[page 31]
Big Boy's' Rules: the secret struggle against the IRA By Mark Urban Published by Faber and Faber. 1992. at £/4.99 Reviewed by John Dolan BIG BOYS' RULES covers the years 1976 to 1987 in Northern Ireland. It is based upon research plus 60 interviews with ex-army special forces members. senior ex-security forces members, ex-specialist intelligence workers. solicitors, republican activists. constables. soldiers and members of the public who witnessed gunbattles. The author. Mark Urban. now a BBC2 Veusnight reporter. himself served in the British army in 1979. The book highlights many instances of the ruthless behaviour of the British state. notably the SAS. The standard SAS operation. documented again and again in this book, is of an IRA active service unit (ASt) either going to an arms dump or on an operation which the SAS have been tipped off about (usually from an IRA informer - Irban estimates one in tO IRA members are informers), and being shot without warning For example. three unarmed IRA members on a mission to blow up a post office depot in 1978. with no apparent threat to human life, were killed by five SAs men informed of the attack. who fired a total of 111 shots at them An indication of their behaviour is the fact that one quarter of SAS killings in Vorthern Ireland have been of people with no paramilitary links.
A COMMON LINK between many of the high-ranking RIC and army officers mentioned in the book is their colonial background - Palestine. Kenya, Malaya. Oman. Cyprus and Borneo were all mentioned in describing their earlier military careers.
Their attitude to their role in Northern Ireland is graphically illustrated. The army's yellow card reasonable force guidelines on says that "firearms must only be used as a last resort." Yet Urban intervicwed an ex-intelligence NCO who told him: "I do not object to this capital punishment or without this policy of shooting warning at armed terrorists." Another intelligence officer told him: "I can't see why we can't admit that we are shooting these terrorists." The very title of the book comes from the army saying "big boys' games, big boys rules: any IRA member caught on active service can expect to be shot. Coroners' inquests into state killings are shown to be a white. wash. Soldiers and police often lie to the courts to cover up events and protect their informers. For reasons of army and RIC morale and reputation, convictions are highly unlikely One striking feature about the IRA members killed is their youth. For example the active service unit ambushed (an army colloquialism for a killing) by the SAS in February 1985 were 16. 20 and 22 years of age. Many of the IRA members referred to in this book were in their late teens or carly twentics.
TO MANY WORKERS in Britain. horrified by the methods employed by the IRA. the actions of the army and REC can be excused in dealing with terrorist murderers' But there are many dangers for the labour movement which even at this stage are clearly exposed by British imperialism's actions in Northern Ireland. M15's F-Branch. dealing with counter-subversion. has a definition of subrersive Which includes Liberty (formerly the National Council for Civil Liberties)! The army's (dis )information policy unit was involved in printing fake Ieaflets and posters to discredit the IRA and loyalist paramilitarics in the 1970s. An ex senior army officer's justification to Mark Urban for lying to the media and CI about shootings was to prevent the army from "being held ransom to that mythical commodity tou call truth." The army's bible for operations in Northern Ireland is called Land Operations. Volume Three counter-rerolationary operations. The term counter revolutionary is revealing. Certainly. in the future. the type of actions taken against the IRA documented in this book could be used against
[page 32]
those fighting for a socialis socicty and the overthrow of capitalism in England. Scotland and Wales. Another incident in the book which will be of interest to CPSA members is when Colin Watlace. who was a government dirty tricks agent in the 19-0s appealel to a civil service board against his dismissal. His appeal was re jected after Ministry of Defence officials had a word with the board.
« course the armed forces aren't superhuman - some of the tales of incompetence in the book are humorous. like the British army patrol who thought they were witnessing an invasion of Northern Ireland be the Southern army: until they realised they had strayed into the Irish Republic by mistake.
More significantly: the army. RIC and DR were riven with tensions and jealouss in the 10s An ex-army officer says of this time: "Fighting the IRA was about number nine on my list of problems every morning" Intormers for one section were being arrested be another section. And despite all the state surveillance of the IRA. an organisation of approximately 350 active members the IRA had an informer in the REC in 1980. and had tapped the phone calls of senior officers The thinking of the armed for- Clearly in the book. decording to an intelligence officer "it's all a matter of acceptable levels" As well is taking into account the interests of British imperialism itself. there is the fear that killing IRA members creates martyrs and leads to further recruits for them. This strategy is counterposed by those who say: like il sergeant Northern Ireland. "we've all basically got the same idea of how we could end this. but world opinion wouldn't stand for it."
Another SAs sergeant unwitting- Is shows up the futilies of the IRA's campaign of individual terrorism when compared to what a mass movement could achicre in rendering groups like the SAS helpless: "With its sinister strects and alienated population. Belfast was no place for highly trained special forces operators." Bearing in mind the subject of this book, conclusive proof of events is impossible to give. But Mark I ran scems to have got a lot of information out of his army interviews to give the clearest picture you are likely to read. But all of the tactics and technology used by undercover units described in this book have already been recaled at one time or another. and the book has had 15 alterations made from the orig inal draft due to the intervention of the D-Votice Committee. This is the department which can keep the media from publishing and broadcasting known news storics. most recently used during the Despite this. it chronicles many actions of the state in Vorthern Ireland, has lots of usctul facts and figures. and confirms the ruthless socialists have measures man! long known the British state has been employing there.