggar.
The lectures, essays and not least the "self-criticism" sessions taught the students to say as little as possible to anyone, and when it was necessary to speak, to carefully weigh and measure the significance of each word, so as not to transgress the line.
Even in this cosy bureaucratic haven the spectre of Trotskyism loomed large. On the day of Trotsky's death a popular festival was suddenly announced. A worker told Leonhard.
"Do you know what some of the workers in the factory are saying? They say that this festival has been announced now just because of Trotsky's death.
'I did not reply. In spite of the end of the purges, it was still too dangerous to talk about Trotsky. I thought it interesting, however, that in August 1940, thirteen years after Trotsky's expulsion from the party and eleven years after he had been exiled from the Soviet Union, there were still a few workers who did not believe the official version of Trotsky's death and considered Stalin capable of celebrating the death of a revolutionary by a popular festival."
It was quite clear that the students and the Komsomol members played no part whatsoever in determining exactly what the line was: there was not one iota of what could be called free debate and discussion. Even hard facts and information were restricted to those 'above' . Leonhard noted how the circulation of information was restricted
'I BEGAN to realise that I was now released from all the burdensome difficulties and adversities which I had experienced before. No more sleepless nights at railway stations. No more struggling to find a niche. No more trotting around offices. No more starvation. " Thus Wolfgang Leonhard entered the Russian bureaucrat's world of special shops, chauffeurdriven cars, private hotel suites and all the other perks and privileges.
His book, , "Child of the Revolution" is an autobiography of his own move from Germany to Russia in 1935, his rise through the Stalinist bureaucracy and his subsequent defection to Yugoslavia in 1949. It is a fascinating account of the workings of the system and well worth reading. Leonhard's book is not a dry political analysis of Eastern European Stalinism: on the contrary, it gives the reader a life-like description of the training of important functionaries; we see the system through the eyes of one who was involved in it.
When he went to Russia as a 13 year old, Leonhard had enormous illusions in the 'Soviet' system, fostered by his own family's involvement in the German KPD. Despite all the insecurities of the purges-his own mother disappeared in 1937—he remained a loyal supporter of the Communist Party and the Young Communist League (Komsomol). The attitude of many young emigrés was similar to his: the struggle against "Trotskyism, Zinovievism" and various other forms of 'sabotage' was absolutely justified, even if one or two individual cases of imprisonment seemed to be rather difficult to understand. Leonhard's years at school and college were years of unstinted faith in the Party line.
It was later in the Comintern School that the workings of the system
Wollengieonhard
became more apparent to Leonhard and he realised that there was a 'niche' for him. At the school, émigrés of various nationalities were trainea for about a year in the political line of the Comintern, in order to do politica work in their home countries. Ihe political line of the Comintern was hammered into the students day l and day out. Every single word had its significance, whether from Pravda or from the lectures. Like today's 'Kremlin-watchers" , the students soon learned that the change of one word could spell an important change in the party line. For example, Leonhard describes how the lectures and the line of Pravda during the war concentrated on the anti-fascist alliance of the USSR, USA and Britain. This theme was repeated ad nauseam. Then in one lecture there was a mention of the struggle against "sectarianism" , without any further elaboration. The students pricked up their ears—here was a new line!—and listened carefully while for days on end the lectures were punctuated with the references to "sectarianism" . Finally, a special lecture on the subjeco was arranged. It was now the duty of the students to be absolutely familiar with the struggle against "sectarianism": how to identify it, analyse it and condemn it. "It was hammered into us again and again, that nothing could be more dangerous than presenting excessive demands or isolating oneself from potential allies." Behind the change in the line (although Leonhard does not mention it) it is clear that the price the Allies are demanding for assistance to the USSR includes the toning down of all the economic and
28
[page 30]
and the students were only given what they were supposed to know. "We were given the literature on the Trotskyist argument, which consisted of a cyclostyled document, carefully put together out of Lenin's statements against Trotsky (naturally omitting his far more numerous statements in favour of Trotsky), together with extracts of Stalin's writings. The document contained not a single line written by Trotsky or any of his followers... there was no risk whatsoever involved in putting into our hands speeches by Hitler or Goebbels, or manifestos from the bourgeois parties, or encyclicals from the Pope, because it was certain from the first that none of them would have the slightest influence on us. On the other hand, books by Trotsky and manifestos by anti-Stalinist organisations... would at least have made some impression on us."
