From the House of War By John Simpson Published by Arrou Books, 1991, at £6.99 Reviewed by David Kaplan JOHN SIMPSON IS is the foreign affairs editor of the BBC. He was amongst the first British journalists to arrive in Baghdad after the invasion of Kuwait, in August 1990. Based on personal experience and interviews. his book is a "viewpoint from Baghdad" of the Gulf war and the events which led up to it.
The 'unilateral' reporters like Simpson, and including Mark Urban. a BBC Neusnight reporter. and Robert Fisk, a journalist for The Independent, looked down on the official pool system set up by the western coalition forces: "It did no good to the journalists who belonged to it and who, therefore. were closely associated with the military. The unilaterals felt that living the army life and wearing uniform for its own sake blurred the necessary distinction between the reporters and the people they were reporting on." In the end. it was the 'unilaterals' who free to do the more adventurous and informative reporting Simpson tries to relate the feelings of ordinary' Iraqis: "The system of reward and punishment obliged people to come out onto the streets and go through the motions of hero-worship with enthusiasm. or face the consequences." A teacher spoke to him: "You must realise that no one here supports Saddam. No one wants this war to happen. No one wants Kuwait." She was part of a demonstration outside the British embasst: journalists had been informed that it was taking place by the Iraqi Information Ministry: Children were shouting Down. down. Bush. Down. down. Thatcher' The teacher continued: "We are only here because we have to be. No one wants to demonstrate. You must understand that." Although there was a fear of the Iraqi regime's brutal methods. there is. however, no doubt that large sections of the Arab workers and peasants had no sympathy for the Kuwaiti regime and were totally opposed to the US-led interhistory vention. This was especially the case in Palestine. Jordan. Algeria and Morocco. Simpson around the Arab quarters of old Jerusalem. Walls were daubed Saddam our leader' and 'U'nite for action'
Simpson argues that Saddam was taking an almost entirely unwilling country into war. Does this explain the massive defeat of the Iraqi army in a land war that finished just 100 hours after it had started? Simpson thinks so. In fact Iraq would have made a formidable opponent if the anti-imperialist feeling amongst the Iraqi people had been successfully tapped Securing democratic rights (including the right of self-determin ation of the Kurds), the arming of the Iraqi masses and exposing the reasons for the war would have gone a long way towards this In its reports on the insurrect. ion in Kurdistan at the end of the war, the book gives a vivid desc. ription of the aspirations - soon to be dashed - of those living during the apparent demise of a hated dictatorship: "There are fen more heady experiences than being with people who have liberated themselves by their own efforts from hated some regime Everyone is a brother. Revolutionary crowds cease to be a collection of cowardly: fallible individuals and become. for a briet moment, something grander and gencrous...
This book is worth reading It is a strong reminder of the swings in opinion during the crisis in both the Middle East and in the West