[page 31]
Defeat from the Jaws of
Victory: Inside Kinnock's
Labour Party By Richard Heffernan anc
Mike Marqusee Published by Verso, 1992,
£11-95 Reviewed by Geoff Jones
FOUR-TIMES DEFEATED A parliamentary leadership trying to out-Tory the Tories; councils scared to raise a whisper of opposition to the destruction of jobs and services; a shrinking membership with an average age nearing • fifty; no national youth organisation, no womens' organisation, no party newspaper and no internal debate: this is the Labour Party today. How did it happen? Heffernan and Marqusee attempt an answer.
Their book falls into three roughly equal sections. The first, The fall and rise of the Labour right, outlines developments between the Tory victory of 1979 and the election of 1987.
The second, Kinnock in command, covers the way in which the party leadership, with the assistance of the Labour Co-ordinating Committee' (LCC), took over the party apparatus and set about 'reorganising, to ensure control from the top of all party activity. The third part discusses in more detail the party's aboutface on unilateralism and the purges of left-wingers which formed a prelude to the debacle of 1992.
As someone invol Labour Party at all levels during this period, I found the book generally factual and fair. One partial exception is the coverage of the struggles in the National Organisation of Labour Students (NOLS) and the Labour Party Young Socialists (LPYS) in the early 1980s. Heffernan and Marqusee do not emphasise strongly enough the 'police state' atmosphere which existed in NOLS, although they describe well the way in which these budding bureaucrats carried over into the trade unions and Labour Party the manipulative skills which they had developed in student politics.
On the other hand they quote, apparently without irony, that these gangsters tried to instil some democracy in the LPYS" (p172) One thing was certain about the LPYS. All regional and national bodies were run absolutely consitutionally and democratically. If they had not been, the party leadership, who had found the LPYS a thorn in their side since the 1970s, would have been very quick to close them down.
There are other Developments are almost always seen merely from a London perspective. Battles 'on the ground' outside London are ignored. The 1984-85 miners' strike receives less coverage than convulsions in Lambeth council chamber; the battles in Liverpool are hardly mentioned and, amazingly, for what was the greatest movement of mass revolt since the general strike, 'poll tax does not even figure in the index.
One is left with a feeling of inadequacy. To the question, 'why did Labour lose in 1992?, one receives an answer compounded of the intellectual and psychological inadequacies of Neil Kin- nock, the machinations of a few dozen members of the LCC, and the weaknesses of a handful of trade union leaders. Surely these cannot be adequate reasons for the implosion of a political party of a quarter of a million members, with social and political roots going back at least a century?
Why did the left-wingers' of the 1970s and early 1980s give up so easily? Heffernan and Marqusee quote numerous examples of left-wing firebrands such as Hewitt, Short, and Ruddock be-
[page 32]
coming tame right-wingers. But implication that this was their due to lust for power and the scent of patronage is inadequate. Those individuals were only the leaders of a stampede to the right up and down the country, in Town Halls and Labour Party GCs, where squatters' leaders transmutated into the fiercest employers of bailiffs, and longtime CND members gave support to 'our boys' in the Gulf.
Obviously, part of the answer lies in the objective political situation of the late 1980s and early 1990s: the defeat of the miners; the failure of Labour councils, with the exception of Liverpool, to stand up against central government; a background of an economic boom, however shaky; and the ideological assault against 'socialism' as Stalinism But the answer has to go deeper. On what programme did the majority of the left fight in the 1970s and 1980s? It is hard now to remember. Those impassioned arguments on 'indicative management and pump-priming, on import controls and the 'alternative economic strategy, on local empowerment and municipal socialism, on 'creative accounting and broad-based resistance, all seem from another epoch. The reason, of course, is that each of these in turn was found empty when a fighting strategy of opposition to the capitalism of the 1980s was required. All the various left' alternatives trumpeted in the pages of New Statesand Labour man, Tribune Briefing, were shown to be wanting.
For the whole period there was only one real alternative. In the Labour Party and trade unions, only Militant consistently pushed forward the unpalatable truth that to bring down the Tories would involve confronting them on the industrial plane, legally if possible but illegally where necessary.
To confront the ideological offensive which underpinned Tory policies meant confronting 'contalism with a programme of na-l tionalisation, state planning and democratic control of trade and industry. Putting forward such a programme based on Marxist ideas might have seemed visionary in the high noon of the Tory boom. Now, with the ruins of British capitalism even apparent to the Tories, it represents the only programme on offer for the working class. No wonder that, more than any other group in the labour movement, Militant supporters have been the subject of hatred and loathing by the right-wing, and, it must be added, dislike by many remaining leftwingers.
History is a guide for the future. Defeat from the Jaws of Victory provides a good picture of the who are now in control types of the Labour Party and a useful record of their background. But it provides only a limited perspective for the future development of the Labour Party. The present leadership will continue the destruction of the party rather than give up power. A process of regeneration can only begin from a return to the socialist values and perspective that inspired the founders of the labour movement.