"Our instructor, Klassner, became quite unrecognisable when he was dealing with the subject (of Trotskyism). Uncontrollable hatred filled his voice, and instead of expounding the relevant arguments his lecture became a flood of abuse-something unique in our lectures at the school"
Later on, by accident, Leonhard came across some articles by Trotsky in the American 'Militant' and he discovered that the Trotskyites "wrote in our own language" , although his reading of Trotsky and his opinions on the matter do not seem to have gone too far. Leonhard explains the electric effect of this discovery. "I could not have been more startled if I had found a pack of dynamite." From that day on he hurried through his filing so that he could devote three or four minutes to reading Trotskyist publications, looking over his shoulder to see nobody was watching.
Later, Leonhard went to the part of Germany occupied by the Red Army and took part in establishing a government. He illustrates in a variety of ways the contrast between the aspirations of the workers who had fought in the underground-they wanted a socialist transformation-and, on the other hand, the emigré bureaucrats key positions in a "people's government". The German workers often set up their own anti-Nazi committees after liberation, but according Leonhard, "every initiative from below was nipped in the bud." Ulbricht, later to become head of the East German regime, justified the 'line' of the KPD before a meeting of members: the new KPD charter "did not go beyond a general anti-fascist programme. Marx and Engels were not even mentioned: -he term 'Socialism' did not oc-
there were one or two surprises,
as when Ulbricht read out the phrase, 'Complete and unrestricted development of free commerce and private enterprise on the basis of private property"'
When Ulbricht was asked how this was different from any democratic programme he answered with a wink, "You'll soon see, comrade! Just wait a bit"
"When Ulbricht had finished his speech and the International had been sung, many of those present raised their fists in the old salute of the Red Front, which Party members had used before 1933. Ulbricht, together with his collegues on the Presidium did not do so. Many others thereupon lowered their arms again. It was a small but typical example of the change which had taken place in the KPD since 1933" • In reality it was the outward showing of changes that had been taking place since 1923.
The line of the new KPD-for a "bourgeois-democratic revolution to complete the tasks of the 1848 revolution"-overcame any independent movement of the workers themselves, alongside the important fact that the bureaucracy patronised by the Red Army had the effective control of the new state. The control over the levers of state power were later the means of overcoming the very bourgeois leaders and political figures that they had installed themselves in 1945, as the bureaucracy, balancing, Bonapartiststyle, between the classes, moved to take over industry and the economy. East Germany became a model of Stalinist Russia.
The value of Leonhard's account is that it confirms from the inside the analysis outlined at the time by Ted Grant in the "Marxist theory of the State"
"The Stalinists proceeded to make an agreement with the shadow of the bourgeoisie... But the difference with Spain (in 1936) was that here the key positions in this so-called coalition, where the shadow of the bourgeoisie possessed no power, remained firmly in Stalinist hands."
Compare Leonhard. 'In the early days of May, the Russian Commandants had established Mayors and local administrations of their own. Their appointments were often entirely capricious... One Commandant, on receiving the order to establish local Mayors in office. Simply went out into the street and seized by the arm the first passer-by whose face he liked for some reason, saying: "Come here! You are now Mayor!"
Ulbricht insisted on at least half the administrative posts being filled by "anti-fascist bourgeois" '. He said "it's
29
quite clear-it's got to democratic, but we must everything in our control."
Yet they could find nothing but Communists! Leonhard describes hilariously his hunt to fill the quota of "anti-fascist bourgeois", who in 1945 were as rare as the holy grail, to fill the administrative apparatus.
Leonhard eventually broke with the East German regime, but despite misgivings about the privileges and perks of the bureacracy, he does not really explain why and how the bureaucracy arose and even less how it could be overcome. His break could be said to have been made from the standpoint of a 'reforming bureaucrat'-he seemed to have had illusions about Yugoslavia, as if Tito's break with Stalin somehow represented a fundamental difference between the two states, and he sought after East German independence from the USSR. He does not suggest at any stage that the workers themselves will ever settle accounts with the bureaucracy-but then the lack of confidence in the workers is itself part of the make-up of the bureaucrat. All in all, a book well worth reading to fit together more pieces in the puzzle, to complete, from a bureaucrat's point of view, the picture of how Stalinism operates.
look have