[page 9]
Led enthaustically the utterly pessimistic and false ideas of Professor Hobsbawm.
According to the latter the Trade Unions had been irretrievably weakened. The working class had been seduced by videos and cars and away from the ideas of class struggle and socialism. Labour was therefore faced with a long decline.
Marxism, in the words of Trotsky, shows "the advantage of foresight over astonishment" .Militant has answered Hobsbawm's arguments many times, predicting a colossal outbreak of class struggle, including the possibility of a miners' strike. It is the crisis of this system that demands that the Tories attempt to defeat the miners as a means of driving down the living standards of the working class.
The terrible long term crisis of British capitalism will also confront a new Labour Government. Those who predict that Labour will never be returned in a General Election, including the author of this book, completely fail to understand the enormous reaction of working people to the ferocity of the Thatcher onslaught.
These sages point out that Labour will need to capture 143 seats in the next election, which is "a virtually unassailable" target. However, they fail to see the colossal swings in opinion that now take place in Britain which itself is a reflection of the economic, social and thereby political instability which now exists.
In Spain we have seen an enormous swing towards the Socialist Party since the demise of the Franco dictatorship in 1975. In Greece we have seen a virtual quadrupling in the support for PASOK the socialist party, since 1974. In France 3 years ago we saw the victory of the Socialist and Communist Party with more than 55% of the vote.
In a much shorter period the working class of Britain, moving from the industrial plane on to the political plane, will direct their energy and their attention towards he return of a new Labor Government. The Tory Party w se shattered in the period that v are going into, not only in tl Vorth, but also in the alleged sc South"
The SDP will be ground betwe he mill-stones of a revived Laboi novement and a rightwards mo ng Tory Party. The Liberals w ›e preserved perhaps as a litt efuge for disenchanted Tories.
### Swing to Labour
It is therefore most likely that there will be a swing back to Labour and a return of a new Labour Government, although a new witch-hunt could cut across this prospect.
Can Neil Kinnock satisfy the demands and aspirations of working people? With the fresh experience of the Mitterand Government in France, of the Gonzales Government in Spain, and the Papandreou Government in Greece, the ruling class do not now fear the coming to power of Socialist Parties which have pledged that they will remain within the framework of capitalism.
A future Labour Government which did not carry through a fundamental change would come under the remorseless pressure of capitalism to carry through counter-reforms on a more devastating scale than 74-79. At a very early stage the capitalists would attempt to split a Labour Government, pressurising some right-wing figure, possibly even Neil Kinnock himself, to stab Labour in the back and form a new version of the National Government of 1931.
If there are any lessons to be learnt from this book it is that only by the adoption of a clear socialist policy can Labour avoid a catastrophe in the future. ANY BIOGRAPHY of Neil Kinnock and its subsequent reviews would be bound to feature the Party leader's support for the expulsion of the editorial board of Militant.
Part of the campaign to discredit Militant at the time was an attempt to distort the ideas of Marxism and to cloud the political issues with a smokescreen of lies and innuendo about the activities of the paper's supporters.
A review of Robert Harris' biography of Neil Kinnock, in last week-end's Sunday Express, manages not only to repeat one of the worst allegations, made by Neil Kinnock himself, but by cleverly presenting it alongside quite separate events appears to make it worse.
Graham Lord (Sunday Express, September 16) writes of Kinnock: "He has had threats to his life and his property. His door has been kicked in. An opponent once pulled a gun on him on his own doorstep. And Kinnock claims members of Militant have stuck dead rats through his letterbox.
" 'Kinnock, as his wife says, both gets very angry himself and makes other people angry in return', says Harris.
The references to Kinnock's "angry" character appear on page 68 of the biography. The story about the door being kicked in and the gun are both on page 102 where the biographer is dealing quite explicitly with opposition to Kinnock from Welsh Nationalists.
Tucked in between these two-and from page 175-is the reference to "members of Militant'. • Thus by their association together, Militant is not only linked with allegations about dead rats, but also to doors being kicked in and threats with a deadly weapon.
But what about the "dead rats" allegations?
This outburst took place at a GMC meeting in December 1981 when Bedwellty CLP was discussing three resolutions on NEC actions: the refusal of Party membership to Tariq Ali; the refusal to endorse Peter Tatchell in Bermondsey and the decision to set up an enquiry into "Militant tendency"
According to Robert Harris, GMC member and Militant supporter Terry Burns heard Neil Kinnock shout, "I know what they're like. They once stuck a dead rat and a used sanitary towel through my door. " Another GMC member also claims to have heard Kinnock make the remark. One Neil Kinnock at the Durham Miners' hunt will not be easily forgotten.
delegate, another Militant supporter, burst into tears. " 'My brother Tony asked him point blank if he was suggesting we'd done it,' says Terry Burns. 'Kinnock denied it. There was absolute uproar. He'd gone way over the top.' "
In other words there was never at any time the slightest bit of evidence to give substance to Kinnock's wild allegations that night...but it has not stopped Public Meeting PAST BE TOMSAI BOARD Maitant/ Gala, Photo: Militant the gutter press from repeating them since.
As for the membership of Bedwellty GMC, they also thought their MP had gone "way over the top". On the first two resolutions, the NEC and the position of Neil Kinnock were endorsed. On the vote on the Militant enquiry, "perhaps as a result of his outburst about dead rats", he was defeated by 22 votes to 18.
[page 10]
Chile, Mexico, France 10 MILITANT 21 September 1984
----- pull-quotes -----
EXPEL THE TORIES NOT THE SOCIALISTS A NC-INSTATE THE FIVE