Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Women Workers and the Trade Unions, by Sarah Boston

· No. 41, Autumn 1989 · pp. 46-47 of the scan · 531 words

The scan: Militant International Review no41 Autumn 1989.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

[page 46]

Women workers and

the trade unions

by Sarah Boston

published by Law'ence

and Wishart

price £8.95

Reviewed by

Yvonne Harrison

Sarah Boston's book is one of just a few which deal in detail with the role of women in building the labour movement. She gives an inspiring account of the willingness of women to struggle. both independently and alongside male workers, to improve their wages and conditions, often in the most adverse circumstances.

The Sander confectionary girls strike in 1892 is one example of that tenacity exhibited in the early part of this century and which still exists today: They walked out after 30 of them were sacked and organised a prolonged strike in

their own union, as well as joint action with Bristol dockers. In a march through the streets of Bristol on Christmas Eve they were met by a squadron of hussars and dragoons who had been ordered to smash them. Many were injured, the dockers leaders arrested and the march speakers charged with 'inciting a riot. But this did not cow the girls, who stuck out for six months before winning improved wages, although not their main aim of union recognition. As Sarah Boston comments, like the match girls, they left their mark on the labour movement.'

More recently, Boston rightly lays emphasis on the struggle of the Ford women machinists for equal pay in 1968. They brought Fords to a standstill and won a partial victory. Their action was instrumental in bringing in the 1970 Equal Pay Act, although they did not win equal pay and skilled status until 1985 when they won a

case under the 'equal pay for work of equal value' clause. As Boston points out, legislation can be slow and laborious and is no substitute for organised union action which is the key to winning real gains for women workers.

Boston's book is more of a chronicle of women's development in the workplace. It does not discuss the causes of women's oppression in society. She does not explain why women from wealthier families were relegated to idleness while in poor families they became low-paid wage labourers.' That women are exploited at work alongside male workers; and at home by bearing overwhelmingly the burden of domestie work is ignored. Boston describes but does not explain.

She catalogues the growth of women's organisations in the early 1900s. These were necessary for women to organise, but it was by no means a golden age for

MIR •45

[page 47]

women and eventually these early Autumn 1989 organisations were incorporated Book Reviews into the general labour unions. 460 MIR Boston suggests that women ill achieve real equality onl hen they are able to go to wor and receive equal pay: and when

"their concerns are listened to, at the TV'C by a full and silent hall: when the number of women delegates to the TUC is proportional to their membership But she fails to show what forces in society block the progress to

achievements or how they can be overcome; and specifically how women's oppression is rooted in capitalist society and only the end of the class system can change fundamentally women's position in society.

← Wired: The Short Life and Fast Times of John Belushi, by Bob WoodwardWilliam Lovett, by Joel Weiner; Arthur Henderson, by F.M. Leventhal →

Something wrong on this page?