Militant International Review Archive

The theoretical journal of the Militant tendency, 1969–1995

The making of

No. 717, 21 September 1984 · pp. 8-9 of the scan · 1,736 words

The scan: Militant 717 1984-09-21.pdf (PDF, opens at this page)

Uncorrected machine reading. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR, cell by cell) from the scan and has not been corrected. Expect misread words and titles. Quote from the scan, not from this page.
How this article was cut and titled: headline found in OCR geometry at 15.0x body type, 1 line(s), left edges within 0.000.

[page 8]

MANY Labour Party members were appalled MANY Labour Party members were appalled By this kind of speech, Neil Kinnock not only By this kind of speech, Neil Kinnock not only at the speech made by Neil Kinnock at TUC fails to support miners fighting for their jobs at the speech made by Neil Kinnock at TUC fails to support miners fighting for their jobs Congress when he condemned "picket and communities, he gives full credence to the violence". In fact from the very beginning of vicious press smears against the this historic strike miners have been disturb- mineworkers. He unwittingly gives succour to ed at the Labour leader's hesitations and all those newspapers and Tories calling for equivocations on the issue, which his TUC judicial vengeance in the form of hefty prison sentences and fines on the many miners unAfter he had given a rousing defence of the Even before TUC Neil Kinnock' s standing coal industry and the case for sustaining the among miners was damaged by his statement pits and their communities, he launched into a long tirade implicity denouncing miners' made last year, only recently publicised, to the effect that Arthur Scargill was destroying the pickets: "But we must put that case without violence", he said " ...violence distracts attention from the central issues of the dispute... No doubt at the forthcoming Labour Party conference many delegates will comment on violence has given the government its only the record of the Hattersley-Kinnock leaderbone of excuse to gnaw on... violence... ship elected only a year ago. Their leaders' disgusts opinion and divides union attitudes behaviour in the miners' strike will be seen by ... it provides opportunities to our enemies."

many workers as being especially significant, Thus Kinnock himself provided a marvellous perhaps a pointer to their stance in future "opportunity to the enemy' by his own speech. There were no ringing denunciations As a contribution to that discussion, in the of police violence, or the curtailment of civil run-up to the Party conference, Peter Taffe, liberties, no pounding the table over the editor of Militant, here reviews a recent harassment and intimidation of striking biography of Neil Kinnock, giving some insight miners. Not surprisingly the press had a field into the Labour leader's background and 'Honourable gentlemen opposite have bemoaned picketing If they had been on strike for 5 weeks, if their families' total income was £7 a week Social Security benefits, if they were worried about smoking their next cigarette, if they were worried about paying the rent, and they saw some cowboy coming along driving a bald-tyred wagon without a road-fund licence, what would their reaction be?

"What would be the instinct of any red blooded man in the House, having put his family to all that inconvenience and near misery, if he saw somebody riding roughshod over his picket line? I know what my attitude would be. In fact I should be worried if it were not the case."

'Honourable gentlemen opposite have bemoaned picketing. If they had been on strike for 5 weeks, if their families' total income was £7 a week... and they saw some cowboy coming along driving a bald-tyred wagon without a road-fund licence, what would their reaction be?' - Neil Kinnock speech seemed only to confirm.

day.

These are not the words of some 'wild eyed' supporter of Militant. It is Neil Kinnock answering Tory charges during the 1972 miners strike about "violent picketing".

Similar statements which flatly contradict Neil Kinnock's more recent utterances are contained in a biography The making of Neil Kinnock written by journalist Robert Harris.

### Moved right

The book shows in some detail just how far to the right Neil Kinnock moved on becoming Labour leader. While it fails to give any adequate explanation as to the objective basis which allowed Neil Kinnock to rise to the leadership of the Labour Party, it is very good in describing what, to say the least, is the inconsistency of the man.

It shows that one of the individuals responsible for Kinnock becoming MP for Bedwellty was a long standing Militant supporter, Terry Burns. This comrade as well as other Militant supporters were rewarded with Kinnock's support for the expulsion of the Militant Editorial Board from the Labour Party.

According to the author, the leader of the Labour Party is now scathing about ambitious young men and women who try to get into Parliament: "when I meet kids at universities today who say they intend 'to make a career' in politics I want to kick their arses. People who think of politics as 'a career' are repulsive"

Every genuine socialist within the Labour movement would echo struggles.

politics.

### ROBERTHARRIS

The making of Neil Kinnock By Robert Harris. Faber and Faber : £4.95 paperback such sentiments. However his wife Glenys is quoted as confirming •Neil always wanted to be an MP. We used to talk about it at University". • Three years out of college, Neil was selected in one of the safest Labour seats in South Wales.

