[page 4]
A FEATURE BY SEAN MACARTNEY The Tories constantly appeal to economic commonsense" and the facts of life, which they maintain are reflected in official documents such as the Coal Board accounts. In reality these are distorting mirrors, and the view they give is governed as much by the outlook, assumptions and policies of those who THE PROGRAMME of pit closures is justified In this case (below) the accounts have been drawn by the government with reference to the finanup according to "directives issued by the Secretary of cial losses recently sustained by the mining inState" (ie the government) so perhaps it isn't surpris- dustry, losses due to a minority of high cost ing that they tell the government what it wants to hear. "uneconomic pits" which have to be closed to The alternative profit and loss account (right) shows how different a picture can be produced-solely from information given by the NCB itself.
A whole bus for ONE scab at Markham pit in Derbyshire. Striking miners will not be impressed by Samuel Brittan's glorificaprepare them as by the facts. NCB Profit and Loss Account for the year to 31 March, SALES Raw material and consumable Employee and pension co Other operating OPERATING Interest Other items TOTAL LOSS for NCB Account 1984 Em 4,660 (947)
2,430)
,641)
(358)
(467)
(50)
(875) Alternative for the y SALES Wages Income Machinery and assets written Less: Redundancy costs etc Government interest Tax and SS 'Loss' NCB sar e and Salaries Tax and SS Raw materials and consumable stores Other operating costs OPERATING PROFIT to NCB accounts as Pensions Subsidence dam Miscellaneous (ir non-government for NCB Profit and Loss ided 31 March other off age clain Iclu ding inte irest) 99• ,601 (947)
(358) (129) (245)
(38)
02)
(875) make the others viable.
Without this contraction, they say, the industry will not be competitive and will continue to be a drain on public funds. The National Coal Board's accounts for the year to March 1984, published a few weeks ago and revealing a loss of £875 million appear to lend colour to these assertions.
A careful reading of the NCB accounts completely demolishes these claims and reveals a completely different picture. At first sight it seems quite clear: the NCB's expenses (miners' wages, machinery, etc) are greater than• income from selling coal and the difference has to be mae up by somebody else (the taxpayer). But it's not that simple. As Andrew Glyn showed in Militant last week the government's claim that it subsidises the production of coal does not stand up to detailed examination.
Loans as cost In the first place over halt the NCB loss is accounted for by interest payments, of £467 million, mostly due to government loans. Such payments represent, in reality, the return to the government on capital invested in the industry as sole "shareholder" in the NCB, ie profit. Treating the payments as a cost to be deducted in arriving at profit is completely misleading. It is entirely the result of political decisions about funding of the NCB; it has nothing to do with the economic realities of mining coal.
It is equally absurd to treat as a subsidy to coal production the cost of pit closures. Yet the accounts include £344 million in "social Sutton B87 LamStion of scabbing. costs" associated with closures (mostly redundancy payments) and a further £189 million was paid directly by the government. So at least £533 million, 40% of all the £1,334 million "subsidy", is not the cost of producing coal at all, but the cost of not producing coal by closing pits. Yet the Tories propose to cut this "subsidy" by closing more pits!
### Pensions
Even allowing for these items, however, the NCB accounts show an operating loss" of £358 million. The meaning of this seems absolutely clear-but again is misleading because many of the so-called operating costs are really nothing of the kind. Included in this category is £130 million paid to former miners (mainly pensions to those retired or made redundant) in no sense a current operating cost.
Another "cost" of producing coal turns out to be £245 million paid out in compensation to those suffering from subsidence caused by mining operations.
Of course, the damage caused by subsidence is real enough, but almost by definition the costs involved are nothing to do with producing coal today, they are the result of past mining operations and would have to be met even if all the pits involved were closed immediately; indeed, it is frequently the closure of a pit, and the conseqent decay of the shafts which produces the damage. In many cases the workings causing problems are very old and have been closed for years— before nationalisation in some cases.