Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

Fiddling the books again

No. 716, 14 September 1984 · p. 4 of the scan · 505 words

The scan: Militant 716 1984-09-14.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 4.9x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 4]

APART FROM the factors considered above, acounts can be manipulated in a more tangible way.

For example, breakdown of coal output reveals considerable variation in productivity: in South Wales, only 1.57 tonnes per worker per shift, compared to a national average of 2.43. Clear evidence of "uneconomic pits"? No, a breakdown of major capital projects currently in progress (this is the only breakdown of investment given in the NCB accounts) shows that of £1,297 million already spent on such projects only f4 million has been spent in the South Wales area, 0.3% of the total, although it produces 6.5% of the coal-twenty times as much.

Small wonder productivity is below average! It is quite likely that the NCB has simply decided to close down most, if not all the South Wales pits. So the area has been deliberately starved of investment (as the South Wales NUM has protested for several years. The resulting low productivity then "proves" how "uneconomic" the pits are, and how necessary it is to close them.

Much attention in the propaganda war is devoted to the long suffering tax-payer, whose money is, you see, being used to subsidise the miners' high living.

Apart from the fact that the alleged subsidies are fictitious as demonstrated above, this conveniently overlooks the fact that miners are taxpayers too, and rather hefty ones at that, in terms of National Insurance and income tax deductions from wages, which are paid over to the government.

In theory income tax deducted, for instance, is a tax on income and has nothing to do with the mining industry as such; in practice, it constitutes a government levy on revenue generated in the industry by its workers. Indeed, some accountants have argued for financial statements to be presented in this way, showing social security and income taxes as part of the government's "take" from value added in an industry, rather than as a cost to be deducted in arriving at profit.

The NCB accounts do not give precise figures, but it is probable that over £700 million was paid to the government in the year-an average of £55 per week per employee. So who is subsidising whom?

The last people to gain any benefit would be the unemployed. After all, the capitalists know that without a pool of unemployed they cannot hope to find the scabs to break the unions.

Political economy Brittan has revealed in a brutally honest way the thinking of the capitalist strategists. They want to see the miners defeated not only to get "uneconomic" pits closed down, but in order to deal a crushing blow to the trade union movement, and a victory for his beloved scabs. As he regretfully admits to himself, "crossing a picket line or breaking strike still carries a stigma".

That is because every picket line crossed and every strike broken weakens the whole body of the labour movement, and that is why support for the miners, in action as well as in words, is so vital for every worker.

← The other NCB accounts 'Subsidies'Scabbing for Britain? →

Something wrong on this page?