Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

William Lovett, by Joel Weiner; Arthur Henderson, by F.M. Leventhal

· No. 41, Autumn 1989 · p. 47 of the scan · 505 words

The scan: Militant International Review no41 Autumn 1989.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 47]

William Lovett by Joel Weiner & Arthur Henderson by EM Leventhal, published by Manchester University Press. Price £7.95 and £8.95 respectively.

Reviewed by Ian Hunter Lovett, from the earliest days of movement in the the labour 1830s and Henderson from the formative period of the Labour party early this century are separated in time. But they are united as stalwarts of 'moderation' Lovett, the defender of 'moral force' against the 'wild' advocates in the Chartist of revolution movement; and 'Uncle Arthur' Henderson, the dogged promoter of Lib-lab trade unionism and 'constitutional' Labourism and compromise.

The Chartists were for class power through universal suffrage. It was the first genuine workingclass political movement in Britain. But Chartism was not only associated with Lovett but also with militants like Feargus O'Connor, Bronterre O'Brien and with Marx and Engels' friends George

Harney and Ernest Jones. Chartist history, however, has been coloured and distorted by Fabians and reformists who have tried to obscure the relationship between Marx and the Chartist leaders in order to separate British Labour history from any connection with Lovett claimed that the Chartist movement had been highjacked by hot-heads. Weiner shows that this was not the case. On the contrary, even Lovett was not averse to challenging repressive laws with violent rhetoric. Weiner reveals the fundamental weakness of Chartism - that it was promoted through a series of gigantic bluffs: a combination of great displays of activity, coupled with fierce threats unless workers' demands were met. It was naively hoped that the government would cave in under this pressure. The crisis for Chartism came when the government stood firm and the bluff was called Some, like Lovett, failed the test. Lovett baulked and turned his attentions away from class action towards 'moral re-education'. Increasingly isolated from the Chartist mainstream, he blamed workers for their own problems and finally supported a capitalist economy and alliances with the middle-

class, both of which he had originally so resolutely opposed. Unfortunately, Weiner provides not even a glimpse of the dynamic of the class struggle which continued to drive the mainstream of the Chartists towards Marxism, Similarly, in Leventhal's biog raphy of Henderson there is no understanding of how the logic of class conflict drove 'moderates' like him to break with Liberalism and found the Labour party. Leventhal tells us that in the early days of Newcastle city council, Henderson "learnt the values of political conciliation and comp romise". On the contrary, what Henderson did learn, the hard way, was that that even Liberal workers, as he was then, immed. iately engendered the hostility of the middle-class Liberal caucus as soon as they tried to pursue spec ifically working-class issues. That is why he eventually left the Liberals.

Lacking a Marxist analysis of events, Weiner and Leventhal can tell us the story of Lovett and Henderson, but they cannot explain why things happened the way they did. So there are worthwhile gleanings to be found from both books, as long as they approached with a sufficiently critical eye.

← Women Workers and the Trade Unions, by Sarah BostonThe Soul of Man under Socialism, by Oscar Wilde →

Something wrong on this page?