Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Karl Marx: Man and Fighter, by Nicolaievsky and Maenchen-Helfen

· No. 26, Summer 1984 · pp. 30-31 of the scan · 1,084 words

The scan: Militant International Review no26 Summer 1984.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents-titles located in body; split and attributed by hand from the scan (article-splits.csv).

MARX:

d figh

By Nicolaievsky and Maenchen-Helfen

Pelican: Price £3.95

Man and fighter

Reviewed Mick Broo

by KS

Penguin Books republished Nicolaievsky's biography of Marx on the centenary of his death. It seems a useful account concentrating on the life of Marx as a practical revolutionary rather than his theoretical works. But Nicolaievsky was a Menshevik. He misinterprets Marx's position on the 1848 revolutions in the spirit of class compromise.

Marxism developed in preparation for the revolutions which broke out in 1848. The "Red Year" in its turn provided the inspiration for the Russiar Marxists, who were faced with a very similar situation at the turn of the cer• tury. The old order was crumbling

[page 31]

MIR June 1984; Book reviews

away. Who would carry through the revolution against Tsarism? What would that revolution achieve?

The Mensheviks believed that the coming Russian revolution would be bourgeois. It would install a democratic republic and clear the way for capitalist development. It would be led by liberal capitalists, whom the workers should support!

The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, believed that for the fullest and most rapid achievement of the tasks of the revolution, the peasantry, led by the working class, would have to be the vanguard fighters for democracy.

This position was developed further by Trotsky. The workers would indeed lead the struggle against Tsarism. However, having achieved power they would not stop at land reform and political democracy but make the revolution "permanent" by moving on to socialist tasks. This is, of course, exactly what happened in 1917.

Nicolaievsky attempts to justify his position by asserting that Marx held a Menshevik position in 1848. He speaks repeatedly of the "coalition of

and revolutionary

" The Communist Manifesto too refers to Germany as "on the eve of a bourgeois revolution" and says that Communists "fight with the bourgeoisie whenever it acts in a revolutionary way."

This is a cautious "algebraic" formulation. How far the capitalist class would in fact "act in revolutionary way" was to be tested in the fire of events. But in no sense was a "coalition" between the workers and their natural enemies the capitalists advocated. The Manifesto goes on, to say, "But they (the Communists) never cease for a single instant to instil into the working class the clearest possible recognition of the hostile antagonism between bourgeoisie and proletariat, in order that... after the fall of the reactionary classes in Germany, the fight against the bourgeoisie itself may immediately begin" , and again "the bourgeois revolution in Germany will be but the prelude to an immediately following proletarian revolution"

According to Nicolaievsky as soon as he became editor of the Neue Rheinische Zeitung Marx dissolved the Communist League. The implication is clear-once a democratic paper was set up all independent working class action was superfluous.

The only evidence to this assertion is from a Communist later arrested and threatened with hard labour for his political activities. It was certainly in his interests to deny the existence of the League! Even the editors are forced to step in at this point and ex-

plain that Marx simply did not have the power to dissolve the League.

As for the Neue Rheinische Zeitung, Nicolaievsky asserts that "there was not a word about the special interest of the working classes or of the workers' special tasks in the German revolution" up to the end of 1848. Evidently in this key revolutionary year Marx behaved like a simple revolutionary democrat!

A few pages later, however, we find that half the wealthy shareholders of the paper defected after 'articles about the June fighting". '. What was this "June fighting" to which this is the sole reference in the book?

In June 1848 the French working class rose against the capitalists and were bloodily put down. The democratic petty-bourgeois vacillated and stood to one side. The Neue Rheinische Zeitung was the only paper in Germany to support the French workers.

At the end of 1848 Marx and Engels drew a balance sheet of the revolution. In articles such as "The Bourgeoisie and the Counter-revolution" they explained how the rising capitalist class, so far from destroying the reaction. were attempting to hide behind it for fear of the people. In practice, as Nicolaievsky has to recognise, "the revolution could only be accomplished against the bourgeoisie.

In Germany, particularly, the working class was a small minority. Marx looked at developments in France to reinvigorate the revolution-and understood that the petty-bourgeoisie would first be thrust forward by the new movement. The petty-bourgeois

30

Heule Wheinifde Britung.

Ergan der Ermotratir.

ig. 1194

31225 žèvers

22200

republicans in France allowed themselves to be out-manoeuvred in 1849, eternally vacillating between capitalists and workers, and their German equivalents too were defeated and dispersed!

The lessons of the revolution were drawn by Marx and Engels in their 'Address to the Communist League' of March 1850. For Nicolaievsky, however, this period "proves better than anything else the extent to which his judgement had been affected by the break-down of his immeasurable hopes." But it is Nicolaievsky's judgement which has been affected by the clear revolutionary line struck by the "Address". He asserts, "whether the document in all its detail really represents Marx's ideas is difficult to decide". No shred of evidence is provided for this.

What were the lessons of the 1848 revolutions? Precisely that 'the independence of the workers must be restored." Secondly, the "Address" goes on to say, 'this so treacherous role which the German liberal bourgeois played in 1848 against the people, will in the impending revolution be taken over by the democratic petty bourgeois, who at present occupy the same position in the opposition as the liberal bourgeois before 1848."

"While the democratic petty bourgeois wish to bring revolution to a conclusion as quickly as possible... it is our interest and our task to make the revolution permanent, until all more or less possessing classes have been forced out of their position of dominance, until the proletariat has conquered state power" . This is necessary "not only in one country but in all the dominant countries of the world."

It was from this appraisal that Trotsky applied the theory of permanent revolution to bring the Russian working class to power in 1917—despite the desperate resistance of the Menshevik co-thinkers of Nicolaievsky. Permanent revolution remains the only hope for the workers and peasants of the under-developed countries, and the foundations for that perspective were laid down in Marx's revolutionary activity in the 1840's.

← Child of the Revolution, by Wolfgang LeonhardProletarian Philosophers, by Jonathan Ree →

Something wrong on this page?