The book details his chequered history both in relation to policy and on the key question of the democratisation of the Labour Party. Like many previous Party leaders he has attacked "capitalism". He denounced the spending cuts announced by the Wilson Government in 1975, commenting to his Constituency Party in Bedwellty "it was not the task of Labour to salvage and reestablish capitalism." justly arrested in the last six months.

coal industry single-handed.

That white paper was, he said, one of the most reactionary ever to be introduced by a Labour government. It was "too much to take"

However, when he was offered a job as Education spokesman by Callaghan after the defeat of Labour in the 1979 general election there was a remarkable transformation in Neil Kinnock's public stance on Labour's policy. Robert Harris explains that the reason for his promotion was that "above all, he (Callaghan) was in desperate need of a left winger to help placate radical critics in the Party."

To the delight of the right-wing "the former scourge of Healy and the IMF now warned MPs (in 1980) that it would be 'hopelessly dishonest" to promise full restoration of the cuts which he said could amount to £10,000 million by the time of the next general election" He repeated this before his own General Management Committee which provoked resolutions condeming him.

This Volte Face of Neil Kinnock was but one of many that are outlined in this book. Thus, he supported the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy. (CLPD) while contriving at one and the same time to be, mostly in secret, opposed to mandatory re-selection!

In the tradition of many who started off on the left he gained a position on the National Executive Committee by supporting the demands of the Tribune left within the Party. Once having gained that position he evolved towards the right at a speed which astonished his Tribune friends.

Poverty of reformism However, the Marxists were not taken unawares by this development. The history of the labour movement is littered with many examples of former left-wingers, many far to the left of Neil Kinnock even in his most left phase, who subsequently ended up on the right of the Party.

McDonald started off as a Left and ended by stabbing the labour movement in the back in 1931. Harold Wilson was originally a Bevanite with impeccable left-wing credentials. So were the infamous Woodrow Wyatt and Reg Prentice. Both ended up as extreme rightwingers but started off as Tribune supporters!

Their degeneration is not at all due to whatever personal deficiencies they have. Reformism by its very nature is contemptuous of theory. It cannot comprehend that capitalism is in capable of giving lasting concessions to the working class.

It has failed to take on board that it is the irreversible decline of British capitalism which explains the ferocity of the Thatcher Government's attacks on all the past conquests of the British working class. "Violence distracts attention from dispute... violence disgusts opinion. our enemies"

In the long term reformism will prepare a disaster for the labour movement. Neil Kinnock, on becoming leader, was extended an enormous fund of good will by the rank and file of the Party. However, in clinging to the myth that lasting improvements are possible within the confines of British capitalism, he could suffer the same fates as previous leaders of the Labour Party.

Some started out on the left but ended up, contrary to all their original expectations, as loyal props of capitalism. Kinnock denounces the "kindly capitalism" of the SDP. But the logic of his position is precisely to seek to render capitalism "more humane and less ferocious" in its attacks on the living standards of working people.

His rightward shift even before becoming leader evoked hosanahs from the most vicious right-wing spokesman within the Labour Party. Thus the arch right-wing Witchhunter General, John Golding, confessed during the leadership campaign: "I think I shall vote for Kinnock. He inspires confidence. I think he will make it all the way to Downing Street"

Neil Kinnock also earned the plaudits of Frank Chapple. And yet the right-wing were the architects of Labour's catastrophic 1979 and 1983 election defeats.

This book reminds us of the ineptitude, bordering on outright sabotage, which emanated from these circles in the run up to the 1983 Election. Thus we had the pulping of leaflets printed on the February 1972 the central issues of the .. it provides opportunities to -Neil Kinnock September 1984 press which prints the Militant during the Bermondsey by-election.

Most Labour workers are familar with this incident. But what is not so well known is that the party's eve of poll leaflet in the General Election was so bad that one regional office of the Labour Party received 80,000 but refused to distribute them. Instead, they handed them over to a couple of local unemployed men who set up a paper recycling business. One full time offical stated "our biggest contribution to the 1983 election was to save a tree".

However, the erratic zig-zags which Neil Kinnock has described in his political career would be of mere passing interest if he had now learnt from past mistakes. Yet as we have detailed in the Militant, in the wake of the 1983 General Election, he and many others embrac- Neil Kinnock 1984

[page 9]

← Learning Liverpool's lessonsDead rats, a gun and a door kicked in →

Something wrong on this page?