Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

For Labour and Women: A History of the League of Women 1906-18, by Christine Collette

No. 40, Summer 1989 · p. 29 of the scan · 731 words

The scan: Militant International Review no40 Summer 1989.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents-titles located in body; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 29]

280 MIR Summer 1 Book Revi

989 sma

For Labour and Women; a history of be League of Women

1906-18 by Christine Collette.

Published by Manchester University Press at £29.95

Reviewed by a

member of the National Committee

Labour Women

The omen's Labour League (WLL), the forerunner of the present Labour Women's organisation, was set up in 1906 to support Labour's representation. It was open to women and wives and daughters of members of societies affiliated to the Labour party. Christine Collette's book is a history from its inauguration until it merged with the Labour party in 1918.

Collette regards this pre-war period as a special period of separate women's organisation superior to today's movement. But completely separate organisations emerged at that time not out of choice but because the structures of the labour and trade union movement did not allow women to become members. Women were refused entry to many craft unions and were forced to form their own unions which were not part of the Labour Representation Committee.

These attitudes were transformed after the First World War and probably the best part of the book deals with this period. Unfortunately Collette wrongly concludes that it was a step backwards for the WLL to merge with the Labour party, for this was precisely a time when increased class consciousness and unity were in the air. One delegate to the 1914 WLL conference, Ada Salter, reported its mood: "They noted all over the world signs of the change that was coming and women of the working classes have taken the foremost place in it. A tremendous transformation was going to take place on this earth; and the injustices of the ages, the misery of the oppressed classes and the sorrow of the poor and tyranny of the wealthy were going to be swept away forever. Nothing could stop the movement. When the trades movement fully realised that all

workers, men and women. youths and maidens, were members one of another, then they would hear more than the rumble of revolution in the distance; the revolution would be here."

That conference voted against arms expenditure, conscription and in favour of international action against war. In 1916 the WLL motion to Labour party conference opposed military service and called for agitation against it. The WLL participated in conferences in support of the Russian revolution and intended to send a delegation to the Petrograd Soviet but was refused passports by the government.

The end of the war and the impact of revolutionary movements internationally produced a shift towards socialist ideas. Women's issues did not become secondary but were integrally linked to the class struggle. The conversion of the WLL into a section of the Labour party was seen by most women as a welcome recognition of their place in the labour movement.

Collette concentrates on the WLL leaders who were mostly middle-class. She describes their individual, personal and sometimes political conflicts but gives less detail of local branch activity where working-class women predominated. Individual branches campaigned on infant mortality, producing leaflets refuting the idea that working mothers were

to blame tor undernourished sick children. Funds were raised to set up a WIL baby clinic.

Many local WLL branches supported women trade unionists and raised funds for strikers. The biggest campaign was on school meals, urging local authorities to adopt the Education (provision of Meals) Act of 1906. By 1912 131 out of 322 authorities provided meals for school children. In Bradford the district auditor surcharged the council for providing meals in school holidays which exceeded the product of the halfpenny rate. Unfortunately, much of this rich history for women's struggles goes unwritten by Collette who tends to rely on national Labour party records rather than local source material. Now the Labour Women's organisation is in danger of being abandoned by women in the Labour Party who have been taken in by the NEC's offer of 40 per cent quotas for women. A history of the WLL could have been used a weapon to defend a Labour women's organisation which really represents working-class women, not a mere structure to be tossed aside in exchange for a few more women in leadership positions. Collette's book has some useful information, but it is not a living document of working-class struggles and at $29.95 is not likely to be read by many working-class women or men.

← When the Music's Over: The Story of Political Pop, by Robin DenselowAn Injury to All: The Decline of American Unionism, by Kim Moody →

Something wrong on this page?