[page 39]
Beyond the Casino
economy By Nicholas Costello, Jonathan Michie and
Seumas Milne Published by Verso, 1989
at £8.95
Reviewed by
Michael Roberts
This book, with a foreword by Tony Benn, represents the arguments of the 'Bennite' wing of the Labour Party. Costello, Michie and Milne - an information technology expert, economics lecturer and Guardian journalist respectively - are strongest rebutting the theories of Bryan Gould et al which accept the alleged success of modern capitalism.
They effectively refute claims of a 'British economic miracle' (p+2 44 and p77-92) and expose the deficiencies of market forces (p59-73), showing that between 1970-84 the City's financial markets made no contribution to building British industry which had to finance all its investment out of retained profits (pl20).
They proclaim, with evidence, the virtues of planning, although they have illusions that the planned economics of Eastern Europe are'socialist' and that Gorbachev's economic reforms are 'steps in the direction' of workers' self-management (p262). Indeed the book's weakness is its alternative to capitalism, which closely resembles the Labour Lefts Alternative Economic Strategy of the 1970s.
The deficiency of this programme remains: political cowardice. The authors' arguments often lead them to conclude that only public ownership and workers' control of industry and the plan can take the economy forward: "If a Labour government is to implement a long-term strategy: it would need to have powers to change the behaviour of the largest few hundred firms that dominate the British economy. Ideally that would mean the nationalisation of all of them" (p109); "The most rational and long-term solution to the problem... would be to turn those few hundred companies into democratically-owned and accountable public bodies." (p25*).
Yet as this conclusion is reached, the authors back away and look for some half-way house Why! Becallie: comnion sense (!) dictates that even to carry out an extension of public ownership on the scale that the French gorernment did in 1981-2 would be an enormous political and organ- ¡sational struggle" (p109).
Thus the old formula of a radical strategy aiming at "planning what would of course be — as Neil Kinnock pointed out at the 1988 Labour Party Conference — a market or capitalist economy" (p259). The programme becomes important reforms in wages, housing etc through public ownership of one or more banks and some key in dustrial companies. coupled with exchange controls and compul sory planning agreements.
It is a programme they admit cannot really take the economy forward, and thereby mobilise the enthusiasm of the working class. and yet will nevertheless provoke i violent reaction from big business that will force a Labour government to retreat. It is dangerous political cowardice: if public ownership of the top 200 companies is the 'most rational solution' why not tell working people the truth and campaign for it?