Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Columbus: His Enterprise, by Hans Koning

· No. 48, Summer 1992 · pp. 30-31 of the scan · 545 words

The scan: Militant International Review no48 Summer 1992.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

Columbus - His Enterprise By Hans Koning Published by the Latin American Bureau. 1992. at .tt.99 Reviewed by Tony Aitman 1992 IS THE 500th anniversary of the discovery of America Christopher Columbus. and alhave ready the celebrations begun, ranging from the sentimental to the disgracetul. One such is Liverpool's Tall Ships spectacular, doubtless celebrating the triangular slave trade with the New World which generated the city's original wealth!

It is good news. therefore. that the Latin American Bureau (LAB) has republished Columbus - His Enterprise by Hans Koning. A reappraisal of Columbus is a necess- Koning ary alternative to what calls the "Eurocentric. white raceoriented, teaching of history:" The LAB has a record over many years of producing excellent material on struggles in Latin America and the Caribbean Amongst all the material produc ed for the anniversary, for anyone wanting an accessible. easy-toread answer to the Columbus myth. this is the book. Written primarily for high school pupils. it shows clearly that the roots of Columbus journey lay not in the love of adventure - or a beliet that the world was flat! - but in the greed of Spanish merchants

[page 31]

for a quick route to the riches of the East. in particular. Chinese gold.

Exposing the hypocrisy of the Church, Koning shows how, in the name of love' and 'charity. Columbus led the systematic enslavement and extinction of the native of the Americas. He peoples shows that colonialism has always meant the brutal subjugation of native populations. He also exposes the irony that those who opposed the enslavement of the 'Ind. ians' because they were dying in their thousands could only propose in its place the importation of 'stronger' African slaves - thus beginning the infamous African slave trade.

As a textbook written by a non- Marxist, the book does have its weaknesses. Koning talks in the introduction of asing the anniversary celebrations to find a "final reconciliation of the races of America, an impossibility as long as capitalism remains. In the words of Malcolm X. you can't have capitalism without racism Koning hopes for "an atonement of past crimes." By whom? Are we all collectively guilty of the crimes of world capitalism. Or does he expect the ruling class to beg for giveness for its actions in the past. while continuing those self-same crimes today?

To Koning. Columbus was "a man of his race". a "typical man of the (White ) West": World War Il was "a great white-race civil war." Despite a disclaimer. itself couched in racial terms — "I am not ig noring the cruelties of other they too fill the pages of races... with man's inhumanity to man" - Koning persists in talking about the West. Not Western capitalism. not a West itself divided into classes with an oppressing and exploiting ruling class. but the West as a single entity for whose actions we all must take the blame. It is this concept of the class struggle that is missing from Koning's analysis Despite these weaknesses. most Iy confined to the introduction and afterword, the book itselt remains an interesting. worthwhile exposure of the Columbus myth. For anyone looking for an antidote to all the jingoistic ballyhoo surrounding the Columbus celebrations. I can think of no better book

← The Samson Option: Israel, America and the Bomb, by Seymour M. HershFrom the House of War, by John Simpson →

Something wrong on this page?