Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Scabbing for Britain?

No. 716, 14 September 1984 · pp. 4-5 of the scan · 355 words

The scan: Militant 716 1984-09-14.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 5.3x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 4]

" 'SCABS' of the worId unite" said the Financial Times in an article by Samuel Brittan, right wing economist and brother of the Home Secretary, last week.

This normally sober and restrained journal of big business has let the mask slip briefly, to reveal the crude anti-union mentality and class interests of monetarism. Brittan's article provides more good reasons for the TUC's decision to give total support to the miners than many of the speeches at Congress. In particular it shows this is not just a struggle by the miners to defend their jobs and communities, but a fight on behalf of all workers who are organised in trade unions. Brittan aims to demonstrate that the defeat of any strike by scabs helps to push down the living standards of workers as a whole. "Scabs" he says, are "people offering themselves for work at below going pay rates, or who will forgoe a pay rise for which a union is struggling"

### Drag down

wages A victory for scabs therefore means means lower wages, and "a net rise in the share of national income going to capital is thus possible" —in other words more money in the pockets of the capitalist class that the Brittan brothers belong to. This, he maintains, will mean more jobs, since these scabs who "price themselves into work" will drag wages down to a level at which the capitalists find it profitable to invest by exploiting this cheap labour.

Quite apart from the fact that workers, even the unemployed, are not prepared to work at any price, but rightly demand a decent wage, Brittan's idea is an illusion. It totally ignores the history of British capitalism over a period of decades, when despite wages falling below those in nearly every other country in Western Europe, the bosses have refused to invest their profits back into industry. The extra money gained by the lowering of wages will, as in the past, be used to increase shareholders' dividends or to make even more money for themselves through speculative investment in property or banking.

[page 5]

14 September 1984 MILITANT 5,

← Fiddling the books againSave Scotland's pits →

Something wrong on this page?