[page 6]
MANTA T ANDREW GLYN exposes Tory lies about ANDREW GLYN exposes Tory lies about the cost of producing coal on the basis of the cost of producing coal on the basis of the NCB's own accounts (below left).
Below he indicates some of the costs of the strike which the government conceals.
Accounting for subsidies AS PART of its propagan- "only" £300 - £400 million.
NUM, the government has are entirely misleading. The quoted huge figures for the NCB is not bankrupt and the amount of 'subsidy' it pays cost of the strike is many Two other costs of the strike which the Tories should take responsibility for.
This analysis (left) shows that proaction of coal last year did now require any government subsidy at all. The value of coal produced, '"Operating losses" sounds as though it means the ex- some £4,150 million, more than paid the cess of the costs of producing coal over the NCB's miners and for the cost of the imputs actualrevenue from sales. Yet included here are a number of items which are not costs of production at all •Social costs is the next chunk of "subsidy" • These are "costs in respect of the closure of uneconomic capacity or redundancy of employees which are wholly or partly met by government grants"
Interest payments is the final item which has to be "subsidised" by the government. This represents £467 million (£400 million of which goes straight back to and Accounts da campaign against the to tha anal inductro Dator tim Lo me coal muusuy. rever Walker. the Energy Secretary, said that the taxpayer contributed £1.3 billion last year, or nearly £130 per week for each miner.
If the NCB really is "insolvent" ', as he alleged" it is not surprising to hear Chancellor of the Exchequer Lawson claiming that the cost of the industry not working during the strike is 'Operating losses The biggest of these is £245 million of provision for payments for •surface damage", the costs of meeting claims for subsidence in mining areas. The near doubling of this item in 1983/84 reflects a rush of claims in the Mansfield area. But it does not reflect the In fact both these figures unes greater inan ine government admits The government. "subsidy" for 1983 covered the NCB's operating losses (£358 million), its interest payments (£467 million) and around £500 million of "social costs". The accounts for 1983 - 84 allow each of these items to be considered in turn.
W VE PIVMULLIVA have to be paid but there is no reason why they should be met (via high prices or worse wages) by those who now use coal or produce it. It is perfectly fair for the taxpayer (via government grants) to cover these payments; in no sense does this make them a subsidy to the production of coal.
These two items more than account for the NCB's operating loss. If they are left out then the NCB made an operating profit in 1983/84. And, but for the £200 million or so effect of the strike and the overtime ban, the NCB would even have financed practically all of its £698 million investment programme out of its own revenue. (see my article in Militant no. 705) They do not, as the NCB's accounting suggests, represent an additional charge making the existing pits less economic, thus seeming to justify more closures. double the corresponding rate of profit. in private manufacturing industry in recent years. So this part of the "subsidy" is mainly paid by the government itself. It gives itself an inflated rate of profit and the NCB an inflated loss.
BIANI ly used in coal production. It is the loss of coal production, put by the NCB at some 1.7 million tonnes per week, worth some £73 million, which is the biggest cost of the strike. This is not the end of the story, for the reduction in the take-home pay of miners, and those in industries supplying inputs into mining must amount to some £20 million per week.
Their reduced spending must lead to reduced production in industries making the consumer goods they would otherwise be buying. In addition the NCB is foreJCB ed to postpone part of its investment programme (which was running at f14 million per week) which again means a fall in the output of the construction industry and others involved. So leaving aside any eftects on the production of steel, from fuel and ore shortages, it is likely that the total cost of the strike in terms of lost production is running at around £100 million per week. Finally the CEGB is using more expensive oil in its power stations, reckoned by stockbrokers Simon and Coates to be costing an additional £18 million per week as compared with using coal. This cost too will eventually have to be borne, probably by electricity users in higher prices, and this must be added to the loss in production to reach the total cost. This total must be well over £100 million per week, and probably as much as £120 million.
----- pull-quotes -----
NCB Photo: Jon Ingham