The Welfare State in Britain since 1945 By Rodney Lowe Published by Macmillan, 1993, £10-99 Reviewed by Mike Waddington • Aprl), April, soda seco VER THE WEEKEND of minister Peter Lilley and his team retreated to Chevening in Kent. This private country residence is where ideas to 'shake up' the social security system were to be brainstormed'. These included whether benefits should be withdrawn if private insurance was available for the claimant and the question of universal child benefit being targeted' to those who really need it - despite the fact that it has been frozen in value for many years. Tarcollapsed. capigeting usually involves means tests, which are generally used to prevent people claiming when they find out that a benefit is available. In the 1970s 50% of those entitled didn't claim supplementary benefit and 60% didn't claim FIS or even rent rebates. The Labour Party's Commission set up by on Social Justice, John Smith, is itself looking at the benefit system and apparently considering diverting child benefit into child care to 'allow' mothers to work. David Blunkett's proposals on workfare are now well known. A new 'we can't afford the welfare state' consensus between the parties is thus being created.
Rodney Lowe's book analyses the history of the welfare state. He concentrates on its heyday (up to 1975), when another sensus' existed in favour of welfare reforms: on Labour's part as apparent steps to equality (the Labour leader Gaitskell said in 1956, "If you don't feel strongly about equality, then I think it is very hard to be a genuine socialist, and if we were to abandon this, then I think there would be very little to distinguish us from the Tories"), and on the Tory side, the minimum necessary measures to maintain social stability.
This consensus was always underpinned by economic growth, so when growth slowed, counter reforms were brought in. In 1951, for example, Labour brought in charges for glasses and false teeth. Just after the 1951 general election the new Tory government proposed raising the school entry age and lowering the leaving
[page 33]
age, to save money.
However, there can be no doubt at all that the welfare state benefited millions of working class the operpeople by suspending ation of the unfettered market, particularly in areas such as health, housing, education and jobs. In fact the Beveridge report (produced during world war two) specifically said, "Experience has shown... that under modern conditions this process of self recovery (of the economy - MW), if effective at all, is likely to be extremely prolonged and to be accompanied by widespread distress, particularly in a complex society like our own".
There is a slightly daft section to this book where there is a thankfully brief discussion about Marxism' and whether the revolution' was helped or hindered by the welfare state, tending towards the caricature of the for everyone the better worse for the Marxists, a nonsense pedalled by academics or right wing Labour politicians to damage the Marxists.
The welfare state, however, did not bring about fundamental change. The bottom 50% of people had 23.7% of income in 1949 and this increased to 24.3% in 1975-76. I discovered from the book something known as the "Gini Coefficient', which denotes greater equality as it declines towards zero, which only fell from 41.1 to 36.6 over the same period.
More importantly, the number of people in poverty increased on the minimum measurements from 600,000 in 1953 i to at least two million by 1964. Brian Abel-Smith and Peter Townsend produced a report in 1965 that showed that 40% of the poor (nearly three million then) were the working poor and up to 1976 the rule was that if you lost your job you had to wait for a when benefit was paid it had to be no more than your last wage even where that was below the poverty line! The Child Poverty Action Group and Shelter were formed in response to this
In 1941 social security was adopted in the Atlantic Charter by the Allies as a war aim. Copies of the Beveridge Report were dropped by bombers on British troops to bolster morale. The confidence of the capitalists had also been severely battered by the depression of the 1930s. T WAS THE economic crisis of 1974 which broke the growth of the welfare state. It was the last Labour prime minister James Callaghan who abandoned full employment as a policy and further cut deeply into social spending. This was primarily aimed at saving money. Thatcher and the 'new right' , however, whilst wanting to save money, also wanted to shift resources to the better off. It sounds incredible but even in the 1970g the top 20% of earners used more of the free facilities in the education sector and NHS than the bottom 20% (respectively three times and two thirds as much). This was developed further by Thatcher not only with tax cuts but through mortgage relief; some £5bn a year now of which £3bn goes to people who earn more than £20,000 a year. It's worth remembering that the Council of Europe's Decency Threshold is £5-52 an hour or £11,500 a year for a 40 hour week: 46% of all employees earn less than that. The Low Pay Unit recently took up the case of a group who earned 67 pence This book is a very good description of what happened. In particular it graphically demonstrates the break of 1975 and the development of the 'new right'. The poll tax gets a brief mention (twenty words actually) which Lowe says contributed to Thatcher's fall. He follows this up with the comment "the public appeared uninterested" over unemployment, failing to see that it is the inadequacies of the official opposition' to the new right that fails to address the real concerns of people. Or as Harry S Truman said to his party, if you put up a own republican to defeat a republican lean ve surprised if the repub. lican wins.