[page 29]
injury to all
the decline of American unioni:
by Kim Moody Published by Verso
£9.95
Reviewed by
Bill Hopwood
In An injury to all, Kim Moody chronicles and examines the decline in the portion of American workers organised into unions. Undoubtedly, many workers worldwide think that the USA is different from other industrialised countries. Below 20 per cent of the workforce is organised and it is the only developed capitalist country without a mass party based on the working class. it seems, superficially, that Amer ican workers are different.
However. beneath the surface, the labour movement has a powerful and militant tradition. After World War II there were 15 million workers organised into unions - 35 per cent of the nonagricultural workforce. This had been achieved by heroic strugg les of millions of workers organising in industries like motor vehicles, steel, chemicals, mining and textiles. In a movement that convulsed America, new unions were built and a new structure - the Congress of Industrial Organisations (CIO) - formed.
In spite of the crucial role of militants in these battles, the union leadership remained with those who accepted the rule of capitalism. They believed in 'business unionism' a philosophy based on the view that what was good for business was good for the workers.
[page 30]
In the long years of the post-
war boom it seemd that business
unionism was a success. Organis-
ed workers won high pay levels - probably the highest in the
world and many other rights such as pensions, lay-off pay and
health insurance. Union membership grew by seven million to reach 22 million by 1975, although the percentage of workers unionised had fallen to 29 per cent.
On the surface there was a stable relationship with employers accepting the unions while the unions backed big business at home and abroad. But with a new crisis in US and world capitalism which began in the mid-1970s this cosy relationship ended Everything changed as big business began a major attack on the unions for which the ladership was totally unprepared
The onslaught of the last 15 years was made easier by a lack of a party of Labour. In other industrialised countries the capitalists proceeded with caution as any head-on clash with workers could push them into political as well as industrial means to fight back.
Big business used many tactics, including unemployment, union busting and relocation of factories to weaken union power. The union leaders relied on the legal process through ballots to win recognition rather than industrial power, which the employers were able to frustrate through complex delaying and blocking tactics. They even used ballots to decertify unions. Rather than fight the employers, the union tops offered concessions, forcing their members to accept job and pay cuts to keep union contracts.
The decisive reason for the absolute decline in union membership to 17 million and as a share to 18 per cent was the leadership's refusal to use their organised power.
In the last decade companies have moved to new regions in the USA, while manufacturing jobs have declined, even in the economic upturn since 1982. The new service jobs have low union membership - only seven per cent of the 45 million workers in wholesale, retail, financial services are unionised.
This decline is not because unions are unpopular. In opinion polls 60 per cent approved of
ATLE
PRICES AG CLEO
unions and 53 per cent of non-
union service workers wanted
unionisation. This is no surprise
as unionised workers continue to
enjoy 30 per cent better pay on average.
However, to build unions in the face of determined employer resistance, takes more than opinion polls. It requires the same energetic mass action that characterised the battles of the 1930s. Yet the union leaders spend less per unorganised workers on recruitment that they did in the
1950s and 1960s.
Kim Moody provides many examples of workers fighting back against the twin obstacles of big business and a conservative bureaucratic leadership. But he has illusions in other, less effective, methods of struggle than industrial action. He believes in consumer burcotts. public lobbying, leatletting and publicity aimed at suppliers customers and bankers of employers in disputes. But these tactics can only be a useful auxiliary but never an alternative to union organisation and industrial action
The reality is that despite the policies of its leaders, unions are not in terminal decline. In key industrial states of California, New York, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Ohio and Michigan where 40 per cent of the American people live, there is 30 per cent union membership. This is a powerful force. And the 17 million membership overall is still higher than in the 1930s where in during the Great Depression it fell as low as three million. The traditions of American workers are for militant struggle and explosive union action. In the years after 1933 in
the face of brutal repression, through mass strike waves, sitdown occupations and regional general strikes, workers built up organised labour. All the forces exist today for a similar transformation. Most workers are discontented after a decade of declining real incomes. women, now a major part of the workforce, are a major growth area for unionisation, as are black and latino minorities who make up 20 per cent of the population.
Rather than being in decline, for organised labour the best days are yet to come
MIR Summer Book Re
•29 1989 riews
American Unions in political action ove prices in 1983.
Car workr demonstr on health care.