Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Poll Tax Rebellion, by Danny Burns

· No. 49, Autumn 1992 · pp. 32-33 of the scan · 1,278 words

The scan: Militant International Review no49 Autumn 1992.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR: cell by cell where that read better, otherwise whole-page and column-aware) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: contents+offset; put in reading order and attributed by hand from the scan (article-reassembled.csv).

Poll Tax Rebellion By Danny Burns Published be Mlack International. 1992 .24.95 Reviewed by Martin Cock SINCE MICHAEL HESELTINES March 1991 announcement that the poll tax was to be scrapped. two lies have been spread to belittle the anti-poll tax movement Lie number one — it had nothing to do with non payment started on the dar of abolition. Every pundit and every politician - from the Tory rebels to the Liberal victors in the Ribble Valky by election. to the right-wing Labour leaders who had done so much to attack the anti-pol! tax campaign — popped up to claim their central role in boating the But this lie began do crumble from the day it started Tory and Labour leader alike. fearing their discrediting in the eyes of millions of workers who could see the councils and courts straining under the weight of non-payment. were forced to admit that. in the words of John Major, the poll tax is uncollectable.

And so began lie number two. This was a bit more clever and first appeared in outline in The Observer. 21 March 1991: "If the poll tax is dead in was killed by non-payment. it was left to a raglag army of ordinary people to destroy a bad law: " This was soon refined down to. well Ok. nonpayment did defeat the poll tax but it just happened and would have happened withour the antipoll tax unions or the involvement of groups like Vilitant:

Il is certainly truc to say that non-payment would have happened come what may. mainly duc 1o poverty: But it is ridiculous to argue that the millions of leatlets explaining people's rights. thousands of demonstrations and mectings. didn't play a decisive role in convincing millions of nonpayers that they weren't alone and to hold out right to the end. Danny Burns, along with others. played an important role in building the anti-poll tas movement in the south west of England. It is a great shame. therefore. that he has written a book. Poll Tax Rebell. ion. which maintains some of the myths around lie number two and adds. for good measure. a third lie - that the city and borough-wide federations were an insignificance. and that the involvement of political people. ic Militant sup porters was i hindrance to the BIRDS BOOK NEATIY divides the anti-poll tax movement into Io distinct parts: the whimpers of protest from the Labour leadership and other politicians and the grassroots based non-payment ordinary involving campaign people.

The one contribution this book

[page 33]

does make is in its tirst two chapters. where it outlines (albeit in a distorted way) the history of the pathetic protests of the official labour movement - the Stop It Campaign. Labour's Poll Tax Protest' and so on.

There is much here which the Labour leaders should not be allowed to forget. For example. Donald Dewar. Labour's Shadow Scottish Secretary: is quoted from September 1988: "This is a party that aspires to be in government... 1 dont believe such a party can afford sclective amnesia when it comes to the law of the land." But Donald Dewar was only hypothesising about selective amnesia'. Danny Burns, in the rest of the book, seems to have been inflicted with a particularly acute case of this handy illness. The overwhelming theme of the remainder of the book is to contrast "the big difference between those (APTI s) which were run by independent activists and many others... Which were dominated or controlled by political groups." (ic Militant - MC) In Burns' amnesia-ridden world. there were two distinct types of anti-poll tax unions. Firstly, there were the genuine: pure ones. communities' by ordinars run which were models of democracy and mass participation. Then there were the bad ones. run by nasty Wilitants who were obsessed with dominating things and with minutes, matters arising and treasurers reports. And never the tain shall meet!

He quotes from a number of activists throughout the book to try and uphold this division - probably the most damning' came from Edinburgh: "We had one member who was very officious and wanted everything done right. We couldn't quite see the point. We just wanted to get out there and fight the sherift officers." This quote came from Jackie Movers of Mayfield APTI' - what Burns' forgets to mention in his rush to tar Militant with the burcaucrats brush. is that Jackie is a Militant supporter, as is his wife Chris. who between them are the most quoted rank-and-file activists in the book!

WHILE BURNS MANAGES a few begrudging compliments about Militant early on ("Of all the Left groupings they had by far the strongest working class base": "they were the only part of the established labour movement who put forward i strategically coherent policy") they don't stop his obvious hatred of Marxism getting the better of him. Anything associated with Militant supporters is belittled. The People's March Against the Poll Tax was 'elitist'. Dave Nellist. who was the parliamentary spokesperson of the non-payment campaign and became known as the 'antipoll tax MP: doesn't even merit a mention.

The 200.000-strong March 31 1990 demonstration was "called by the non payment campaign" as though the one million leaflets and posters produced by the All- Britain Anti-Poll Tax Federation existed. Indeed. claims that the Federation was 'insignificant' and comes out in support of the Labour leadership's attack on it as a Wilitant front. In another fine display of selective amnesia' Burns forgets to mention that he stood for national secret- ary of this insignificant body for iwo years running!

Burns lays heavy emphasis (+0 out of 200 pages) on the Trafalgar Square riot and the demonstration at Brixton prison attacked by the police. Indeed. his book is pub lished by the same company which published Poll Tax Riot. which effectively argued that Tratalgar Square was the single most important event in the defeat of the poll tax. (The arguments in this pamphlet are dealt with in MIR No.+5) Burns' analysis comes straight from the anarchist tradition of He argues 'spontaneity. that "most of the successful Anti-Poll Tax I'nions operated on a principle of parallel development" Well. my APTU had over 1.000 members and was extremely successful, but we had never heard of this principle!

What it apparently means is that "sometimes strategies which appcar to be contradictory can actual- Iy reinforce each other". So "the actions of those who are not prepared to break the law were not undermined by (those) who chose to throw fire bombs... the occupations of the courts didn't prevent those who wanted to argue legal technicalities"! In other words. everyone could do whatever they like 'in the name of the Anti-Poll Tax Union' - so what was the point in discussing tactics, what was the point in the union or in mectings at all? This is basically an argument agamst democracy in a movement. Marxism is not a burcaucratic imposition drafted onto the strug gles of the working class. Rather. it is a method of utilising past strug gles (theory is nothing more than concentrated experience) for current battles.

Militant's role in the poll tax struggle was in this tradition. Our aim is not to stifle the immense hidden initiative and talent of workers in bureaucratic structures. On the contrary, the job of Marxists is to tap initiative and anger and give it coherent direct- 10n.

This approach is in contrast to those who argue for 'spontancity" and parallel derelopment. Directionless struggle is precisely that - it gets you nowhere Reading Danny Burns book feels a bit like getting nowhere. It's certainly nothing like a real history of the anti-poll tax movement.

← Big Boys' Rules: The Secret Struggle against the IRA, by Mark UrbanAfter the cold war →

Something wrong on this page?