Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Chancellor cooks the books

No. 715, 7 September 1984 · p. 6 of the scan · 377 words

The scan: Militant 715 1984-09-07.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 4.3x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 6]

estimated costs arising from this year's mining; rather it is the historical legacy of past coal mining operations.

Another major item is £130 million of pensions and other payments to retired miners. In no sense can a pension paid to a retired miner, or compensation to people whose houses suffer subsidence damage, be regarded as costs of getting out coal now. Certainly they "siso elbo's.

Again, they are not a cost Considering all this how can come up with a figure of £20 as the cost of the strike?

First of all he is concerned only with the cost to the government (NCB and other nationalised industry losses, lost tax revenue from miners, social security and costs of policing).

It is not surprising that he does not bother to count the cost of the strike to miners and other workers, preferring not to see the miners as part of society at all. But still Lawson possibly million per week his figure is only one-third of that suggested by Simon and Coates.

Their explanation is that he has not counted the cost of running down coal stocks as a cost at all. His 'cash flow' estimate of the government's costs is no real guide to the true cost to the government, let alone to the real cost to the country which is at least five times his figure.

The government has been cooking the books on the balance of payments as well. Whilst Tebbit told the House of Commons that the effect of the strike was "minimal" Simon and Coates reckon the extra coal and oil imports as "at least £237 million per month, without making any allowance for higher imports in other industries such as steel. There appears no way that these estimates can be squared with the government's own indications of the strike's losses".

The government likes to pretend that the costs of the strike are a modest investment required to reorganise an insolvent industry. In fact it is imposing massive costs in lost production and higher priced oil. These average out at around f2 per week for each person in the country. Even looked at in narrow financial terms workers are paying an enormous cost for the government's attempt to smash the NUM.

← NCB fraud exposed Extra costs of Tory attackSirs' 'solidarity-truth about steel output →

Something wrong on this page?